Citation
Responding to trauma

Material Information

Title:
Responding to trauma how presidential discourses reshape the dialogues of healing
Creator:
McWilliams, Kelsie Marie ( author )
Language:
English
Physical Description:
1 electronic file (113 pages). : ;

Subjects

Subjects / Keywords:
Speeches, addresses, etc., American ( lcsh )
Genre:
bibliography ( marcgt )
theses ( marcgt )
non-fiction ( marcgt )

Notes

Review:
Though national traumas span everything from mass shootings to natural disasters, presidential responses have largely remained the same, following rather formulaic conventions in order to console and comfort the American people. Much of the previous literature on the rhetoric of trauma examines the process of healing and what it means to heal from trauma, though these definitions are often narrow and impose unrealistic expectations onto survivors. Additionally, both presidential rhetoric and trauma rhetoric neglect that others are often juggling multiple exigencies, including campaigning and political advocacy, when responding to a disaster. This thesis examines how President Barack Obama has responded to various tragedies throughout his presidency. I analyze his responses to the following events: the Aurora theater shooting, Superstorm Sandy, and the Boston Marathon bombing.
Thesis:
Thesis (M.A.)--University of Colorado Denver.
Bibliography:
Includes bibliographic references.
General Note:
Department of English
Statement of Responsibility:
Kelsie Marie McWilliams.

Record Information

Source Institution:
University of Colorado Denver
Rights Management:
All applicable rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.
Resource Identifier:
900877455 ( OCLC )
ocn900877455

Downloads

This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

! "#$%&'()'*!+&!+",-.,/ ! 0&1!%"#$)(#'+),2!()$3&-"$#$!"#$0,%#!+0#!(),2&*-#$!&4!0#,2)'* ! 56 ! 7#2$)#!.,")#!.31)22),.$ 89,9:!-;<=>?@;=>?:!GHIG ! ! ! ! ,!AJ>@<@!@K5LF!AB!AJ> 4EMKDA6!BC!AJ>!*?EFKEA>!$MJBBD!BC!AJ> ! -;<=>?@;A ! BC!AJ>!?>OKL>;A@!CB?!AJ>!F>P?>>!BC! .E@A>?!BC!,?A@ #;PD<@J GHIQ !

PAGE 2

<< ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! R!GHI Q 7#2$)#!.,")#!.31)22),.$ ,22!")*0+$!"#$#"S#( !

PAGE 3

<<< ! ! +J<@!AJ>@<@!CB?!AJ>!.E@A>?!BC!,?A@!F>P?>>!56 7>D@<>!.E?<>!.M1>;!ENN?B=>F!CB?!AJ> (>NE?AL>;A!BC!#;PD<@J 56 ! ,L6!S6!0>??<;P .DD>!3BL@ ABMT ! .E6!IU :!GHIQ ! ! !

PAGE 4

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

;M<>@ :!<;MDKF<;P!MELNE;!?>@NB;F<;P!AB!E!F<@E@A>? 9 .6!AJ>@<@!>YEL<;> @ JBX!%?>@;A!8E?EMT! &5ELE!JE@!?>@NB;F>F!AB!=E?F<>@!AJ?BKPJBKA!J<@!N?>@;M69!) E;ED6[>! J<@! ?>@NB;@>@!AB!AJ>!CBDDBX<;P!>=>;A@/!AJ >!,K?B?E!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P:!$KN>?@AB?L!$E;F6:! E;F! AJ>! 8B@AB;!.E?EAJB;!5BL5<;P 9 ! +J>!CB?L!E;F!MB;A>;A!BC!AJ<@!E5@A?EMA!E?>!ENN?B=>F9!)!?>MBLL>;F!F/!,L6!S
PAGE 5

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

PAGE 6

=< $!",-'*1'&*)$-)$# 30,%+#" )9 )'+"&(-3+)&'!,'(!"#S)#1!&4!+0#!2)+#",+-"# 99999999999999999999999999999999 999999999999999999999 I ">=<>X!BC!AJ>!2
?EAK?> 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9999999999999999999999999999999 +6N>@!BC!+?EKLE 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999 ` 4EMED<;P 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9999999 a )@@K>@!BC!">N?>@>;AEA@@!E;F!$N>>MJ>@ 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 999999999999999 IG .>F?EP> 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9999 IQ +J>!0BDBMEK@A 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9999999 Ib 3?>EA<;P!3BLLK; 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9999 GI %>FEPBP<>@!BC!+?EKLE 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 G` %?>@;AAB?@;A@NB;@>!AB!(<@E@A>? 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999 QI &5ELE!"J>AB??<;P!.6!(EAE 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999 _G ,;ED6[<;P!AJ>!(EAE 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 999999 _Q .>AJBFBDBPAB?!.E<;A>;E;M> 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9999 `I ">@AB?E A<=>!"J>AB?AJBF 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999 `d (<@MBK?@>!BC!">;>XED 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9 `` )))9 ,'!,',2e$)$!&4!&8,.,\$!"#$%&'$#$!+&!+0#!,-"&",!+0#,+#"!$0&&+)'*:! $-%#"$+&".!$,' (e:!,'(!+0#!8&$+&'!.,",+0&'!8&.8)'* 99999999999999999999999999999 `U

PAGE 7

=<< "J>AB?ED<;P 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9999 `U +>DD<;P!%>BND>\@!$AB?<>@/!0>ED<;P!E@!(<@>LNBX>?L>;A 99999999999999999999999999999999 999999999 aH %EA???B>@/!0>ED<;P!AJ?BKPJ!0<@AB?6 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999 bH f1>!8BK;M>!8EMTg/!0>ED<;P!E@!E!3JE?!E;F!3BLLK;ED!#CCB?A 9999999999999999999999 bQ "J>AB?A<;P!#Y

;M<>@ 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9999999999999 UI )S9 3&'32-$)&' 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999 Ua 8)82)&*",%0e 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 99999999999999999999999999999999 9999999999 IHI !

PAGE 8

I &2!3$-%' 4 4)$%*.5&$4*)'!).'%-64-+'*1'$2-',4$-%!$5%' 4789:;<=8>:7 &;!&MAB5>?!IG AJ :!GHHa:!)!XE@!E!@J6!Ia ^ 6>E? ^ BDF!@>;?E;!0?9! .6!CELF! C?BL!$BKAJ>?;!3EDX!LB;AJ@! N?!FE6!BC!BK?!0BL>MBL<;P!N>N!?EDD69! 1>!JEF!ZK@A!C<;<@J>F!E!F BFP>5EDD! ABK?;EL>;Ah!;>YA!XE@!E!PEL>!BC!AKP ^ BC ^ XE? / ZK;;D6!T;>X!E;6B;>:! 5KA! ) ?>DKMAE;AD6 F>@M>;F>F!AJ >!5D>EMJ>?@!AB!ZB<;!L6!N>>?@ 9!1>!NDE6>F!E!?BK;F i AJ>!ZK; !NDE6>F!E!@>MB;F!?BK;F i AJ>! @>;!N?>NE?>F!CB?!AJ>!C<;ED!?BK;F:!E! C>X!?EL5K;MA;=<@>F!E!NDE;/!AJ>6 ABDF!K@! EDD! AB!P?E5!AJ>!?BN>!E;F!NKDD!JE?F!B;! AJ>!MBK;A!BC!AJ?>> 9! 2!F!T;BX!AJEA! E!MBKND>!BC!ZK;>L<;PD6!CEP69!1 >!J>E?F!AJ>!MBK;AFBX;/!I9!G9!d 9!1 >!EDD! NKDD>F!AJ>!?BN>!EA!B;M>:!P<=<;P!F! X> ?>!5DBBF ^ MK?FD<;P!@M?>EL@ AJEA!)!@AA9!);!AJ>!@EL>! XE6!AJEA B;> J>E? @ AJK;F>?!5>CB?>! @>><;P!AJ>!D!@M?>EL<;P N?>M>F>F!AJ> @?<;P!AJ>!P6L ;E@;?6:!E! CDKA<@A:! E;F!.? i JEF!X?EN N>F AJ>!?BN>!E?BK;F!AJ>!D>=>?EP>9! + J>!FBMAB?@!XJB!A?>EA>F!AJ>L!>YNDE<;>F!A JEA!AJ>!CB?M> BC!AJ>!@>;!?BN> JEF! ;>E?D6!@>=>?>F!5BAJ!.;?6\@!JE;F@9 1J>;!;>F:!0>;?6!?E;!A BXE?F@!AJ>! P6L!FBB?@!E;F!BKA!B;AB!AJ>!CBBA5EDD!C<>DF!<;!E!@AEA>!BC!@JBMT 9!.>E;XJ:!.?>! MDKAMJ<;P!J<@!JE;F! XJ! E;BA J>?!@AKF>;A JEF!?F!AJ>!@J!E! ABK?;A!E;F @ABN!AJ>!5D>>F<;P9

PAGE 9

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

!AJ< @!X?B;P9! )A!@>>L>F!@B!L<;B?:!5KA!XJ>;!)!?>EF! ED<[>F AJEA!AJ>!L>FCC>MA<=>D6!X?;!L>!BKA!BC!L6!BX;!A?EKLEAYN>?<>;M>9! +J>!PKDA!CB?!NE?ACKD!AKP ^ BC ^ XE?!PEL>! XE@! >CC>MA<=>D6! >?E@>F!56!AJ>! L<@<;CB?LEAOK>;A!BMMK??>;M>:!E;F!=ED>;M>!<@!B;D6!>YEM>?5EA>F!56!AJ>! BL;@>;M>!BC!AJ>!L>F!?>ED;@!>=>?6!FE6:!EDD!E?BK;F!E;F!AB! K@9!+J>!NB@@<5F6!BMMK??<;P!<;!L6!BX;!5EMT6E?F!JE@!5>MBL>!LB?>!?>ED!@<;M>!)\= >! D<=>F!<;!3BDB?EFB:!XJ>?>!@B!LE;6!N>BND>!D<=>!ZK@A!L@!EXE6!C?BL!3BDKL5<;>!0!0?>!)!NDE;;>F!AB!L>>A!E!C?<>;F!CB?!DK;MJ!E?BK;F!AJ>!MB?;>?! C?BL!AJ>!,K?B?E!3>;AK?6!I`!LB=<>!AJ>EA>?!AJ>!FE6!BC!AJ>!@JBBA<;P9!+?EKLE!5>MB L>@!AJ>! @K5Z>MA!BC!@LEDD!AEDT!E;F!XEA>?!MBBD>?!MB;=>?@EA;A@:!@KMJ!MB;=>?@EA
PAGE 10

d @JBX!D!?>@N>MA!CB?!AJ>!N>BND>!XJB!E?>;\A!ZK@A!XEAMJ<;P!AJ>!@AB?6!K;CBDF!B;!AJ>!;>X@:! 5KA!E?>!D<=<;P!AJ>!@AB?6!>=>?6!@>MB;F:!L<;KA>:!E;F!JBK?!BC!AJ> @9!,DD!ABB!C?>OK>;AD6:! F<@MBK?@>@!BC!A?EKLE!;>PD>MA!AJ>!X>DD5><;P!BC!AJB@>!XJB!JE=>!>YN>?<>;M>F!AJ>!A?EKLEA=>;A!FMAD6!56!AEDT<;P!B=>?!AJ>L!B?!E5BKA!AJ>L:!5KA!;BA! !"# AJ>L9!"J>AB?@NB;@>@!AB! A?EKLE!E?>!BCA>;!CBMK@>F!B;!AJ>!X?B;P!EKF<>;M>:!EF! EA!NEDD!?>@A!BC!fK@:g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

PAGE 11

Q XJEA!E;@!AB!J>ED!E;F!JBX!@K?=<=B ?@!ME;!N?BM>>F!AB!?>MB=>?!C?BL!AJ>YN>?<>;M>:! E;F! AJ>!?BD>!BC!?J>AB?@@>@9 $>MB;F: )!@KPP>@A!AJEA N?>@;A@!BC! A?EKLE!CE!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!BC!A?EKLE!@K?=<=B?@9!);@A>EF:!AJ>@>!F<@MBK?@>@!@>?=>! AJ>!;>>F@!BC!5?BEF>?! EKF<>;M>@!B?!AJ>!NK?NB@>@!BC!AJ>!?J>AB?9!,!JE;FCKD!BC!A?EKLE! @K?=<=B?@\!N>?@B;ED!;E??EA<=>@!E?>!NB@F!E@!L>AB;6L=;M>!BC!AJ>!MJE?EMA>?!E;F! J>?B<@L!BC!EDD!A?EKLE!@K?=<=B?@:!LE?P<;ED<[<;P!AJB@>!XJB!FB!;BA!MB;CB?L!AB!AJ>@>! >YN>MAEA;A!XE6@!AJEA!AJ>!@EL>!L>AENJB?@!E?>!KAF!AB!F>@M?<5>!AJ>! ?>MB=>?6!N?BM>@@!E;F!AJ>!>CC>MA!BC!AJ>@>!MDAB??@AE;F<;P@!BC! J>ED<;P9!4<;EDD6:!L6!E;ED6@<@!>YEL<;>@!AJ>!?BD>!BC!LKDA!>Y

;M<>@:! AJEA!<@:!JBX!>Y

;M<>@ BAJ>?!AJE;!AJ>!A?EKLE!DC!@JEN>F!?>@NB;@>:! <;MDKF<;P!AJ>!GHIG!MELNE@!@KMJ!E@!PK;!MB;A?BD9!);!EAA>LNA<;P!AB!ZKPPD>!LKDA!>Y

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

PAGE 12

_ %?@>?A':B'8C?',>8?9D8<9? +J>!@MJBDE?@J!?J>AB?@! >YN>?<>;M>@! ?E;P<;P!C?BL!AJ>! J?@B;ED!AB!;EA=>;!PDB5ED!A?EKLE@9! $BL>!@MJBDE?@!@KNNB?A!AJ>! K;F>?@AE;F<;P!BC!A?EKLE!E @!E;!K;@N>ETE5D> >YN>?<>;M>:!E;F!@K?=<=B?@!BC!AJ>!A?EKLEA=>;A!E?>!<;MENE5D>!BC!NKAA<;P!AJ>!>YN>?<>;M>!<;AB!XB?F@9!&;!AJ>!BAJ>?!JE;F:!@MJBDE?@! ED@B! E?PK>!AJEA! 56!NKAA<;P!AJ>!A?EKLEA=>;A!<;AB!E!MBJ>@< =>!;E??EA<=>:!@K?=<=B?@!BC!AJ>! A?EKLE! X!E5D>!AB!J>ED9!86!?6!F>C<;ETE5D>:!6>A!AJ>!?>L>F6!CB?!A ?EKLE! <@!NKAA<;P!D6!?>;F>?@!J>ED<;P!<;EMM>@@<5D>9! +J?BKPJBKA!AJ<@! D
?EAK?>!?>=<>X:!)!X!C<>DF!@JBKDF/!I9W!MB;@A?KMA LB?>! <;MDK@<=> F>C <;ED<;Ph! G9W! >YEL<; >!JBX!?J>AB?@!>;EMA CEAJ>?JBBF!<;!F<@MK@@<;P!A?EKLEAYN>?<>;M>@h! d9W!>LNBX>? @K?=<=B?@!BC!A?EKLE!AB!?>MDE;M6h! Q9W! F?EX!B; LKDA! ;E??EA<=>@!AB!MB;@A?KMA!JB;>@A!E;F!MBLND>Y!?>N?>@>;AEA;PEP>!X! F<@M!BC!F<@E5@h `9W!E;ED6[> JBX!MBLN>A<;P!>Y

;M<>@!<;CB?L!E!?J>AB?\@! ?>@NB;@>!AB!A?EKLEh!E;F! a9W!F>A>?L<;> XJ@@!A?EKLE!C?BL E!N>FEPBP?@N>MA<=>9! 8>MEK@>!BC!AJ>!X!?E;P>!BC! >=>;A@!>;MBLNE@@>F!XAB?CC;A!CB?!L>!AB!F<=!KN!AJ>!@MJBDE?@JMA!=E?@!BC!AJ>!?J>AB?YEL<;>!AJ>!F>C<;! >=>;A@!;MBLNE@@>@9!+J>;:!)!X! D?EAK?>!B;!AJ>!?J>AB?@!J>ED<;Ph!P?ENND>@!XY@!BC!?>N?>@>;AEA@N>M?;<;P!AJ>! 0BDBMEK@Ah!M?>EA>@!MBLLK;h!E;F!MB;A?<5KA>@!AB!N>FEPBP69!! !

PAGE 13

` $EF?G':B'$9DYEL<;<;P!XJEA!fA? EKLEg!K@KEDD6!L>E;@!<; AJ<@!@MJBDE?@JF!<;!3E?KAJ:!E!N>?@B;ED!A?EKLE:!E@!F<@A<;PK<@J>F!C?BL!E!MBDD>MA<=>!B?!@BM!N@6MJ>!AJEA!5?>ET@!AJ?BKPJ!B;>\@!F>C>;@>@!@B!@KFF>;D6!E;F!X!AJEA!B;>!ME;;BA!?>EMA!AB!CC>MA<=>D6g!Vf+?EKLEg!IbaW9!$KMJ!E!F>C<;!J>DNCKD!CB?!K;F>?@AE;F<;P!XJEA!MB;@A@!E!N>?@B;ED!A?EKLE:!<@!ED@B!N?B5D>LEAD<>@!B;!E!N>?M><=>F!@JB?AMBL<;P!B;!AJ>!NE?A!BC!AJ>!<;F<=YN>?<>;M>F! A?EKLE9!+J<@!@KPP>@A@!AJEA!!<;F<=;AEDD6!E;F!NJ6@!A?EKLEA=>;A i ?EAJ>?!AJE;!AJ>!>=>;A!DC i AJEA!F>C<;>@!A?EKLE9!&;>!MBKDF!AJ>;!K@>! AJ<@!F>C<;A>?L<;>!XJEA!E;@!CB?!E;!<;F<=< FKED!AB!J>ED!C?BL!E! A?EKLEA=>;A/!AB!D>E?;!AB!>CC>MA<=>D6!?>@NB;F!AB!AJ>!A?EKLE9!)!ED@B!AET>!<@@K>!X! XB?F!f>CC>MA<=>D6g!E@!)!XBKDF!E?PK>!AJEA!AJ>?>!<@!;B!XE6!AB!>CC>MA<=>D6!?>@NB;F!AB!A?EKLE9!);! F>C<;<;P!E!MBDD>MA<=>!A?EKLE:!#?@/!f86! $ "%%&$!'(&#!)*+,* :!B;!AJ>!BAJ>?!JE;F:!)! L>E;!E!5DBX!AB!AJ>!5E@@!BC!@BM!AJEA!FELEP>@!AJ>!5B;F@!EAAEMJ<;P!N>BND>! ABP>AJ>?!E;F!!N?>=E;@>!BC!MBLLK;ED=>?:!)! XBKDF!A>;F!AB!F<@EP?>>!XC<;?!=<@!L>LB?F!<;! ?>@NB;@>!AB!A J>!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P!<;!,K?B?E:!;A!AJEA!AJ<@!NE?AMA<=>! A?EKLE! 5?BKPJA!AJ> MBLLK;AJ>?!LB?>!AJE;! F!!MBLNDF!F>C<; @!AJEA!A?EKLE!<@!LB?>! AJE;!ZK@A!AJ>!<;@AE;M>!B?!>=>;A!AJEA!LE?T>F!AJ>!<;F<=?!fAJ>!B@MAX>>;!E!M?<@<@!BC!F>EAJ!E;F!AJ>!MB??>DEA<=>!M?<@<@!BC!Dg!Vf-;MDEF!#YN>?<>;M>g!aW9 );! BAJ>?!XB?F@:!AJ>!A?EKLEA=>;A!DC!<@!KDAD6 ZK@A!AJ>!5>P<;;<;Ph!;MBLNE@@>@!

PAGE 14

a AJ>!@K5@>OK>;A!@A?KPPD>!CB?!@K?=<=ED!<;!AJ>!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!E!A?EKLEAYN>?<>;M>:!AJ>! ?EF?>;A!>Y<@A>;M>!BC!E;!<;F<=?!D<=>!D!AJ>!XE6!J>!B?! @J>! F!A?EKLE9!(B?F!<;!3E?KAJ:! @AEA>@:!f?>NB@@>@@<;P!B;>\@!D!@AB?6! AJ?BKPJ!P<=<;P!A>@ADC!E!CB?L!BC!EMALB;@A?EA<;P!AJ>!;>>F! CB?!@K?=<=B?@!AB!MBLLK;!AJ>YN>?<>;M>@!<;!E!XE6!AJEA!EDDBX@!AJ>L!AB!N?>@>?=>! EP>;M69!86!FB<;P!@B:!E @K?=<=B?!<@!E5D>!AB!D<=>!B;>\@!D!LB?>!CKDD69!8>MEK@>:!EMMB?F<;P!AB! 2EK5:!AJ>!>=>;A!DC!f<;=E?M<@<=>!CB?LEA<=>!?BD>!<;!XJB!B;>!MBL>@!AB!5>:! E;F!<;!JBX!B;>!MBL>@!AB!D< = >!B;>\@!D:g! Vf+?EKLEg!aHW AJ>!EMA!BC!P<=<;P!E!A>@A! A ?EKLEA=>;A!EDDBX@!@K?=<=B?@!AB!>@AE5D<@J!AJ>;AMDE@@>@!AB!AJ>!>=>;A:!E;F!MJBB@>!JBX!AJ>!>YN>?<>;M>!C!5 ?!@MJ>L>!BC!AJ>!@AB?<>@9 ! 1D=>I>8D8>7J'2?DI>7J ' .KMJ!BC!AJ>!D
?EAK?>!>YEL<;>@!J BX!AJ>!?J>AB?!K@>F!AB!CEM! J>ED<;Ph!JBX>=>?:!)!XBKDF!E?PK>!AJEA!LE;6!?J>AB?@!E?>!<;EF>OKEA>!XJ>;!@!AB!CKDD6!MB;=>6<;P!E!A?EKLEAYN>?<>;M>:!XJLEA! >YN>?<>;M>!<@!AJ>!>E@<>@A! XE6!CB?!@K?=<=B?@!AB!5>P<;!J>ED<;P!C?BL!A?EKLE9!3B;@>OK>;AD6:!AJ>! ?>@>E?MJ!<;!AJ<@!E?>E!CBMK@>@!B;!>AJB@!E;F!AJ>!?BD>!BC!AJ>!?J>AB?!<;!MBLLK;\@! BX;!A?EKLE:!E@!X>DD!E@!AJ>!MJEDD>;P>@!AJEA!MBL>!XAB?YA9! +JBKPJ!;E??EA<=>!<@! E;!AJBF!@K?=<=B?@!BC!A?EKLE!KA!AB! MBLLK;!AJ>YN>?<>;M>@:!AJ>!D?EAK?>!F>LB;@A?EA>@!AJEA!LE;6!?J>AB?@!CEDD!@JB?A!BC!CKDD6!MB;=>6<;P!AJ>!>YN>?<>;M>9!,@!"B@>LE?6!1<;@DBX!E?PK>@:!

PAGE 15

b B?F<;E?6!DE;PKEP>!FB>@!;BA!L>>A!AJ>!F>LE ;F@!BC!MBLLK;MEK@>! A?EKLE!<@!E;!>YA?EB?F<;E?6!>YN>?<>;M>:!XJ?>;AD6!LET>@!ETE5D> 9!)!XBKDF! E?PK>!AJEA!ETE5D>!AB!AJ>!>YA>;A!AJEA!?@!AJB@>!XJB!JE=>!;BA! >YN>?<>;M>F!AJ>!A?EKLE9 4?BL!L6!>YN>?<>;M>:!XJ EA!<@!K;@N>ETE5D>!E5BKA!A?EKLE!<@!AJ>! 5B;F!E;F!AJ>!MBLLK;EA>@!ELB;P!AJB@>!XJB!JE=>!>YN>?<>;M>F!AJ>! A?EKLE9!,@!1<;@DBX!@AEA>@:!?J>AB?@!MBLLK;!A?EKLE@!AJ>6!JE=>! >YN>?<>;M>F!LK@A!?>D6!B;!F>=@!D!A?BN>@!E;F!L>AENJ B?@!5>MEK@>!AJ>!A?EKLE!f@J! >YN>?<>;M>!AB!N?>MB;M>NAKED!C@BK?M>@g!V`HUW9!,@!3E?KAJ!>YNDE<;@!<;!J>?!5BBT! -.$%*',&/#012&)'&.$&3#4)*+,*5#6*))*!'(&5#*./#7'8!")9 :!A?BN>@!EDDBX!X?F!<;! ?>@NB;@>!AB!A?EKLE!AB!5>MBL>!LB?>!CBMK@>F!B;!?6!E;F!F>@M?!@AEA>@:! f N ?>M<@>D6!XJ>;!AJ>!A>YA!ENN>E?@!LB@A!JKLE;:!MJE;F! #YN>?<>;M>g!3E?KAJ!bGW9!$K?=<=B?@!ME;!NBA>;A!@KMJ!F>=@:!AJBKPJ!AJ>6!E?>!BCA>;! DBBT>F!FBX;!KNB;!<;!BAJ>?!CB?L@!BC!X?!AJ>!BAJ>?X<@>!K;@N>ETE5D>!E@N>MA@! BC!E!A?EKLE9! +JBKPJ!@MJBDE?@!E?PK>!AJEA!A?BN>@!E;F!L>AENJB?@!LE6!J>DN!@K?=<=B?@!MBLLK;! AJ>YN>?<>;M>!BC!A?EKLE:!LE;6!@MJBDE?@!EFF?>@@!JBX!NB@A ^ A?EKLEA@@!F<@B?F>?! V%+$(W!ME;!>YEM>?5EA>!AJ>!K;@N>ETE5 D>!;EAK?>!BC!E!A?EKLEAYN>?<>;M>:!LET<;P!! F=>?:!)!XBKDF!E?PK>!AJEA!ETE5D>!>=>;A:!AJ>;!AJ>?>!<@!;B!MD>E?!5>;>CAX>>;!@K?=<=B?@!BC! A?EKLE!XJB!>YN>?<>;M>!%+$( E@!BNNB@>F!AB!AJB@>!XJB!FB;\A9!8>MEK@>!BC!AJ>!MBLND>Y! ;EAK?>!BC!A?EKLEALB?6!<;!AJEA!=BT>F!K;F>?!NE?AYNDE<;>F! 56!SE;!(>?!7BDT!E;F!SE;!(>?!0E?A!E@!M
F!<;!3E?KAJ!Vf+?EKLEg!I`dW: A?EKLE!<@!;BA!>E@
PAGE 16

U A?E;@C>??>F!<;AB!;E? ?EA<=>:!XJ!LB@A!>CC>MA<=>!XE6!CB?!@K?=<=B?@!AB!N?BM>@@! AJ>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!A?EKLE9!,@!E!?>@KDA:!X??EN>KA!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!E!A?EP>F6:!XJ@!E!N?B5D>L!CB?!JBX!J>ED<;P!<@!F>C<;>F!E;F! E@@> @@>F9!,@!49]9!SE;!kKK?>;!>A!ED9!EFF?>@@>@:!X?@NB;@>!AB!A?EKLE!ME;!>YJ<5?<@ACC>MA<=>!<;!P>;>?ED:!AJBKPJ!LB?>!?>@>E?MJ!LK@A!5>!FB;>!B;! JBX!X?!?>MB=>?6!N?BM>@@!E;F!J>DN!XD6! <;>=!CB?!@K?=<=B?@!BC!A?EKLE:!XJFD6!MD>E?!5E@>F!B;!AJ>!@MJBDE?@J!?J>AB?;!)!XBKDF!@KPP>@A!AJEA!@MJBDE?@!@AKF6<;P!X??EN>KA!N?>?>OK<@
!BC!5><;P!E5D>!AB!CB?LKDEA> E!;E??EA<=>!E;F!DBBT!CB?! BAJ>?!EAA?<5KA>@!AJEA!E?>!LB?>!<;F!BC!J>ED<;P9!%>?JEN@!@MJBDE?@!@JBKDF!A?EM>!AJ>!K@EP>! BC!A?BN>@!E;F!L>A ENJB?@!<;!@K?=<=B?@\!X?YN>?<>;M>@!BC!A?EKLE:!E@!E! F>MD<;>!<;!AJ>!K@>!BC!AJ>@>!F>=@!LE6!@JBX!AJEA @K?=<=B?@!?>D6!D>@@!B;!P>;>?ED<[EA!AJ>YN>?<>;M>@!X;M>@!XJB!JE=>!;B!N>?@B;ED!<;=BD=>L>;A!X! A?EKLEA=>;A9 +JBKPJ!LKMJ!BC!AJ>!D?EAK?>!CBMK@>@!B;!E!LB?>!N@6MJBDBP?@N>MA<=>!BC! J>ED<;P:!!AJEA!@BL>!@K?=<=B?@!JE=>!@K@AE<;>F!NJ6@@! C?BL!AJ>!A?EKLE!AJ>6\=>!>YN>?<>;M>F:!AJBKPJ!LB@A!BC!AJ>!D?EAK?>!B;D6!>YEL<;>@!JBX!AB! CEM!J>ED<;P!N@6MJBDBPBK@D69!!)!XBKDF!MB;A>;F! AJEA!AJ<@!N>?N>AK EA>@!E;!B=>?@F!K;F>?@AE;F<;P!BC!AJ>!5BF6!E;F!XJEA!E;@!AB! J>ED!C?BL!A?EKLE9!+J<@!<@!XJ>?>!A?EKLE!@AKF<>@!XBKDF!5>;>C!B=>?DEN!X@:!@<;M>!5BAJ!F<@M@!@JE?>!E;!>LNJE@<@!B;!?>CB?L:!>@N>MPE?F@! AB!MJEDD >;P<;P!E;F!?>M?>EA<;P!F>C<;?@B;!E@!X>DD!E@!?>MDE;M69!0BX>=>?:!

PAGE 17

IH @K?N?<@<;PD6:!AJ>?>!<@!D!<;A>?EMAAX>>;!AJ>!AXB!C<>DF@9! 3B;@?<;P!AJ>!F>P?>>!AB! XJ?DEN!<;!A>?L@!BC!AJ>@!8>?P>?!OK>@A@!E;F!A?EKLE!@AKF<>@!MB;@?!AJ>L@>D=>@!AB!5>!LKAKEDD6!>YMDK@<=>:!@AEA<;P:! f8BAJ:!ECA>?!EDD:!E?>!MB;M>?;>F!X=E@AEA<;P!<;ZK?6!E;F!CC>MA@h!5BAJ!NDEM>! <;F<=YA@h!5BAJ!CBMK@! <;A>;@<=>D6!B;!N?B5D>LEAN?>@>;AEA?P>?!FB>@ EMT;BXD>FP>! AJ>!LE;6!BDBP;>A@!AJEA!F<=!AJ>!AXB!C<>DF@h!CB?!>YELND>:!XJ!A?EKLE!@AKF<>@!<@! @JEN>F!AB!E!DE?P>!>YA>;A!56!AJ>!K@>!BC!L>AENJB?:!F<@E5< D@!@>>@! L>AENJB?!E@!E5D><@A! <;!AJEA!;F@!AB!<;F!E!f?>CK@ED!AB!?>MBP;<[>!E;F!<;MDKF>!F<@E5YN>?<>;M>!E;F!L>AENJB?;BL>;B;g!VSD6:!8>?P>?!@KPP>@A@!AJEA! fA?EKLE!@AKF<>@!?>=>ED@!M>?AE<;!AJ>B?>A@:!XJ!F<@E5@!@KPP>@A@!NBDOKEM<>@!<;!A?EKLE!@AKF<>@g!V_aaW:!AJBKPJ!!!K@>@!AJ>!NJ?E@>!f5D<;F!@NBA@g!AB!LET>!J<@!NB<;A9!)A\@!>=;A!C?BL!AJ>!PEN@!<;!>EMJ! F<@M!AJEA!A?EK LE!@AKF<>@!XBKDF!5>;>CEAD6!C?BL!LB?>!<;A>?EMA@!E;F!=!=>?@E:!NE?APE?F@!AB!K;F>?@AE;F<;P@!BC!J>ED<;P!E;F!?>MB=>?6! C?BL!A?EKLE!E;F!MB;C?B;A<;P!>YN>MAEA!B?!?>@NB;F!AB!A?EKLE!<;! M>?AE<;: @BMNAE5D>!XE6@9! )A!<@!!AB!EMT;BXD>FP>!AJEA!EDAJBKPJ!AJ>!?J>AB?@! LKMJ!>LNJE@<@!B;!J>ED<;P:!AJ>!C<>DF!FB>@!>YEL<;>!JBX!@K?=<=B?@!BC!E!A?EKLEAYN>?<>;M>! ME;!X?
!CB?!NK?NB@>@!BAJ>?!AJE;!J>ED<;P!E;F!?>MB=>?69!, @!,L6!2E?@>;!F>@M?<5>@!<;!J>?! E?A!>;AF!f\)!1E@!">EF6!CB?!E!.>;F<;P\/!"J>AB?MB=>?6!<;!(BKP! %>EMBMTl@!*?<[[D6!e>E?@!E;F!1EDT<;P!)A!&CC:g!J>?!@K5Z>MA!KDAD6!?>NK?NB@>F!J<@!;E??EA<=>!

PAGE 18

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g!V 2E?@>;! QGIW:! F>LB;@A?EA<;P!JB X!%>EMBMT\@!L>LB@;\A!MB;CB?L!AB!AJ>!MB;=>;A?EN>KAEF:!J>!?>NK?NB@>@!J<@!BX;!A?EKLE@!AB!EF=BMEA>!CB?!E!5?! PBED!E@!C?BL!J<@!N>?@B;ED!?>JE5LB;@A?EA>@!AJEA!@MJBDE?@! @JBKDF!5 >!LB?>!BN>; ^ L<;F>F!ABXE?F!A>YA@!AJEA!FB;\A!C!MK??>;A!;E??BXD6!F>C<;>F!E! BC!J>ED<;P:!XJD6!@A?;M6!6!ME;;BA!CB?L!E!MBJ>@<=>! ;E??EA<=>!BC!AJ>YN>?<>;M>9! ! 4GG:7 &=>?EDD:!!MD>E?!AJEA!@MJBDE?@!XJB!@AKF6!AJ>!?J>AB?! XY!OK>@A;!>=EDKEA<;P!JBX!A?EKLE!<@!?>N?>@>;A>F!E;F!56!XJBL9! 'B!?>N?>@>;AEA=>?!MENAK?>!AJ>!>YN>?<>;M>!<;!;AA6!AB!E!F>P?>>!AJEA! @EA<@C<> @!EDD!AJB@>!XJB!>;FK?>F!?!AJ>!A?EKLE9!&;!AJ>!B;>!JE;F:!E!@K?=<=B?!<@! DF!56!J<@!B?!J>?!BX;!A?EKLEALB?6!<;!EMMK?EA>D6!NB?A?E6<;P!AJ>!A?EKLE!E;F!

PAGE 19

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
?EAK?>!<;!AJ<@!C<>DF!CBMK@>@!B;!JBX!?J>AB?@!MJBB@>!AB!?>N?>@>;A!@N>MMA@!BC!AJ>!>=>;A:!>@N>M!MB;A>YA!BC!E!NK5D6!E? >! KDAD6!?>@NB;@<5D>!CB?!<;!MB;=>6<;P!AJ>!A?EKLEAYN>?<>;M>!AB!E;!EKF<>;M>9!);!J<@! E?A!>;AF:!f+J>!%J>;BL>;BDBP6!BC!(<@E@A>?/!+BXE?F!E!"J>AB?F6:g!"B5>?A! 1EF>!7>;;6!E?PK>@!AJEA!?J>AB?@!XJB!?>@NB;F!AB!A?EP>F6!JE=>!5?BEF>?!?>@NB;@<5@!AJEA! AJ>YA@!LK@A!@JBKDF>?!<;!AJEA!AJ>6!LK@A!f?>=>ED!@BL>AJ<;P!CK;FEL>;AED!E5BKA!AJ>! MJE?EMA>?!BC!A?EPAB?!BC!@BL>!NE?A!BC!?@ABBF!E@!AJ>!NJ>;BL>;BDBP6!BC!AJ>!F<@E@A>?g!VUbW9!!"J>AB?@!XJB!?>@NB; F!AB!F<@E@A>?! <;!AJ>!NK5DEDL!E?>!<;MENE5D>!BC!F<@AE;M<;P!AJ>L@>D=>@!C?BL!AJ>!>=>;A!B;M>!AJ>6!JE=>!

PAGE 20

Id 5>>;!>YNB@>F!AB!OK>;AD6:!@KMJ!?J>AB?@!KA!?J>AB?CCB?A!AB!>;@K?>!AJ>F>LNA!A?EP>F6!V7>;;6!IHHW9!+J<@!<@!<;!F MA!MB;A?E@A!AB/!I9W!AJ>! EKF<>;M>:!AJB@>!XJB!@>>!AJ>!A?EP>F6!K;CBDF!AJ?BKPJ!AJ>!L>FMAEMD>! V7>;;6!IHHW!E;F!G9W!AJ>!X@@>@:!XJB!>YN>?<>;M>!AJ>!F<@E@A>?!AJ>L@>D=>@!V7>;;6!IIGW9!,@! E!?>@KDA:!AJ>!?J>AB?F6!@>?=>@!E!K;!NK? NB@>!<;!AJEA!!MDB@>!AB!AJ>! F<@E@A>?!5EMT!C?BL!AJ>!;B; ^ >@@>;A!<;AB!E!XE6!BC!5><;P!<;!AJ>!XB?DF:!X?@g!V7>;;6! IHdW!E@!AJ>!?J>AB?!LK@A!N?B=!f@BDEM> i <;!AJ>!CB?L!BC!MBLCB?A:!>YNDE;EAMA;;6!IIGW9!! (B;6ED>!*?AA!E;F!(B;;>A?!,DD<@B;!>DE5B?EA>!B;!AJ>!?J>AB?\@! ?>@NB;@<5@!AB!AJ>!NK5D!f.ET<;P!E!3E@>!CB?!">@AB?EA<=>!"J>AB?@NB;@>!AB!(<@E@A>?9g!,@!AJ>6!E?PK>:!?>@AB?EA<=>! ?J>AB?!LB@A ENN?BN?!AEMA!<;!NB@EF>?@J!XJ>;!AJ>6! LK@A!?>@NB;F!AB!E!M?<@<@!B?!A?EP>F6!5>MEK@>!FKM<;P!AJ>!BCC>;@<=>;>@@!BC!AJ>!BMMK??>;M>!E;F!LE<;AE<;<;P!E!NB@!:!AB! CEM!5>AX>>;!AJ>!NK5DEF>?@:!E;F!J>DN<;P!=! P>;>?ED!NK5D!@>;@>!BC!AJ>!M?<@<@!>=>;Ag!V *?AA!E;F!,DD<@B;! dbHW9!86!FB<;P! @B : D>EF>?@!E?>!E5D>!AB!?>N?>@>;A!AJ>!A?EKLE!;BA!E@!E!NBD?!E@!E!P >;K<;>! >CCB?A!AB!?>EMJ!BKA!E;F!BCC>?!E@@<@AE;M>!E;F!D>EF>?@JMEK@>!BC!AJ>!LE;6!MBLND>Y!XE6@! A?EKL E!ME;!5>!?>N?>@>;A>F:!E@!7>;;6 ;BA>@:!@@>;AAX>>;!AJ>!A>YA@! N?BFKM>F!56!@K?=<=B?@!BC!E!A?EKLE!E;F!AJB@>!XJB!E?>!<;!NB@EF>?@J>D! B5DF!AB!?>@NB;F:!E@!AJ>6!E?>!MBL<;P!C?BL!LKDA:!F<=>?@>!N>?@N>MA<=>@!X@!E;F!<;A>;AN>;F<;P!J>E=!MB;A>YA!E;F!>Y

;M>!BC!AJ>!A?EKLE!DC9!

PAGE 21

IQ ,@!)!MB;@?!AJ>!?>E@B;@!5>J<;F!8E?EMT!&5ELE\@!?>@NB ;@>@!AB!A?EKLE:!E;F!XJ!MJBB@>@!AB!?>@NB;F!AB:!XJ>;!J>!?>@NB;F@:!E;F!XJ6:!)!XM>@@E?!CBMK@>F!B;! J<@!<;A>;A@A!JBX!J>!N>?@B;EDD6!5>;>CET<;P!NK5D!A?EKLE!E;F!JBX!@KMJ!E!?>@NB;@>!5B D@A>?@!J<@!BX;!M?>F<5EF>?9 $MJBDE?@!JE=>!N?>@>;A>F!E!?J>AB?;>XED i @@AB?EA<=>!?J>AB??;EA<=>!J>K?<@A!ME@>!BC!A>YA@!AJEA!?>@NB;F!AB!A?EKLE@9!);!?>PE?F@!AB!AJ>! D
?EAK?>!AJEA!>YEL<;>@!NK5DEF >?@\!?>@NB;@>@!AB!A?EKLE:!AJ>?>!<@!E!MD>E?!A>;@AX>>;!AJ>!?J>AB?\@!;>>F!AB!LE<;AE<;!E;F!5BD@A>?!J<@!B?!J>?!!=>?@K@!N?B=;K<;>!D>EF>?@JAA!E;F!$>>P>?!>YEL<;>!<;!AJ>! f4?BL!)LEP>!">@AB?EA; >XED/!,NN?BEMJ>@!CB?!-;F>?@AE;F<;P!%B@A ^ 3?<@<@! 3BLLK;!D?EAK?>!B;!?>@NB;@>@!AB!A?EKLE!C?BL!NK5D@!JE@! CBMK@>F!B;!AJ>!XE6!AJ>@>!?J>AB?@!@A?<=>!AB!?>N?>@>;A!AJ>L@>D=>@!<;!E!NB@!DMEK@>! BC!AJ<@:!$>>P>?!E;F!*?AA!E?PK>!CB?!E!F<@MBK?@>!BC!?>;>XED!<;!?>@NB;@>!AB!M?<@<@9!+J<@! <@!F?>;A!C?BL!*?AA!E;F!,DD<@B;\@!E?PKL>;A!<;!@KNNB?A!BC!?>@AB?EA<=>!?J>AB?MEK@>!AJ>!?J>AB?;>XED!f<;=BD=>@!E!LB?>!P>;>?EA<=>!E;F!@NB;AE;>BK@!F!AJEA! <@!@JEN >F!;BA!ZK@A!<;!?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!M?<@<@!DC:!5KA!56!MB;A>YAKED!E;F!@BM;@?!AJ>!M?<@<@!>=>;A!E;F!<;CDK>;M>!?>@NB;@>!AB!@!XN?>@>;AEA!;BA!ZK@A!<;J>?>;A!<;!AJ>!=>?6! <;@AE;AE;>BK@!A> YA@!N?BFKM>F!56!NBDEF>?@:!5KA!ED@B!<;!AJ>!N?B5D>LEA! ;>X@!L>F@!5<;E?<>@!XJ>;!MB=>?<;P!A?EKLE@9!);!E!M?;A!BC!AJ>!L>F
PAGE 22

I_ %EA?E=6:!<;!J>?!E?A!>;AF!f1?LB?6!<;!&AJ>?!%BD@/! L>?M?>@A!*?BKN@!E@!3BLND?@!<;!Uc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
!N>?M>NA?>!AB!E!M>?AE<;! @AE;FE ?F<[>F!;E??EA<=>!BC!AJ>!>=>;A9!.B?>!NB<;A>FD6 :!2>E=6!>YEL<;>@!AJ>!XE6!AJ>!L>F!AB!MB;A?BD!AJ>!;E??EA<=>@!BC!A?E KLE AJ?BKPJ!!BC!5<;E?<>@ i @N>M?B!=@9! =DD!E@!E;!L i XJ?TBX@@ >@ E@!X>DD!<;! J<@!BX;!>YEL<;EA!?J>AB?!L>F!D?EAK?>!>YEL<;>@!JBX!AJ>!,L>? F;@@!@!MDN?>@>;AEA@A=>;A@:! XJ;!A?EKLEAYN>?<>;M>!CB?!AJ>!@ET>!BC!LET<;P!AJ>!>=>;A!LB?>! EMM>@@<5D>!AB!P>;>?ED!EKF<>;M>@9!);!f+>DD<;P!n& K?\!$AB?6!+J?BKPJ!'>X@!BC!+>??B?<@L:g!(E;!

PAGE 23

I` 8>?TBXD!'B@@>T!MB;A?E@A!,L>?DAB?F?EP>!BC! =E???B?<@A!EAAEMT@9!+J>!EKAJB?@!F?EX!DE?P>?!MB;MDK@!?BD>!BC!;E??EA<=>! E;F!E?MJ>A6N>@!E@!AJ>6!N>?AE<;!AB!, L>?F?EP>!BC!<;A>?;EAX@!@AB?<>@:! MDEMEK@>!CB?>!@B!F<@AE;A!C?BL!,L>?;M>@:!;>X@ME@A>?@! CEM>!E!K;!MJEDD>;P>!<;!EAA>LNA<;P!AB!LET>!AJ>!@AB?6!EMM>@@<5D>9!8>?TBXT! EFF?>@@!AJ>!5<;E?6!<;J> ?>;A!<;!F>M?@N>MA<=>!AB!K@>!XJ>;!MB=>?<;P!E!A?EKLEA=>;A/!BK?!@AB?6!=@9!AJ>?!E?MJ>A6N>@!AB!ME@A! =!A?EKLE!<;!NB@!E;F!J>?B@!XJ!A>??B?<@A@!B?!N>?N>A?EAB?@!BC!AJ>! M?< L>!5>MBL>!AJ>!=?FA@!LET>!K@>!BC!E!1@A!;E??EA<=>!AJEA!@@!@KNNB?A>?@!BC!,L>?ED@!E;F!NBD@!E@!AJ>!J>?B>@!XJB! MBL>!AB!AEL>!E!DE;F!?KD>F!56!BKADEX@:!BAJ>?X<@>!T;BX;!E@!AJB@>!XJB!LE<;AE<;!E!5DE AE;AD6! E;A< ^ ,L>?;FE9!+JBKPJ!8>?TBXT!N?B=!<;A>?>@A<;P!<;@!KDAD6!F@!AJ>!A6N>!BC!L6AJ!AJEA!ZBK?;ED<@A@!K@>!AB!A>DD!AJ>!@AB?6:! AJ>;A!KDAD6!;>PD>MA@!AJ>!;>PEA<=>!MB;@>OK>;M>@!BC!JBX A?EKLE!<@! ?>N?>@>;A>F!56!AJ>!L>F?TBXFP>@!AJEA!,L>?F@!AB! E!N?BFKMA<=>!MB;=>?@EA?<;P!@JEDDBX!?>N?>@>;AEA!ED@B!MB;A>;F@!AJEA!AJ>!GQ ^ JBK?!;>X@!M6MD>!ME;!@A !J>ED<;P!56!J! NB@!ELF69!8>?TBX@@>@!AJ>!?BD>!BC!AJ>!L>F!ECA>?LEAJ!BC! A?EP>F6!E;F!ECC!E@!fMB;=>6B?:!A?E;@DEAB?:!L>FE;<;P ^ LET>?g!V`QQW:! F<@A<;PK<@J<;P!5>AX>>;!AJ>!NBX>?!BC ;>X@!N<>M>@!E;F!>F!>;AF!f+J>! )?B;?B!BC!SMJ/!0>ED<;P!+?EKLE!+J?BKPJ!.6AJ!E;F!3BDD>MA<=>!

PAGE 24

Ia .>LB?69g!+J?BKPJ!E!A>YAKED!E;ED6@<@!BC!;>X@!MB=>?EP>!?>@NB;F<;P!AB!AJ>!SMJ! @JBBA<;P:!J>!>YEL<;>@!5BAJ! !?BD>!BC!E?MJ>A6NED!;E??EA<=>@9!8>?TBX@! AJEA!;E??EA<=>!<@!!J>ED<;P!N?BM>@@!5>MEK@>!BC!@BM<>A6\@!OK>@A!CB?!J>?B>@9!0>! ED@B!@JBX@!AJEA!E;!?B!ME;!5>!LB?>!CEM!BC!J>ED<;P!AJE;!E!@!E?MJ>A6NED! J>?B9!);! AJ>!ME@>!BC!SMJ:!E;!?B!XJB!<@!A<>F!AB!AJ>!MBDD>MA<=>!L>LB?6!BC! E;BAJ>?!A?EP>F6!ME;!>LNJE@<[>!fEDD!AJ>!PBBF!AJEA!>Y<@A@!<;!@BM<>A6!F>@N
!@g! V 8>?TBXCKD!CB?!K;F>?@AE;F<;P!AJ>!?J>AB?; MBKND>F!X!P?BX<;P!<;CDK>;M>!BC!AJ>!GQ ^ JBK?!;>X@!M6MD>!5>MEK@>!J>!@JBX@!JBX!AJ>! L>F;A!J>ED<;P!ELF6!<;!@N!BC!LEAN?>@>;AEA!N>BND>!E@@BMF!XL9!0BX>=>?:! 8>?T BX;A!E5BKA!!F>P?>>!BC!@KNNB?A!K@>F!AB!ZK@A!?BD>!BC!AJ>! L6AJ?B!E;F!;>PD>MA@!AB!MB;@?!XJ6!YA9 +JBKPJ!;E??EA<=>!EDDBX@!CB?!E!LB?>!>LBAF?EP>!BC! A?EKLE@:!8>?TBX LB;@A?EA>@!JBX!AJ>!L>F@!;E??EA<=>!AB!?>@JEN>!AJ>! >YN>?<>;M>@!BC!A?EKLE!@K?=<=B?@!<;!B?F>?!AB!L>>A!AJ>!;>>F@!BC!E;!EKF<>;M>9!,@!8>?TBX@!AJ?BKPJBKA!J<@!XB?T:!;E??EA<=>!EDDBX@!CB?!A?EKLE@!AB!5>!MB;=>6>F!AB!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!<;! E!XE6!AJEA!< @!LB?>!EMM>@@<5D>:!E@!LKMJ!BC!AJ>!A?EKLE!AJEA!FB>@!BMMK?!<@!BCA>;!FYNDE<;!B?!F<@MK@@9!'E??EA<=>!5?@!AJ<@!PEN!56!NB?A?E6<;P!A?EKLE!<;!E!?>MBP;<[E5D>!CB?L:! B;>!AJEA!<@!BCA>;!>E@<>?!CB?!EKF<>;M>@!AB!F

@A!E;F!LE;EP>9! ,FF?TBXA6N>@ :!LKMJ!D!;E??EA<=>: EDDBX!CB?!BAJ>?X<@>!<;EMM>@@<5D>!N>?@B;@!B?!MJE?EMA>?@! <;!E!;E??EA<=>!AB!CF<@NB@>F!LBDF!B?!C:!>;E5D<;P!EKF<>;M>@!AB!K;F>?@AE;F!XJB!

PAGE 25

Ib AJ>@>!N>BND>!E?>!E;F!XJEA!LBA<=EA>@!AJ>L!56!NB@L!B;!>YA?> L>!>;F@!BC!AJ>! @N>MA?KL9! ! 4>"%"$*+8! # );!EFFYEL<;<;P!JBX!L>F?EP>!MBLND@!?>N?>@>;AEA!D
?EAK?>!F>D=>@!<;AB!AJ>!MBLND>Y@!BC!JBX!A?EKLE@!E?>! N>?LE;>;AD6!MBLL>LB?EA>F!<;!E!NK5D?A<;>;A!<;!?>PE?F@!AB! AJ>!N?B5D>L!BC!L>LB?!0BDBMEK@A9!);!J>?!5BBT:! 4)*+,*#*./#!>&#?&,")9#"B# :"%'!'$8 :!]>;;6!#FT<;@!E@T@:!f+B!XJEA!>YA>;A!<@!AJ>?>!E!A6N>!BC!nA?KAJ\!AJEA!<@!5>6B;F!A>DD<;P:! 5>6B;F!;E??EA<=>:!AJEA!E!@A?EE?!; E??EA<=>!B?!E;!B5Z>MA<=>!J<@AB?@og!VIIaW!+J<@!OK>@A@!LKMJ!BC!AJ>!?>@>E?MJ!AJEA!>YNDB?>@!JBX!AJ>!0BDBMEK@A! E;F!BAJ>?!A?EKLE@!@JBKDF!5>!?>N?>@>;A>F!<;!MB;A>LNB?E?6!MKDAK?>:!AJ?BKPJ!A>YA@!<;MDKF<;P! CLB?Y ELND>:!#FT<;@!F>@M?<5>@!JBX!XJ>;!0BDBMEK@A!@K?=<=B?@! CA!AJ>?EAB?@:!AJ>!@K?=<=B?@!JEF!>N@!E5BKA!AJ>!@J>>?!FDD<;P! AJ>!@AB?<>@!E;F!;E??EA<=>@!BC!AJ>?@B;ED!JB??B?@9!,@!@J>!>YNDE<;@!M<@>D6! AJEA!XJ@!BKA@!AJ>!D<;PK<@A?!AJEA!M@!XJEA!X>!MEDD!@BMED!?>ED<[EA@!XBKDF!;BA!5>!@B!>E@??>F!AB!XB?F@! XBKDF!KDAD6!@JEN>!AJ>!XE6!AJEA!AJ>!0BDBMEK@A!XBKDF!5>!?>N?>@>;A>F!<;!MBDD >MA<=>! L>LB?69! &;!AJ>!B;>!JE;F:!@MJBDE?@!?>MBP;<[>!AJ>!!BC!EMMK?EA>D6!NB?A?E6<;P!AJ>! >=>;A@!BC!AJ>!0BDBMEK@A!AJ?BKPJ!AJ>!XB?F@!BC!AJ>!=L@>D=>@h!B;!AJ>! BAJ>?!JE;F:!@MJBDE?@!K;F>?@AE;F!AJEA!AJ>@>!<;F<=!;BA!;>M>@@E ?!BC!

PAGE 26

IU N?>@>;A<;P!E!MBJ>?>;A!E;F!MBJ>@<=>!;E??EA<=>!BC!AJ>!KAF!<;!E! J<@AB?!0BDBMEK@A9!+J<@!A>;@EA>@!E;!>AJLLE:!N!NE@A!EPE<;@A!?>@N>MA!CB?! @K?=<=B?@\!>YN> ?<>;M>@!BC!AJ>!A?EKLE9!);!J<@!E?A! >;AF!f+J>!"J>AB??!E;F!AJ>!)LN>?EA<=>!BC!1?D!8>?;E?F ^ (B;ED@! E?PK>@!CB?!E!?J>AB??!AJEA!FB>@;\A!N?BFKM>!T;BXD>FP>!E;F!>YNDB?>@!XJEA!AJ<@! L>E;@!<;!?>DEA!LE;A?E!fEDXE6@! ?>L>L5>?:g!XJ;!?>N>EA>F!<;!AJ>! ECA>?LEAJ!BC!A?EP>F69!0>!CBMK@>@!B;!AJ>!?BD>!BC!>6>X@@!A>@A?!A?EP>F6!E;F! E?PK>@!AJEA!D!CB?L!BC!>=;M>!XJ>;!@!AB!A?EKLEA=>;A@9!4! >AJB@!BC!AJ>!>6>X@@!<@!MBLN? BL<@>F!5>MEK@>!AJ>?>!<@!E!PEN!5>AX>>;!XJEA!<@!X@@>F! E;F!XJEA!AJEA!N>?@B;!ME;!@E6!E5BKA!!EKAJ>;A!A>@A!@>>;!E@! OK>@A:!>@N>M!EKAJB?!@A?KPPD>@!AB!MB;=>6!AJ>!>YN>?<>;M>!<;!E!XE6!AJEA! ?>EF>?@!X?@ AE;F9!8>MEK@>!>6>X@@!A>@AAB?YN>MAEAAB??@N>MA<=>!<@! <;@KCC;Ah!<;@A>EF:!AJ>?>!LK@A!5>!E!@>NE?EA>!?J>AB??!E;F!@BM!<@!@MEK@>!;P>@!E;!>AJ?EA<=>!E@@BMF!X@!AJ>!MB;@>OK>;M>@!BC!MB;A<;KEDD6!>;CB?M<;P!YN>MAEAYA@!<;! ?>@NB;@>!AB!A?EKLE!@JBKDF!N?BFKM>!T;BXD>FP>9! );!AJ>MA@@E6@:! C'! .&88'.A#D'8*8!&)3#088*98#".#E&2)&8&.!*!'".#*./#!>&# 7"%"$*+8!5# 8>?;E?F ^ (B;ED@!E;F!"Z[>?:!EDB;P@!BAJ>?!EKAJB?@:!EMT;BXD>FP>! AJ>!N?B5D>L@!XX<;P!>6>X@@!A>@A=;M>!FK>!AB!AJ>!MBLN?BL<@>F! ;EAK?>!BC!AJ>!?J>AB?!XJ!A?6<;P!AB ?>MB;M!AJ<@!N>?@N>MA<=>!X?!NBA>;AN?>@>;A!AJ>!0BDBMEK@A9!);!@N
!BC!AJ<@:!AJ>!EKAJB?@!ELB;@A?EA>!AJEA!AJ>!0BDBMEK@A!

PAGE 27

GH ME;!<;F>>F!5>!@K5Z>MA!AB!?>N?>@>;AEA@N
!?@B;ED!F<@AE;M>!C?BL! LE;6!XJB!E?>!ED<= >!ABFE69!8>MEK@>!AJ>!@J>>?!F>NAJ!E;F!@>=>?!A?EP>F6!EDLB@A! PKE?E;A>>!AJEA!;B!EMMBK;A!XN?>@>;A!?;E?F ^ (B;ED@!E;F!*D>Z[>?\@! >CCB?A@!@>>L!OK!DBCA69!8KA!AJ<@!FLLE!<@!;BA!K;MBLLB;!EM?B@@!AJ>!D?EAK?>!BC!A?EKLE:! NE?ADEA!0BDBMEK@A9! ! ,@!@MJBDE?@!JE=>!;BA>F:!A?EKLE@!ME;!5>!B?<>;A>F!?J>AB?EMJE5D>!LBL>;A@! <;!B?F>?!AB!E=B;A@!BC!?>N?>@>;AEALEA@!EDD!ABP>AJ>?! 56!P?ENND<;P!X!<@@K>!BC!F>?<=<;P!L>E; <;P!C?BL!A?EKLEA=>;A@!<;@A>EF!BC!>;@K?<;P! J<@AB?@!JBX!AJ>!J<@AB?!C?BL!AJ>!0BDBMEK@A!JE@! ?>@KDA>F!<;!LE;6!?>M>;A!L>LB?!B=>?AD6!N>FEPBP!X?! >YNDN?>@>;AEA!0BD BMEK@A!>YN>?<>;M> i CB?!>YELND>:!EA!E!L>LB?!K@>!BC!LEAB?YA>?L<;EA?LE;6!<;!B?F>?!AB! F>D<=>?!E!LB?>!B=>?A!L>@@EP>!E5BKA!AJ>!JE?@J!?>ED;BM!VIGQW9!$KMJ!MB;A?B=>?@LB? OK>@A@!E;F!>YN>?<>;M>@!@JBKDF!5>!N?>@>?=>F! AJ?BKPJ!NK5DLB?!D?EAK?>!F>LB;@A?EA>@:!AJ>?>!<@!=>?6!D!MB;@>;@K@!B;! AJ>!>YA>;A!AB!XJ?@B;ED!;E??EA<=>@!@JBKDF!<;CB?L!NK5DLB?@>! ;E??EA<=>@!@JBK DF!@JEN>!E!LB?>!J<@AB??@AE;F<;P!BC!A?EKLEA=>;A@!<;!AJ>;AA69!+J<@!;BA!B;D6!MJEDD>;P>@!E;!<;F<=@A!DE?P>?! @BM@!BC!A?EKLE@!AJEA!E?>!MB;@A?KMA>F!E?BK;F!@KMJ!X@@>@9!+J>!A>;@AX>>; J<@AB?6!E;F!MBDD>MA<=>!L>LB?6!J!N?B5D>LEA!BC!L>LB?!F>@F!AB!CEM!E!@<;PKDE?!N>?@N>MA<=>!B;!AJ>!>=>;A!DC:!MBLNE?>F!AB!AJ>!LE;6! LKDAA>F!XE6@!AJ>!A?EKLE!XE@!>YN>?<>;M>F!56!AJB@>!XJB!>;FK?>F!
PAGE 28

GI .KMJ!BC!3E ?KAJ\@!XB?T!MBLND@!AJ>!;BALB?6!<;!?>DEALB;@A?EA<;P!AJ>!MBLND>Y@!BC!?>N?>@>;A<;P!A?EKLE@!EMMK?EA>D6!AJ?BKPJ!J<@AB?!B;>!JE;F:!@J>!EF=BMEA>@!CB?!fAJ>!NB@@<5?! @A?EC>?>;A?!5E@>F!B;!@!LBF>D@!BC!>YN>?<>;M>!E;F! ?>C>?>;M>Wg! V3E?KAJ!f-;MDEF!#YN>?<>;M>g!IIW9 $J>!@>>L@!AB!@KPP>@A!AJEA!E!LB?>! <;MBLND>A>!EMMBK;A!BC!J<@AB?6!<@!DD6!<;>=!XJ>;!EAA>LNA<;P!AB!MJ?B;!AJ>!;EAK?>!BC! =E?!@JEN>F!F?>;AD6!XJ>;!@!A?EKLE9!,A!AJ>! @EL>!A:!K;F>?@AE;F<;P!fAJEA!J<@AB?6:!D!A?EKLE:!<@!;>=>?!@\@!BX;:!AJEA!J<@AB?6! <@!N?>M<@>D6!AJ>!XE6!X>!E?>!F!<;!>EMJ!BAJ>?\@!A?EKLE@ g!V3E?KAJ f-;MDEF! #YN>?<>;M>g!GQW!LE6!5>!T>6!<;!N?BFKM<;P!E!LB?>!MBDDE5B?EA<=>!J<@AB?6!AJEA!NB?A?E6@!AJ>! MBLND>Y!?>DEAAX>>;!<;F<=!CEM>!BC!A?EKLE:!?EAJ>?!AJE;! ?>D6<;P!B;!C?EPL>;A>F!<;F<=@9!0BX>=>?:!AJ>?>!<@!E!MD>E ?!>AJLLE!<;!AJ>! LEA<;P!E!J<@AB?!K;?>LL!BC!JBX!;BA!AB! 5>A?E6!AJ>!NE@Ag!V3E?KAJ!f-;MDEF!#YN>?<>;M>g!GaW9 &;!AJ>!B;>!JE;F:!AJ>?>!<@!EDXE6@!E! F>@!AB!EMMK?EA>D6!NB?A?E6!AJ>!>=>;A@!BC!AJ>!NE@Ah!J BX>=>?:!D6!AJEA!AB!@BL>!F>P?>>:! AJ<@!<@!;BA!EDXE6@!NB@@<5D>!B?!C>E@<5D>:!?>@KDA<;P!<;!E;!<;MBLND>A>!N!BC!E!A?EKLEA=>;A9 ! &9?D8>7J &:HH<7>8E'D7;K:9'.>GG:7D7=? $MJBDE?@!JE=>!E;ED6[>F!JBX!?J>AB?@!>;EMA!AJ>@!AB!>@AE5D<@J!>AJB @!E;F! MBLLK;!AJ>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!A?EKLE:!KDAD6!M?>EA<;P!E!@>;@>!BC!MBLLK;9!);!J>?!E?A!>;AF:!f3BLLK;LED>!$K?=<=B?@!1@@<;P!

PAGE 29

GG AJ>!'B!*K;!"D=>@!<;AB!AJ>!XE6@!XBL>;!XJB!@K?=<=> F!B?!X@@>F! AJ>!'B!*K;!"!7B?>E;!XE?!A>DD!AJ>!AJ>?<;P!AB! BAJ>?@9!!,@!3JB@:!AJ>@>!XBL>;!C?!AJ>YN>?<>;M>@!AJ?BKPJ!AJ>!D>;@!BC! LBAJ>?JBBF9!#EMJ!XBLE;!F>C<;>@!BAJ>?!XBL>;!<;!AJ>!MBLLK;F!AJ>! A?EKLE!E@!E!F<@ENN>E?>F:!F>FF!B?!@K?=<=>F!LBAJ>?:!5KA!3JB@!AJEA!LBAJ>?JBBF!<@! E!fFBK5D> ^ >FP>F!?J>AB?=g!VdHW9!)A!EDDBX@!AJ>@>!XBL>;!AB!5B;F!XEMJ!BAJ>?!;BA! B;D6!E@!@K?=<=B?@!BC!AJ>!@EL>!>=>;A:!5KA!ED@B!E@!E!MBLLK;?@9!0BX>=>?:!E@!3JBYNDE<;@:!fAJ>!MB;M>NA!BC!3B;CKM?JBBF!JE@!>;E5D>F!AJ>!'B!*K;!"LED>!?J>AB?@! AB!E?A!AJ>?X<@>!K;@N>ETE5D>!L>LB?<>@h!6>A!B;!AJ>!BAJ>?!JE;F:!F! AJ>!C>LED>!;E??EAB?@!AB!ZKFP>!AJ>F!B;>@\!>YN>?<>;M>@!<;!AJ>!XE?! AJ?BKPJ!AJ>!C?!BC!E!@A?!AJEA!D>EF@!AB!PKg!VdHW9!+J<@! F>LB;@A?EA>@!JBX!A?EKLE!JE@!AJ>!NBA>;A!@K?=<=B?@\!BX;!@BM@!E;F! @>DC ^ N>?M>NA?>CB?>:!AJ>AJB@:!X J@B;EA>@!X?;E?F ^ (B;ED@\! E?PKL>;A!E5BKA!JBX!A?EKLE!F>A?EMA@!C?BL!E!?J>AB?\@!M?>F<5=>?:!5BAJ!E?A@!CE?!JBX!@K?=<=B?@!BC!A?EKLE!MBKDF!NBA>;APE<;!>AJB@ i CB?!>YELND>:!<;! M@!BAJ>?!AJE;!XJ>;!AJ>6!EAA>LNA!AB N?B=!E;!EMMK?EA>!J <@AB?!>=>;A i B?!JBX!?J>AB?@!ME;!<;MB?NB?EA>!ENN>ED@!BAJ>?!AJE;!>AJB@!<;!B?F>?!AB!5K!NBX>?!BC!LBAJ>?JBBF!E@!E!N?B=BMEA<=>!?J>AB?@AE5D<@J<;P!5BAJ! >AJB@!E;F!NEAJB@!X;!EKF<>;M> JE@!;BA!PB;>!K;;BAF!<;!AJ>!XB?T!BC!BAJ>?! @MJBDE?@9!'E;M6!.

?\@!E?A:!f+J>!*!%JBABP?ENJ/!+J>!S<>A;EL!1E?!E;F!AJ>! .ET<;P!BC!'EAK?ED!.>LB?6g!>YNDB?>@!JBX!AJ>!;BAB?A;EL>@>!PEAK?>F!<;!

PAGE 30

Gd AJ>!NJBABP?ENJ!AJEA!MEL>!AB!?>N?>@>;A AJ>!K;F<@M>?;<;P!JB??B?@!BC!AJ>!S<>A;EL!1E?! >@AE5D<@J>F!EP>;M6!AJ?BKPJ!J>?!?BD>!E@!E!LBAJ>?9!+B!@BD;@>!BC!EP>;M6:!AJ>! XBLE;!<;!AJ>!NJBABP?ENJ!ABBT!E!@>MB;F!N:!5KA!XJ!JBDF<;P!J>?!@B;!E;F!J?!@ME?@!C?BL!AJ>!;ENEDL9!);!5BAJ 3JB?\@!E?A@:!LBAJ>?JBBF!<@!K@>F!AB!>YNDE<;! AJ>!A?EKLE!>YN>?<>;M>F!56!AJ>!?J>AB?@9!4B?!AJ>!?J>AB?@!<;!3JB<\@!N<>M>:!AJ<@!ME;!ED@B!5>!K@>F! AB!ME@A!LB?ED!ZKFPL>;A!B;!BAJ>?!L>L5>?@!BC!AJ>!MBLLK;!<;!.
?\@!N<>M>:!AJ>! LBAJ>?JBBF!E;PD> <@!NE?A><;P!E@!JBX!AJ>!S<>A;EL>@>!XBLE;!JE@! A?E;@F!C?BL!E!=KD;>?E5D>!6BK;P!P?9!86!K@<;P!LBAJ>?JBBF!E@!E!ABBD!AB! @N>ET!AJ>!K;@N>ETE5D>:!AJ>@>!XBL>;!E?>!E5D>!AB!N?B=!BAJ>?@!X!<;@YN>?<>;M>@9 );!L>F?EP>!BC!A?EKLE@!<;=BD=<;P!XBL>;:!AJ>!;BA?JBBF!<@! >YNDBF!AB!>YEM>?5EA>!AJ>!!BC!E;!>=>;A:!B?!<;!AJ>!ME@>!BC!A>??B?<@L:!AB! NDEM>!E;!EFF?!BC!5DEL>!B;!AJ>!XBLE;!CB?!E5E;FB;<;P!E;F!A?EKLEA<[<;P!J>?! ? >DEA<=>@!V8>?TBX!8BL5>?@!E@!1BL>;!1E??;F!AJEA!AJ<@!K@>!BC!AJ>! >AJB@!BC!LBAJ>?JBBF!XJ>;!F<@MK@@<;P!A?EKLE!M?>EA>@!E!@>;@>!BC!F<@@B;E;M>!ELB;P!AJB@>! XJB!;A?@ E;F!LE6 >YN>?<>;M>!E!?E;P>!BC!?>EMA!5BL5> ?!XJB! MDE!EMA>F!<;!AJ>!5>@A!<;A>?>@A!BC!J>?!MJ;9!)A!<@!?!JBX!>CC>MA<=>D6!BAJ>?!@BM@:!XJ>;!ZKYAENB@>F!X?AE<;!A6N>@!BC!A?EKLE@:! LE6!>@AE5D<@J!>AJB@!<;!B?F>?!AB!>D?AE<;!?>@NB;@>@!C?BL!EKF<> ;M>@9! ,!=>?6!MD>E?!PEN!J>?>!<@!AJ>!DEMT!BC!D?EAK?>!B;!CEAJ>?JBBF!E@!E!CB?L!BC!>AJB@! AJ?BKPJ!XJ!A?EKLE!E;F!KDAD6!5KEA>! F<@@B;E;M>9!86!>YMDKF<;P!AJ>!?BD>!E;F!?JBBF!<;!MBLLK;F6:!AJ>! D< A>?EAK?>!FB>@!AXB!AJ<;P@/!<;CB?M>@!AJ>!@A>?>BA6NLBAF!

PAGE 31

GQ X?JBBF:!;>PD>MA@!AJ>!>OKEDD6!>LBA!BC!CEAJ>?@:!E;F!N>?N>AKEA>@!E! N>?M>NA;A>>!CEAJ>?@!K;<;=BD=>F!<;!AJ>!D<=>@!BC!AJ>; 9 $MJBDE? @!JE=>!B5@>?=>F!BAJ>?!XE6@!AJ>!L>FEA>@!F<@@B;E;M>!XJ>;!MB=>?<;P! A?EKLEA=>;A@:!<;!EFF@!AJEA!?>@B;EA>!X;M>@9!2>E=6!E;F!.EDB;>6!E?PK>!AJEA!AJ>!L>F?AE<;!A?EKLE@!E@!;EA=>;A@! XJ!LE?P<;ED<[<;P!BAJ>?!A?EKLE@:!AJ>?>56!N!XJB!>YN>?<>;M>F!A?EKLE@!;BA!XB?AJ6!BC!5><;P!N>?M><=>F!E@!E!LEZB?!>=>;A9! $N>M!EKAJB?@!MBLNE?>!3BDKL5<;>!E;F!AJ>!">F!2ET>!$MJBBD!@JBBA<;P@:!E?PK<;P! AJ EA!XJ!>EMJ!@JE?>F!@?<@A!5>MBL>!E!;EA! ">F!2ET>!$MJBBD!XE@!OK;9!+J<@!<@!5>MEK@>!AJ>!L>FF!3BDKL5<;>!FK>! AB!AJ>!N?!E;F!L ^ MDE@@!F>LBP?ENJ!=!">F! 2ET>!$MJBBD! XE@!LE?P<;ED<[>F!5>M EK@>!MA>F!E!DBX>? ^ MDE@@!MBLLK;!,L>?!EKAJB?@!OK>@A!N?>FBL<;E;AD6!XJ
!E;F!L!MDE@@!EKF<>;M>! AJEA!AJ>!N?>@@!@>>L@!AB!5>!AE?P>A<;P!E;F!AET>!<@@K>!X!CEMA!AJ EA!@KMJ!E!5!B?!F!?!@?N>AKEA<;P!XJ!N?<=P>! E;F!F>L>E;<;P!AJ>!DBX>?!MDE@@>@9! )!E?PK>!AJEA!5>MEK@>!@KMJ!A?>EAL>;A!C?BL!AJ>!N?>@@! <@BDEA>@!AJB@>!JE=>!>YN>?<>;M>F!fD>@@>?g!A?EKLE@:!! D;>F!AB!E;BAJ>?!CB?L!BC! A?EKLE:!E@!AJB@>!XJB!>YN>?<>;M>F!AJ>!CB?PBAA>;!A?EKLE!LK@A!;BX!F>C>;F!AJ>!@! BC!AJ>YN>?<>;M>9! .B?>!?>M>;A!@MJBDE?@J@!B;!AJ>!XE6!@K?=<=B?@!BC!A?EKLE!KA!FF!AJ>YN>?<>;M>@!X< AJ!D ^ L<;F>F!N>BND>!E;F!KDAD6!5KYNDB?>@!<;!J>?!E?A!f-;F>?@AE;F<;P!+?EKLE!m!AJ>!"J>AB?
PAGE 32

G_ BC!">MB=>?6/!,!(<@MBK?@>!,;ED6@<@!BC!SED<;P!]BK?;ED@!BC!3JYKED!,5K@>! $K?=<=B?@:g!F;=;A@!EDDBX!C B?!E!LB?>!EMM>@@<5D>!E;F!NK5D!CB?!@K?=<=B?@!AB! @JE?>!AJ>@!E;F!N?BM>@@!AJ>C!X?@9!+JBKPJ!<;!+JBLN@B;\@!>YELND>:!AJ>! @K?=<=B?@!E?>!<;J>?>;AD6!5BK;F!56!AJ>!MBLLB;!>YN>?<>;M>!BC!@>YKED!E5K@>:!6!BX;!E;F!MDEYN>?<>;M>!<;!E!NK5D!E;!B;D<;>!F<@MK@@6!5>MBL>!E!NE?A!BC!AJ>!MBLLK;@A@!<;!J>?! E?A!f365>? ^ $NEM>@!BC!*?<>C/!&;D<;>!.>LB?!3BDKL5<;>!0!<;A >?;>A!ED@B!EDDBX@!C?<>;F@!E;F!CEL!XJB!JE=>!F<>F!<;!E!A?EKLE! AB!@JE?>!AJ>LB?<>@!E;F!>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!P?<>C!XEMJ!BAJ>?9!$KMJ!E!@NEM>!N?B=@!E! LKMJ ^ ;>>F>F!BKAD>A!CB?!AJB@>!XJB!JE=>!@K?=<=>F!E!A?EKLE!B?!DB@A!E!DB=>F!B;>!<;!E!A?EKLE:! EDDBX <;P!AJ>L!AB!MB;;>MA!XXCBK;F!MBLLK;@AE5D<@J>F!AJ?BKPJ!AJ>MA!)!XBKDF!@E6!AJ>@>!EMA!AJ>!XE6!A?EKLE! JE@!5>MBL>!E!NE?A!BC!@K?=<=B?@\!;A@:!)!XBKDF!ED@B!@KPP>@A!AJEA!AJB@>!XJB!E?>!F 56!AJ<@!A?EKLE!LK@A!MJBB@>!AB!MDE;A?AE<;D6!5>! =<>X>F!E@!E!@ED<;P9!86!ZB<;<;P!E;!B;D<;>!MBLLK;!KDAD6! EMT;BXD>FP<;P!AJ>!!A?EKLE!JE@!LEF>!B;!AJ>@!E;F!EDDBX<;P!!AJ>AJB@!56!?>EMJ<;P!BKA!AB!BAJ>?@!XJB!LE6!ED@B!5>!LBA<=EA>F!AB!MBL>!AB!A>?L@!X! A?EKLEA=>;A!JE@!@JEN>F!AJ>@9 $MJBDE?@!ED@B!;BA>! AJ>!!BC!?>MBP;<[<;P JBX!<;CD@A>?;! K;F>?@AE;F<;P@!BC!A?EKLE!B;!BAJ>?!MKDAK?>@! LE6!M?>EA>!F<@@B;E;M>!56!CK?AJ>?!LE?P<;ED<[<;P! @K?=<=B?@!BC!A?EKLE@9!86!@A>?;!=<>X@!B;!AJB@>!XJB!5>DB;P!AB!BAJ>?!MKDAK?>@! E;F!JE=>!>YN>?<>;M>F!A?EKLE:!@MJBDE?@!?<@T!@A?@>!@K?=<=B?@!BC!EP>;M6!E;F!

PAGE 33

G` ;>PD>MA<;P!AJ>!MKDAK?ED!;KE;M>@!AJEA!LE6 B?!LE6!;BA!@JEN>!AJ>?>;A!XE6:! XJ@@>@!<;!J>?!E?A:!f1?!%BD?<;P!ELB;P!$BLEDAK?;>>@!<;!#AJ@! AJ<@! LE?P<;ED<[>!AJB@>!XJB!?>EMA!AB A?EKLE!<;!E!XE6!AJEA!FB>@!;BA!EFJ>?>!AB!1>@A>?;! >YN>MAEA?N>AKEA<;P! AJ>!N?B5D>LEAE!AJEA!AJ>?>!<@!E!?@NB;F!AB!A?EKLE:!XJ>;!<;!?>ED@@!AJ>YN>?<>;M>@!<;!E!XE6!AJEA!<@! K;!AB!AJ>? @B;ED@:!AJ>@:!E;F!AJ>=>?:!AJ>!?>ED!XJB!@JE?>!>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!A?EKLE!LE6!EMA!C!<;A>?>@A!BC!AJ>MEK@>!AJ>!A?EKLE!DC!ME;!>LNBX>?!E;F!MB;;>MA! AJB@ >!XJB!JE=>!>YN>?<>;M>F!!JBX!AJ>!L>F?N>AKEA>@!E!J<>?E?MJ6!BC! !<;!F>M!;EA?A!AJEA!@MJBDE?@!XJB!=<>X!B?! E;ED6[>!AJ>!>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!;B; ^ 1>@A>?;!N>BND>@!AJ?BKPJ!E!1>@A>?;!D>;@!?<@T!<;CD?@N>MA<=>!B;!BAJ>?!A?EKLE@!XJ!LE?P<;ED<[<;P!AJB@>!XJB@>!>YN>?<>;M>@!FB!;BA!EFJ>?>! AB!1>@A>?;!>YN>MAEA?G':B'$9D!N>FEPBP6!BC!A?EKLE!EA>?L<;>!JBX!AB!EFF?>@@!A?EKLE!<;!AJ>! MDE@@?BBL!ENN?BN? D6!E;F!>CC>MA<=>D69 +JB KPJ!LKMJ!BC!AJ>!D
?EAK?>!F>D=>@!<;AB!NBA>;AFEPBP@:!@KMJ!E@!C?>> ^ X??@EA@NB;F!AB!<;!AJ>!MDE@@?BBL!E;F!XJ6!<@!;BAE5D6!E5@>;A!C?BL!AJ>! @MJBDE?@J
PAGE 34

Ga ,@!E!MBLNB@?=>F! JBX!UcII! MB;A<;K>@!AB!@JEN>! NK5D:!)!EP?>>!X?A!XET>!BC!UcII:!E!;>X!ENN?BEMJ!AB! MBLNB@FEPBP6!<@!;>M>@@E?69!);!J<@!E;AJBDBP6:! 4)*+,*#*./#!>&*$>'.A#"B#C)'!'.A :! $JE;>!8B??BXLE;!@AEA> @!AJEA!UcII!<@!KDAD6!AJ>!>Y

;M6!AJEA!LBA<=EA>@!AJ>!MBDD>MA?LB?>:!J>!EMT;BXD>FP>@!AJ>!F@!BC!B?PE;<[<;P!AJ>!>@@E6@!<;!AJ<@!5BBT!5KA! >YNDE<;@!AJEA!AJ>6!f>Y<@A!X@A?6!BC!K;F>?@AE;F<;P!E;F!>YN>?<>;M>:!XJ>?>!J<@AB?6:! L>LB?6 :!E;F!A?EKLE!M?B@@!XFEPBP6!E;F!?J>AB?B?6g!V 8B??BXLE;! QW9!+J>!5BBT!DC!?><;CB?M>@!AJ>!;BA?>!<@!E!X!?E;P>!BC!?>@NB;@>@!AB!A?EKLE:! E;F!AJ>!?>!E?>!LE;6!XE6@!AB!A>EMJ!<;!A@!BC!A?EKLE9!) A! >;=<@!MBLNB@!XJ>?>!@!BC!A?EKLE!E?>!?>F:! L>E;<;P!<@!M?>EA>F:!;E??EA<=>@!E?>!>YNDB?>F:!MKDAK?>!<@!M?F:!E;F!A>YA@!ME;!5>!?> ^ ENN?BN?F9!+J>!F<=>?@YA!<@!@A!E@N>MA i ;BA!B;D6!FB!EKAJ B?@!X?! E5BKA!E!=E?<>A6!BC!A?EKLE@!<;!LKDA!J<@AB?YA@:!5KA!AJ>6!ED@B!EDDBX!CB?! L6??@AE;F<;P@!BC!AJ>!MBLNB@!XJ>;!@!AB!A>EMJ<;P! @AKF>;A@!<;!A@!BC!A?EKLE9 ,D@B!LBA<=EA>F!56!UcII!E;F!AJ>!&!")'$*%#4>&")9#*./# @",2"8'!'".#:&/*A"A95 EFF?>@@>@!AJ>!@EL>!MB;M>?;@!E5BKA!JBX!AB!<;MB?NB?EA>!M?<@<@!E;F! A?EKLE!<;AB!AJ>! MDE@@?BBL9 &;!AJ>!B;>!JE;F:!@ J>!E?PK>@!AJEA!E!NB@A ^ UcII!?J>AB?B?6! @JBKDF!NB@>!fE!MB;A>LNB?E?6!ENN?BEMJ!AB!CB@A>?<;P!M;@J;P<;P! N?>=C<;?@AE;F<;P@!BC!NEA?;A9!+JBKPJ!UcII!< A@>DC! ?>N?>@>;A>F!;BA!B;D6! AJ>!=KD;>?E5?@!D!

PAGE 35

Gb NEA?LBM?EM6:!.K?NJ6!JBN>@!AB!MJEDD>;P>!A>EMJ>?@!E;F!@AKF>;A@!ED!AB! F>=>DBN!F?EM6!<;!B?F>?!AB!M?YEL<;>!AJ>!MKDAK?ED!E?AF!<;! ?>@NB;@>!AB!M?<@>@!D!UcII:!<;@A>E F!BC!@!BC!M?!FK>!AB!AJ>=>;A@9!+J>!EKAJB?!ED@B! F>LB;@A?EA>@!AJ>!;=<@;@J!PDB5ED!E;F!<;A>?MKDAK?ED! N>?@N>MA<=>!<;!B?F>?!A B!?>MB;M!B;>@>DC!X!?>ED=BD=<;P!;>AXB?T!BC! ;EA@9!-DAD6:!AJ<@!X;P>!@AKF>;A@!AB!5>MBL>!LB?>! M??@!BC!MKDAK?>:!5KA!XNE?>!@AKF>;A@!AB!X?
!E;F!MBLNB@>!<;!E! LKDA@!.BCC>AA:!E@!MF!<;!.E?&#?'./J8# 09&3#K,*A&#*./#?&,")9#'.#C)'!'.A#*;"+!#4)*+,*5# ED@B!EF=BMEA>@!CB?!E!NB@A ^ UcII!N>FEPBP69! ,@!.BCC>AA!@AEA>@:!UcII!f5>PE;!E!;EA?@EAED<;P!A JEA!MBKDF! ;BA!5>!EMMBLND<@J>F!56!AXB!XB?DF!XE?@:!<;@AF!?EM<@L:!AJ>!S<>A;EL!nMB;CD! 5BL5<;P!BC!AJ>!C>F>?ED!5K@@!A?EP?>!X>!E?>!AJ>!LB@A!=KD;>?E5D> i BK?!MJ;g!V__W9! .BCC>AA!CBMK@>@!@N>M!>YM>>F<;PD6!=<@KED!E;F!@6L5BD!BC!UcIIh!E@!J>!;BA>@:!AJEA!C!BC!AJ>! A?EP>F6!XE@!@JBMT<;P:!5KA!B=>?!A:!AJ>!<;CDK>;M>!E;F!!CEF>@:!XJD6!XJ>?>!J>!AJ<;T@!A>EMJ>?@!ME;!<;A >?=>;>!E;F!CEM!AJ>!F>=>DBNL>;A!BC!B;D6!fE! @EF;>@@!AJEA!5>MBL>@!<;A>P?EA>F!<;AB!AJ>!?>@A!BC!Dg!V_aW9!);!?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!A>YA@!AJEA! @AKF>;A@!N?BFKM>!<;!AJ>!XET>!BC!E!A?EP>F6:!AJ>!<;@A?KMAB?\@!ZB5!<@!AB!D>A!AJ>!@AKF>;A!T;BX! XJEA!AJ>!A>YA!LET>@!=<@<5 D>!<;!NK?@K!AJEA!?>CD>MA@!E;!>LBA! @B?A9!86!>=EDKEA<;P!JBX!E!@AKF>;A\@!XB?F@!?>ND!AJ>!A?KAJ!AJEA!J>!B?!@J>!XE;A@!AB!

PAGE 36

GU MB;=>6:! AJ>!A>EMJ>?!5>MBL>@!E!PK:!E@@<@A<;P @AKF>;A@!<;!?>N?>@>;A<;P!AJ>!F>NAJ!BC!AJ>LBA< B;ED!ZBK?;>6@!AJ?BKPJ!X?MEK@>!MBLNB@@!LE6!CE=B?!>;F!PBED@!AJEA!CBMK@!B;!E!@AKF>;A\@!BX;! ;A;@>!BC!@>DC:!@MJBDE?@!ED@B!>YEL<;>!JBX!A>EMJ>?@!LE6!C>>D!B5DF!AB!CKDC@!X!MDE@@?BBL!56!?>@NB;F<;P!A B!E!@AKF>;A\@!F<@MDB@K?>!BC!A?EKLE!<;!E! NE?A@!.9!,;F>?@B;!E;F!.E?YNDB?>!<;!AJ>!;EAK?>!B C!AJ>!MBLNB@!>YN?>@@<=<@A!X?!A>EMJ>?@!XJB!E?>!K;@K?> BC JBX!AB! ?>@NB;F!AB!C>>D!LB?>!D!AJ>?EN<@A@!?EAJ>?!AJE;!X?!E;AJBDBP6:!,;F>?@B;!E;F!.EM3K?F6!@>A!BKA!AB!>YNDB?>!JBX!A>EMJ>?@!KA!fAJ>YN>?A<@>!E@!X?@@ ?@:!E;F!JKLE;!5><;P@!AB!J>DN!@AKF>;A@!M?>EA>!A>YA@! AJEA!>L5BF6!AJ>F!>YN>?<>;M>:!AJ>!MD>E?>@A!>YN?>@@=>?! K;F>?@AE;F<;P!BC!AJEA!>YN>?<>;M>!<@!E=E!AB!AJ>!@AKF>;Ag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
PAGE 37

dH @AKF>;A@ XJB!F<@MDB@>!>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!A?EKLE!BKA!BC!;>M>@@!E;>MFBA>@!<;!AJ<@! E;AJBDBP6!N?B=!=EDKE5D>!<;@!N?BFKMA<=>!E;F!ENN?BN?! ?>DEA@>!@AKF>;A@!<;!AJ>!MDE@@?BBL:!5KA!;BA!XJ>;!AJ>6!@A>N!BKA@!BC!AJB@>! 5BK;FE?<>@!E;F!EAA>LNA!AB!F<@MK@@!A?EKLE!X E@!E MB;C?AE<;D6!NE?A!BC! AJ>!A>??<;P!E!A>EMJ>?9 1J!AJ>!MBDD>MAFP>@!AJ>!AJ>?EN>KA!>LNJE@<@! <@!B;!AJ>!XE6!@AKF>;A@!E;F!A>EMJ>?@!LE6!X?
! E5BKA!A?EKLE!<;!B?F>?!AB!>;PEP>!LB?>! L>E;<;PCKDD6!X6!A>;E;A@!BC!MBLNB@FEPBP69!,;F>?@B;!E;F!.EM3K?F6! FBMKL>;A!@KMJ!MB;;>MA!MBLND>Y@!BC!?>N?>@>;AEADEA>!AB! B;>\@!BX;!;A;@>!BC!@>DCh!JBX!AJ>!@>DC!ME;!5 >!=<>X>F!E@!fA?E;@CB?LEA<=>:!E@! @BM;PEP>F:!E@!BN>;!AB!?>=<@AB?@!@AKF>;A@!XP<>@! CB?!MBN<;Pg!E;F!f>OK;A!CB?!D<=<;Pg!VdaWh!JBX!@AKF>;A@!ME;!KA!;E??EA<=>!AB!f@KAK?>g! AJ>L@>D=>@!<;AB!AJ>!F<@MBK?@>!BC!E;!BAJ >?!VIUHWh!JBX!X>E=<;P!>YN>?<>;M>@!<;AB!E! MBLN?>J>;@<=>!;E??EA<=>!ME;!CEM!?>MB=>?6!VbUWh!E;F!JBX!>@@E6@!FBMKL>;A<;P! BNN?>@@!K@>F!AB!M?!>Y<@A<;P!NBX>?!@A?KMAK?>@!E;F!BDBP<>@!VI_dW9!8>MEK@>! EDD!X?@@>;AF!<;!N>?@B; ED!>YN>?<>;M>:!MBLNB@!@AKF>;A@! X;@>@!E;F!N>?@N>MA<=>@!AJEA!AJ>6!ME;!ENND6!AB!BAJ>?!E@N>MA@!BC!AJ>@:! F>LB;@A?EA<;P!AJ>!A?E;@C>?E5!@T6!D>E?;!<;!AJ>!X?!@TDN!@AKF>;A@!LET >!@>;@>!BC!AJ>E;<;PCKD!XE69 ,@!"9(9!$ELK>D@!>YEL<;>@:!A>EMJ>?@!ME;!@>?=>!E@!PK@!XJ!J>DN<;P!@AKF>;A@! ;E=!AJ>@NB;@>@!AB!A>YA@!AJEA!F>ED!X=>;A@9!);!AJ<@!ME@>:!$ELK>D@! EEMJ!@AKF>;A@!JBX!AB!E;ED6 [>!AJ>@NB;@>@!AB!E!CA!FK?<;P!AJ>!

PAGE 38

dI 0BDBMEK@A!56!CYEL<;<;P!<;A>?;>A!K@>?@\!?>@NB;@>@!AB!AJ>!CF!<;!J<@! E?A:!f+J>!"J>AB?EMJ<;P!E5BKA!AJ>!0BDBMEK@A!E;F!%B@ALBF>?;!,CC>MA!<;!E;! ,F=E;M>F!3BLNB@9g!!+J>!E@@;A!DC!XE@!@A?KMAK?>F!AB!CBMK@!B;!fCBK?! LBF>@!BC!>LBA;@NB;F<;P!AB!A>YA@!E5BKA!A?EKLE/!;AED<[<;P:! K;<=>?@ED<[<;P:!E;F!E@@D@! Q_HW9!4D @ F>C<;>@!K;<=>?@ED<[<;P!E@!AJ>! 5>D<>C!AJE A!fAJEA!AJ>?>!<@!;B!<;J>?>;A!L>E;<;P!B?!=EDK>!BC!AJ>!?>N?>@>;AEA! F>C<;>@!;A;!fN>BND>!F>C>;F!EPE<;@A!J<@AB?6!56!MB;M>;A?EA<;P!B;!AJ>LBA@NB;@>@!AB!AJ>!J<@AB?N?>@>;AEAD@!Q_GW9!+B!!ED <[<;P:! $ELK>D@!>YNDE<;@!AJEA:!f86!?>CBMK@<;P!AJ>!>CC>MA!BC!AJ>!C!>CC>MA!AJEA!D=>@:!AJ>@>!@AKF>;A@!>;F!KN!ED<[<;P!5BAJ!AJ>!M?>EAB?!BC!AJ>!C?@B;ED!=EDK>@ g VQ_dW9!2E@AD6:!E@@AJ<;P!<;AB!E!;>X! MB;A>YA!5KA!ED@B!AB!NDE6!KNB;!?>MBP;<[E5D>!AJ>L>@!E;F!EAA?<5KA>@!CB?!E!P>;>?ED<[>F! EKF<>;M>g!V$ELK>D@!Q_QW9!,@!AJ>!EKAJB?!F>A>?L<;>@:!f56!JE=<;P!@AKF>;A@!X?
!E5BKA!AJ>LBA@!<;!E!M?EMJ>?@!ME;!J>DN!AB!E =B!N@>!LBF>@! V$ELK>D@!Q`dW9!+J?BKPJ!MB;C?B;A<;P!E;F!MJEDD>;P<;P!@AKF>;A@\!<;XE?FD6!CBMK@>F!?>@NB;@>@:! $ELK>D@!F>LB;@A?EA>@!JBX!MBLNB@EMJ>?@!E?>!E5D>!AB!AK?;!F<@MK@@!N?BFKMA<=>!MB;=>?@EA>D< ;P!AJ>!;>>F!AB!@EM?!@KMJ!E!PBED!CB?!AJ>! <;A>P?EMJ!@AKF>;A\@!N@6MJ>9 (<@MK@@?=>@!E;!>OKEDD6!!<;!(A!ED9\@!E?A!f(<@MK@@<;P! AJ>!-;CEAJBLE5D>/!3DE@@?BBL ^ 5E@>F!">@NB;@>@!AB!+?EP>F6:g!XJ!J>DNCKD PKD<;>@!CB?!<;@A?KMAB?@!D>EF<;P!MDE@@!F<@MK@@!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!UcII9!+J>!PKD<;>@! AJ>L@>D=>@!CBMK@!LB@AD6!B;!M?>EA<;P!E!@EC>!@NEM>! CB?!@AKF>;A@!AB!=B!BN<;
PAGE 39

dG >;@K?<;P!AJEA!AJ>!MB;=>?@EA@N>MACKD!E;F!BN>; ^ L<;F>F W :!PK@NB;F<;P! AB!F<@NDE6@!BC!>LBAYAKED<[<;P!AJ>!F<@MK@@;A;A!MB;M>?;@! E;F!>@AE5D<@J<;P!PBED@!CB?!AJ>!MB;=>?@EA!BC!AJ>!F@!BC!@KMJ!F<@MK@@!EKAJB?@!J!=EDK>!BC!@AKF>;A@!MBDD>MA<=>D6!E FF?>@@<;P!fAJ>!F@AF!56!MBLLK;F6g!V7E?FA!ED9!GGW9!86!@KMM>@@CKDD6!D>EF<;P!AJ<@!@B?A!BC! MB;=>?@EAEMJ>?!ME;!J>DN!@AKF>;A@!K;F>?@AE;F!AJ>!;>>F!CB?!D<@A>;<;P!E;F!E;! E5!>Y NDB?<;P!MB;;>MA?@B;ED! >YN>?<>;M>@9 1J!@BL>!BC!AJ>!D
?EAK?>!>YEL<;>@!JBX!A?EKLE!ME;!5>!E!K;YN>?<>;M>!<;! AJ>!MDE@@?BBL:!BAJ>?!@MJBDE?@!E?PK>!AJEA!AJ>!MDE@@?BBL!ED@B!CE=B?@!M>?AE<;!A?EKLE@!B=>?! BAJ>?@9!(ENJ;>!">EF\@!E?A!f1 ?!3DE@@V?BBLW!E@! 8B?F>?DE;Fg!>YEL<;>@!AJ>!X??DE;F!XJ>;!CBMK@<;P!B;!JBX!A?EKLE! MKA@!EM?B@@!@BMPB?<>@!E;F!MBLLK;@!AJEA!E?>!E;MJB?>F!<;!A6N;AP>!<;F<= ?@B;ED!>YN>?<>;M>g!V">EF!II`W:!EDDBX<;P!AJ>!MDE@@!AB! CK;MAF!MBLLK;=>?:!">EF!MDE! MDE@@?BBL!<@!B;D6!EMM>NAE5D>!!A?EKLE@!E?>!fED?>EF6!D>PF!<;!AJ>!NK5DL?>@!B?!CB?M>CKDD6!E?AF!56!@A?B;P!@BML>;A@g!VII`W:!NB@<;P! N?B5D>L@!CB?!@AKF>;A@!X?!@>YKED!=;M>9!,L?! D?EAK?>!B;!A?EKLE:!AJ<@!?>MB;M>NAKED<[EAYN>?<>;M>!<@!E;! K;K@KED!=B :!XJ!AB!>;MBK?EP>!;E??EA<=>!E;F!>YN?>@@<=<@A! X?!MDE@@?BBL!E@!E!K;YN>?<>;M>9!);!MB;ZK;MAFP<;P!AJEA! M>?AE<;!A?EKLE@!E?>!N?<=P>F!E;F!@;M>F!<;!AJ>!MDE@@?BBL:!@KMJ!E;!K;F>?@AE;F<;P! ME;!

PAGE 40

dd ED@B!BN>;!KN!MB;=>?@EA!AE5BB!;EAK?>!BC!M>?AE<;! >YN>?<>;M>@9!,@!E!MBLNB@DC:!JBX>=>?:!)!XBKDF!EAA>@A!AB!AJ>!F;PEP<;P!@AKF>;A@!<;!AJ<@!A6N>!BC!F<@MK@@D6!5>!XB ?AJ!AEMTD<;P9!)A! XBKDF!5>!;>M>@@E?6!AB!>@AE5D<@J!M>?AE<;!PKD<;>@!E;F!LBF>?EA@@K?<;P! @AKF>;A@!AB!F<=KDP>!B?!F<@MDB@>!AJ>YN>?<>;M>@!X?>!N>FEPBP<>@! BC!A?EKLE!XBKDF!5>;>C!<;A>?EMA@:!XJ;!P?ENND>@! X@!BC!F<@MDB@K?>9! +J>!MDE@@?BBL!E@!E!@NEM>!CB?!MBDD>MA<=>D6!XB?T<;P!AJ?BKPJ!A?EKLE!<@!E;!MA!BC!AJ>!D
?EAK?>!B;!AJ>!?J>AB?X!]9!'>XMBL5!>YEL<;>@!AJ>! MBLND>Y!?>DEAAX>>;!@N EM>:!@KCC>?<;P:!E;F!E5@>;M>!<;!AJ>!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!UcII9!.KMJ! BC!AJ>!E?A!<@!M>;A>?>F!E?BK;F!JBX!AB!AEDT!E5BKA!A?EKLE!<;!AJ>!MDE@@?BBL:!XJEA!@B?A!BC! @NEM>@!E?>!M?>EA>F!E;F!KAF!<;!AJ>!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!A?EP>F6:!E;F!JBX!AJB@>!@NEM>@!NDE6!E! ?BD>!<;!?>MB=>?69! ,CA>?!A?EP>F6:!@NEM>@!ME;!N?B=!AJ>!L>E;@!CB?!MBBN>?EA@@>;A!J>ED<;P!N?BM>@@ i AJ?BKPJ!AJ>!K@>!BC!D<@A>;<;P!E;F!E@T<;P!OK>@A!ME;!ED@B!fE@@<@A!K@!<;!>YNB@<;P!JBX!=EDK>@!CB?!E!@AB?6!E?>!M?>EA>F:!J;:!E;F! @JF :g!V '>XMBL5! a_aW!BCC>?<;P!<;@@!E?>!@;M>F!B?!P<=>;!E!NK5DXMBL5!MB;;>MA@!AJ<@!@>;@>!BC!E5@>;M>!AB!X?;!J>!@AEA>@:!fX??<;P!<;=BD=>@!?>MB;A>YAKED<[<;P!E5@>;M>@!@B!AJEA!AJ>6!X!FMA!K@>@!CB?!B AJ>?! @N>M@:!'>XMBL5\@!XB?T!<@ MBLND>Y! E;F!F!AB! AJ>!>YA>;@<=>!6>A!;>M>@@E?6!EAA>;A!P<=>@!AB!LKDA!=B@:!?E;P<;P!C?BL!AJ>! @AKF>;A@!<;!J<@!MDE@@!AB!J<@!.K@D< PJ5B?:!<;!AJ>!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!UcII 9!0BX>=>?: '>XMBL5\@! XB?T!@>?=>@!AB!J!XE6!A?EKLE!ME;!M?>EA>!E5@>;M>@!E;F!JBX!B;>!CK;FEL>;AED!

PAGE 41

dQ LBA<=EA@NB;@>!AB!A?EKLE!<@!AB!C!E5@>;M>!X!T<;F!BC!N?>@>;M>:!XJ>AJ>?! LB?AJ<;P!>D@>9!+ET<;P!AJ<@!<;AB!EMMBK;A <;!AJ>!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!E!A?EKLE! XBKDF!5>!=EDKE5D>!CB?!E!MBLNB@EMJ>?!AB! FB!<;!AJ>!MDE@@?BBL h!C?>>!X?!E!@LEDD!5KA!AJ>?EN>KAP6!AJEA!@AKF>;A@!ME;!P?E@N!B;AB!<;!B?F>?!AB! C>>D!E@!AJBKPJ!AJ>6!E?>!C!@B?A!BC!PEN!< ;!?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!A?EKLE!EA!JE;F9!! &;>!NBA>;A!N>FEPBP?EAK?>!B;!A?EKLE!<@!F>M;!E;F! JBX!AB!EFF?>@@!E!A?EKLE:!B?!<;!BAJ>?!XB?F@:!XJ!XB?AJ6!BC!EFF?>@@<;P!<;!AJ>! MDE@@?BBLo!3D>E?D6:!A?EKLE@!AJEA!E?>!F>>L>F!;EA !LB?>!DD6!AB!N>?L>EA>!AJ>! D<=>@!BC!@AKF>;A@!AJ?BKPJ!AJ>!;>X@:!5KA!DBMED!A?EKLE@!E@!X>DD!LE6!5>!JE?F!AB!9!,@!E;! <;@A?KMAB?:!AJ<@!<@!B;>!BC!L6!5@A!MJEDD>;P>@!<;!AJ>!MDE@@?BBL:!6>A!AJ>!MK??>;A!D
?EAK?>! FB>@!D!AB!J>DN!L>!?>MAL9!+B!L>:!AJ<@!<@!E!P?B@@!B=>?@! @MJBDE?@J?!AEMTD>@!A?EP>F<>@!AJEA!E?>!!AB!:!D!UcII:!B?!@@!AJEA!<;@A?KMAB?@!T;BX!XJ>;!AJ>6!LK@A!EFF?>@@!E!A?EKLE!<;!AJ>!MDE@@?BBL9!)!XBKDF! E?PK>!AJEA!@MJB DE?@!LK@A!AET>!E!@A>N!5EMT!E;F!CYEL<;>!XJEA!L>?!F>C<;D6!F>M!XJ!MDE@@?BBL9!)@!F!B;!AJ>!@MBN>!B?!@>=>?!A?EP>F6:!B?! FB>@! @KMJ!E!F>M<@N>;F!LB?>!B;!AJ>!F>LBP?ENJ!MDE@@?BBL!DCo!+J>! D?EAK?>!MK??>;AD6!5?<;P@!L>!;B!MDB@>?!AB!E;@X>?<;P!AJ>@>!OK>@A!AB! >;PEP>!X!L>E;<;PCKDD6!DEA>?!B;!<;!L6!E;ED6@<@9! !

PAGE 42

d_ 39?G>;?78>DI'%C?8:9>= 1@;AAB??>!<@!LKMJ!F>5EA>!E5BKA!AJ>!NK?NB@>!E;F!=EDK>!BC! AJ>!C<>DF:!E@!LE;6!@MJBDE?@!JE=>!>;PEP>F!<;!AJ>!EMA!BC!f;E=>D ^ PE[<;P9g!+JBKPJ!@MJBDE?@!JE=>! =E?<>F!K;F>?@AE;F<;P@!BC!XJ6!AJ>!C<>DF!LEAA>?@:!LE;6!@MJBDE?@!JE=>!;AF!XE6@!<;! XJ C<>DF!LK@A!EFENA!E;F!MJE;P>!<;!B?F>?!AB!T>>N!KN!X!?EN=BD=<;P!NBDF@!AJEA!@JEN>!AJ>!D
?EAK?>9!1J! AJ>!D?EAK?>!JE@! BCA>;!CBMK@>F!B;! E;ED6@>@!BC! NE?A@;M<>@:!P>;?>@!BC!@N>>MJ>@:!B?!>=>;A@:!C>X!@MJBDE?@! JE=>!XB?T>F! AB!@JEN>!AJ>!P>;?>!BC!M?<@<@!?J>AB?CC>MA<=>!E;F!LE;EP>E5D>!XE69!+JBKPJ!M?<@<@! ?J>AB?C>?@!AB!<;A>?;EA@:!@MJBDE?@!JE=>!?>M>;AD6!NE!EAA>;A@A@:!XJ!BCA>;!AET>;!E!5EMT@>EA!AB!B;PB< ;P!MB;CD!AJ>!3BDF! 1E?W!EA!AJ>!CB?>C?B;A!BC!AJ>!NBD?@EA@KDA:!AJ>?>!<@!=?!?>C<;<;P!AJ>!P>;?>!BC!M?<@<@!?J>AB?! FBL>@A@:!E@!C?BL!AJ>!=>?6!;>XD6!F>C<;>F!@K 5 ^ P>;?>!BC!;EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?!?J>AB??EAK?>!?>=<>X:!)!E?PK>!AJEA!AJ>!C<>DF!DC!LK@A!MB;A<;K>!EFENA<;P!AB!@K! MJE;P<;P!F>LBP?ENJ!N?>@;M6!E;F!AJ>!MJEDD>;P>@!BC!;>X!L>F@@>D!CB?! NBDAB??LB?>:!)!@JB X!JBX!AJ>!P>;?>!BC N?>@;AAB?E=>@! LKMJ!AB!5 >!F>@F!E@!;AD6!F>C<;>F! E;F!LK@A! ED@B!T>>N!NEM>!X!<;M?>E@<;PD6! MBLND>Y!K; F>?@AE;F<;P@!BC!FBL>@A@!<;!B?F>?!AB!5>!K@>CKD!E@!E!P>;?>!X!C<>DF! BC!N?>@;AAB?!F>C<;@;AAB?DC!<@!BCA>;!XD6!F>5EA>F!E;F!?>F>C<;>F!56! @MJBDE?@!E@!A>MJ;BDBP@!@JAB?!J<@!F>C<;>L!E!5BFB?>!&AAB!1<;FA!]?9!F>C<;>@!AJ>!F<@M!56! AJ>!?>DEA
PAGE 43

d` 5>AX>>;!AJ>!N?>@;A!E;F!AJ>!NK5D!@N>M!F>@M?<5>@!AJ>!C<>DF!BC! N?>@;AAB?YEL<;EA!XE6!N?>@;A@!ENN>ED!AB!MB;@A;A@!E;F! @K5@>OK>;AD6!fPE<;:!LE<;AE<;!B?!DB@>!NK5D!A>Y A@!CB?!E;ED6@<@!E?>! KDAD6!AJ>!fNK5DL>;A@g!P<=>;!56!E!N?>@;A!VIHGW9!,;ED6@>@!BC!@KMJ!A>YA@!BCA>;! CBMK@!B;!@<;PD>!@N>>MJ>@:!NE?A@@>@!E;F!M?<@<@!@N>>MJ>@:!E@!X>DD!E@! ?J>AB?L>;A@!AJEA!E;M<> @:!AB!P>A!D>P<@DEAF:!pE;Fq!AB! F>C>;F!EPE<;@A!MB;A<;K<;P!BNNB@@g!VIH`W9!0BX>=>?:!AJ>!C<>DF!ME;!ED@B! >;AE;?>!@AKF<>@!AJEA!>YEL<;>!@@!<;!?J>AB?@;M<>@!VIH`W9!+JBKPJ! N>?JEN@!E!5F:!1<;FA!]?9\@!E? A!?E<@>@!@BL>!<;A>?>@A<;P!OK>@AX!L>F;FE ^ @>AA<;P!BC!;EA@gVIIHWo!E;F! fXJEA!E?>!AJ>!?J>AB??>;M>@!5>AX>>;!MELNE?;<;Pg!VIIIWo )!XBKDF!EP?>>!AJEA!5BAJ!OK>@A< B;@!E?>!!C<>DF!AB!AEMTD>9!);! B?F>?!AB!ZK@AF!E;ED6@<@!BC!N?>@;AYA@:!@MJBDE?@!XBKDF!DD6!;>>F!AB!>YNDE<;! JBX!AJ>!=E?<>A6!BC!L>FF!AB!MB;=>6!@KMJ!A>YA@!LE6!FMAD6!<;CDK>;M>!D>P<@DEA5EA>9!1 !P?BX<;P!F?>!N?>@;A@!ME;!>;PEP>!FMAD6!X?@!E;F!MB;@A;A@:!2E!BC!E;!<;M?>E@<;PD6!MB;=>?@EA@;AAB?>L@!OK
!NDEK@<5D>9!,@!NBD@!5>MBL>!CBFF>?!CB?!<;A>?;>A!L>L>@!E;F!=< ?ED! =B@:!)!XBKDF!NB@>!AJ>!E!AJEA!>AJB@!XMBL>!JE?F>?!E;F!JE?F>?!CB?!N?>@;A@!AB!LE<;AE<;9!$!LB=>@!BC!>=>?6!N?>@;A!E?>!FBMKL>;A>F! <;!AJ>!>YA>;@<=>D6!F?E<;<;P!MELNEE@B;!D>EF<;P!KN!AB!AJ>!>D>MA ?@!ME;!LB?>! >E@!CB?!5?BT>;!N?BL<@>@!E;F!CB?PBAA>;!@DBPE;@9!8>MEK@>!E! =B!MD!MDB@K?>!BC!*KE;AE;ELB!8E6!XJ!?K;;<;P!CB?!

PAGE 44

da N?>@;A!<@!EMM>@@<5D>!AB!=FA:!= BA>?:!B?!5DBPP>?!EA!E;6!A:!@KMJ! N?BL<@>@!ME;!EDXE6@!5>!5?BKPJA!AB!AJ>!CB?>C?B;A!BC!=BA>?@\!MB;@M@@:!D>EF<;P!AJ>L!AB! OK>@A@;A\@!@J@!B;M>!AJ>6\?>!<;!BCC9!%>?JEN@!LB?>! OKE;A!@AKF<>@!AJEA!?E;T!AJ>!C?>OK> ;M6!BC!M>?AE<;!XB?F@:!D!f>MB;BL6:g!fJ>EDAJME?>:g! E;F!fPK;@:g!<;!MELNE>MJ>@!=@9!N?>@;AYA@!LE6!N?B=!LB?>!<;@! N?@!BC!N?>@;AAB?6!>=BD=>9 ! );!AJ>!@EL>!XE6!AJEA!N?>@;AAB?!<;=>;AX! A>MJ;BDBP<>@:!MBL>!MD>E?!AJEA!LKMJ!BC!AJ>!@MJBDE?@J!?J>AB?@;M6! <@!OKMBL<;P!BKAFEA>F!5>MEK@>!@!E!N?>@;A!XJB!<@!E!XJ
!LED>9!,@!.E?6! $AKMT>6!>YEL<;>@!<;!J>?!E?A:!f">AJ<;T<;P!AJ>!"J>A B?@;M6!E;F!%?>@;AAB??@AE;F<;P!BC!N?>@;A?!JE@!N?>;!<;CB?L>F!56!fKNN>?! MDE@@:!@A?E!LED>!>YN>MAEA@g!VdUW9!$AKMT>6!;BA>@!AJEA!AJBKPJ!E! P?>EA!F>ED!BC!N?<=P>!<@!?>OKF!<;!B?F> ?!AB!EAAE<;!AJ>!BCC!BC!AJ>!N?>@;M6:!LE;6! N?>@;A@!JE=>!PB;>!BKA!BC!AJ>;!AJ>L@>D=>@!AB!AJ>!MBLLB;!,L>?!@A@>?=<;P!AJ>;@>!BC!@AEAK@!VQIW:!N?>@>;A<;P!E;!<;A>?>@A<;P!NE?EFBY!<;!AJ>AB??!EFF<;P!AB AJ<@!MBLND>Y@;A@!XJB!BCA>;!N?>@>;A!AJ>L@>D=>@!E@! @N>ET<;P!CB?!AJ>!>=>?6FE6!,L>?!K@KEDD6!B;D6!@N>ET<;P!CB?!AJ>!L!MDE@@!,L>??AX<;>F!X@!BC!MDE@@!E?>!M>?AE<;D6!<@@K>@!BC!?EM>:!E;F!E@!$AKMT>6!E?PK>@:!AJ>! >D>MAF!AJ>!C<>DF!X;A6!BC!BNNB?AK;AJ<;T<;P! AJ>!N?>@;M6!E@!@BD>D6!E!XJ!>YNDB!<@!ED@B!EXE?>!BC!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!&5ELE! MBKDF!@A?6!X>DD!f>;EMA!AJ>!;B?L@!BC!XJ;>@@g!VQIW9!$AKMT>6!ED@B!F<@MK@@>@!JBX AJ>! N?>@;M6!<@!M>?AE<;D6!E!NEA>?;ED<@A:!fXJ>?>!BK?!;EAYN>MAEA;F>?!E?>!

PAGE 45

db N>?CB?L>F!E;F!?Fg!V $AKMT>6! QQW9!+J<@!N?>@>;A@!NE?A;P>@!ABXE?F! ME;F@!XJB!FB!;BA!C!A?EF!LED>!;B?L:!<;!AJ>!@>;@>!A JEA!XBL>;!LK@A! N?B=>!AJ>;PAJ!E;F!fABKPJ;>@@g!V $AKMT>6! QQW!E;F!OK>>?!ME;F@!LE6!5>!N>?M><=>F! E@!AJ?>EA>;<;P!AJ>!LE@MKD<;!NB@6! Q_W9!+J>!EMM>@@<5@;A>MJ>@!JE@!ED@B!X;>F!AJ>!@MBN>!BC!A>YA@!AJEA!MBKDF!5> MB;@?>F!N?>@;A:!XJ!MJEDD>;P<;P!@AE;FE?F!;BAAX>>;!AJ>!N?>@;A!E;F!AJ>! NK5D6! QaW9 &;>!E?>E!BC!>LNJE@<@!X!@MJBDE?@J!P>;?>!BC!N?>@;AAB?=BD=> F!B=>?!A!X!K; !M< ?MKL@AE;M>@!BC!>EMJ!N?>@;M69!. B?>! ?>M>;AD6:!AJ>!@MJBDE?@JF!B;!JBX!AJ>!N?>@;A!>@AE5D<@J>@!E!LB?>!C?<>;FD6! ?ENNB?A!X!,L>?@;AAB?B?P>! 1E@J<;PAB;!AB!8?A@!AJEA!N?>@;AAB?MBL>!LB?>! fE;A< ^ <;A>DD>MAKED:!E5@A?EMA:!E@@>?A<=>:!F>LBM?EA?@EA?! ;BA>@:!AJ>?>!JE@!5>>;!fE!@!N?>@;M6!EA!AJ>!AK?;!BC!AJ>! AX>;A<>AJ!M>;AK?6! C?BL!E!A?EF:!E;F!K;?J>AB?!<;AB!E!LBF>?;:! >YNE;@<=>:!E;F!@A?;AD6!?J>AB?!<;!XJ;A@!?BKA<;>D6!@N>ET!B=>?!AJ>!J>EF! BC!3B;P?>@@!E;F!AB!AJ>!NK5DEF!E;F!AB!PB=>?;g!VdGUW9!,@!F>LB;@A?EA>F!56!2YEL< ;EA@;A@@EP>@:!E?!AJEA!@KMJ!?J>AB?MBL>!LB?>!fN>BND> ^ B?<>;A>Fg!<;@A>EF!BC!5><;P!CBMK@>F!B;!D>EF>?@!E;F!?>N?>@>;AEA<=>@!<;! PB=>?;L>;A!VddUW9!+J<@!MJE;P>!<@!ED@B!ENNE?>;A!<;!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!LB?>!N?>@;A< ED!?J>AB?C>?>;M>@!CEL;!E;F!>LNJE@<[>@!AJ>!N?>@;M6!E@!LB?>!BC!E!MBL?EF>@JEF!BC!E;!EKAJB?!N?>@;A\@!DD
PAGE 46

dU fF>NDC!E@!E!@BD>!@NBT>@LE;!CB?!AJ>!;EA?NDE 6!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!AJ>! ,L>?L!BC!PB=>?;L>;A!<@!E!@6@A>L!BC!@>NE?EA>F!NBX>?g!V 2@;AAB?MBL>!LB?>!<;MDK@<=>:!CBMK@>F!B;!5?<;P<;P!,L>?;@! ABP>AJ>?!56!K@<;P!XB?F@!@KMJ!E@!fK;
g!E;F!56!EMT;BXD>FP<;P!@ BM<>A6\@!LB@A!=KD;>?E5D>!<;! !XB?F!fNB=>?A6g!V 2<;CB?M>!?@EAMA@:! AJ>!C<>DF!JE@!DBBT>F!EA!JBX! N?>@;A@!JE=>! <;M?>E@<;PD6!?>D<>F!LB?>!B;!=E?ED@!AB!>AJB@9!86!ENN>ED<;P!AB!AJ>?@>! ?E; P>!BC!?BD>@:!N?>@;A@!E@AE5D<@J!AJ>@@!E;F!JE=>!KAF!LB?>! E;>MFBA>@!AB!LET>!AJ>L@>D=>@!LB?>!?>DEAE5D>!AB!MB;@A;A@!V 2FP>@!AJEA!@KMJ!MJE;P>@!LE6!LET>!N?>@;AAB??@F:!J>!MEK A!K@>!BC!DBPB@!E@!E!@BDKA?\@!LE;!AJEA!2@!<@!DBBT!AB!BAJ>?!NBA>;AMA!<@@K>!BC!?J>AB?CC>MA<=>D6!NEA?B;<[>@!AJ>!,L>?BND>9!0BX>=>?:!M?\@!B=>?K@>!BC!DBPB@!@>>L@! AB!5>!@AJB@!E;F!DBPB@!E@!NBDE?!BNNB@@:!;>PEA<;P!E;6!E!BC!5EDE;M<;P!?J>AB?ED@9!S=>?6!NBD@!CEMA!<;!@BL>!XE6!<;!B?F>?!AB!LET>!E!NB<;A:! XJ>AJ>?!;EAB?!]BJ;!76D\@!@AEA >L>;A!AJEA!fE5B?ADD!B=>?!UH!N>?M>;A!BC!XJEA! %DE;;>F!%E?>;AJBBF!FB>@g!V (X6>? W!B?!3B;P?>@@LE;!+BFF!,T<;\@!E@@>?A!C>LED>! 5BF6!ME;!>LNDB6!F>C>;@>!L>MJE;<@L@!<;!B?F>?!AB!C>;F!BCC!E!?EN<@A!V #D:!AJ<@!<@;\A!EMM>NAE 5D>:!5KA!)!XBKDF!E?PK>!CB?!E!LB?>!>AJF!ENN?BEMJ!AB! NBDAB??!AB!?>@N>MA!AJ>!<;A>DD>MA!BC!AJ>!,L>?BND>!E;F!CB@A>?!E!LB?>! B5Z>MA<=>!>;=;A!CB?!F>5EA<;P!NBD@9!

PAGE 47

QH 1!C<>DF:!AJ>?>!@>>L@!AB!5>!LKMJ! F>5EA>!B=>?!XJ6!AJ>!@AKF6!BC!N?>@;A?@!E;F!JBX!!NBD@@9!,@!]EL>@!'9!(?KMTLE;!E;F!]K@A<;! 19!0BDL>@!E?PK>!<;!f(B>@!%?>@;AAB??o!%?@;A@;A@!ME;!K@>!?J>AB?!AJ>M! EKAJB?@!EFF?>@@!AJ>!A>MJ;!BC!N?D6!JENN>;@!XJ>;!AJ>!L>F;A:!EDDBX<;P!AJEA!<@@K>!AB!<;CDK>;M>!AJ>!NK5D?M>NA@;A\@!N>?CB ?LE;M>!Va_aW9!)C!(?KMTLE;!E;F!0BDL>@\!N?>L<@>!<@!A?K>:!AJ>;!AJ>! ?;L>;A!<@!;BA!@B!JBA i N?>@;A@!E?>!ZKFP>F!LB?>!56!AJ>>A ^ AEDT!=BA>?@!?EAJ>?!AJE;!AJ>!OKEDE@!E;F! NBD@9!+JBKPJ!AJ>!EKAJB?@!JE=>!@J>F!DL:!XJEA!<@!K;MD>E?!<@!XJEA!@B?A!BC! >AJ!F<@M!BC!N?>@;AAB??!F>C<;!C<>DF!JE=>!5>>;!K; F>?!@M?KA<;6!E@!X>DD9! (E=C@T6:!<;! J<@!E?A!>;AF!f%?>@;AAB?!%BX>?!BC!(>C<;@A! F>C<;@;AAB?CC>MA@:g!@E6<;P!AJ>6!E?>!5BAJ!ABB!;E??BXD6! K;F>?@ABBF!E;F!B=>?@!N? BM>@@!BC!MBLLK;!;EAK?>!BC!?J>AB?!N?>@>;A@!d!N>?@N>MA<=>@!AJEA!ME;!5>!KAF!<;!E;ED6[<;P!N?>@;AAB??@N>MA<=>@Wh!JBX>=>?:!J>!ED@B!E?PK>@!AJEA!@MJBDE?D6!K;F>?@AE;F<;P! BC!N?>@;A AB?!DF!AB!ZK@A!B;>!BC!AJ>@>!N>?@N>MA<=>@g!V`HUW9! ">@>E?MJ>?@!LE6!ED@B!MB;@?!@AKF6<;P!N?>@;AAB?6>!AB!BCC>?<;P!;>X! N>?@N>MA<=>@!B;!AJ>!ME@>!EA!JE;F!AB!@KPP>@A<;P!5?BEF>?!N?<;M@!AJEA!XDN!AB!>YNDE<;! ?J> AB?!LB?>!P>;>?EDD6g!V`IIW9!,@!kE?>C@T6!E?PK>@:!N?>@;AAB?C<;>@!

PAGE 48

QI NBDEDC@T6!N?>@>;A@!E;!EDA>?;EA<=>!J>K?<@A@;AAB?YEL<;>@!AJ>!XE6!N?>@;A@!?>F>C<;>!MB;M>NA@!E ;F!E@!E;F! JBX!XD6!EMM>NA>F!AJB@>!F>C<;MBL>9 )A!<@!MD>E?!C?BL!L6!>YEL<;EA@>!@MJBDE?@!AJEA!AJ>!C<>DF!DC!JE@!5>>;! MB;@<@A>;AD6!K;F>?PB<;P!E;!;A!BC!JBX!>N!NEM>!X=>DBN<;P!P>;?>@: X>E?6!BC!LNJE@<@!B;!XJ
!LED>!N?>@;A@:!E;F! <;@>MK?>!E5BKA!@!E;F!@9! ! 39?G>;?78>DI'%?GF:7G?'8:'.>GDG8?9 &;>!@K5 ^ MEA>PB?6!X!C<>DF!BC!N?>@;AAB?@!B;!N?>@;A@NB;@>@!AB!M?<@<@:!XJCC>MA<=>D6!5>MBL>!;?>!BC!N?>@;AYA9!+J>! LB@A!?!<;!AJ<@!@K5 ^ MEA>PB?6!BC!N?>@;AAB?! LKDA!>Y

;M<>@!AJEA!LE6!@BK@D6!LBA<=EA>!E!N?>@;A\@!?>@NB;@>!AB!E!F<@E@A>?9! 7>=<;!.M3DK?>!C BMK@>@!B;!B;>!NE?AY

;M6 i ;EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?@ i <;!J<@!E?A!f+J>! "J>AB??/!+J>!%?>@;A?!,FF?>@@!E@!E;!#L>?P>;A!*>;?>9g!0>! E?PK>@!AJEA!N?>@;A?!?>@NB;@>@!MBLN?<@>!AJ>!P>;?>! V.M3DK?>!I W9!4B?!B;>:!AJ>6!DEMT!JKLE;!MKDNE5EF!EAA?<5KA>F!AB!;EAK?>!B?!CEA>! V.M3DK?>!GW9!3?<@>@!AJEA!E?>!;BA!E!?>@KDA!BC!;EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?@!BCA>;!<;=BD=>!E!MB;CDAX>>;! PBBF!E;F!>=OK@!L!;EAK?ED!F<@E @A>?@!E?>! K;@BDF!N?B5D>L@:!BAJ>?!M?<@>@!E?>!>=BT>F!56!AJ>!N?>@;A\@!?>@NB;@>!V.M3DK?>GW9! +JBKPJ!.M3DK?>!CBMK@>@!B;!;EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?@!E@!E!@<;PKDE?!>Y

;M6:!J>!N?B=@!AJ>! >YELND>!BC!*>B?P>!19!8K@J!JE=<;P!AB!JE;FD>!5BAJ!0K??!7EA?<;E!E;F!AJ>!@D BX!?>@NB;@>!

PAGE 49

QG BC!4#.,!E@!E!@?>!5BAJ!AJ>!;EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?!DC!E;F!AJ>!L<@JE;FD<;P!BC!!FKED!>Y

;M<>@9! 'EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?!?J>AB?@!@>=>?ED!K;!MJE?EMA>?<@A?!P>;?>!BC!F<@E@A>?!?J>AB?;>?ED9! .M3DK?>!F>AED>L>;A@!BC!AJ<@! P>;?>/!AJ>!N?>@;A!I9W!F>@M?<5>@!f>=>;A@!AJEA!JE=>!A?E;@NFg!<;!B?F>?!AB!@JBX!fAJ>! ;EA!=!N?>@;A:!E@!MJ<>C!>Y>MKA<=>:!<@!EXE?>!BC!AJ>!@@NB;F<;Ph!G9W!fF>AE;!56!?>@NB;F>?@!E;F!AJ>!4>F>?ED!PB=>?;L>;Ag!E;F! >YNDE<;@!AJ>!?>LE<;<;P!MBK?@>!BC!EMAYN?>@@>@!AJ>!;EA!DB@@!BC! D!E;F!AJ>!LEA>?@!BC!AJB@>!ECC>MA>F!E;F!F<@NDEM>F!56!AJ>!F<@E@A>?g!<;!B?F>?!AB! NB?A?E6!JD C!E@!fE!MBLNE@@!E;F!ME?<;P!Chg!Q9W!fN?B=@!E@@K?E;M>@!BC!4>F>?ED! @KNNB?A!<;!AJ>!?>D<>C!E;F!?>@MK>!>CCB?A@hg!_9W!fN?E<@>@!AJ>!>CCB?A@!BC!AJ>!DBMED!MBLLK;>?@:!MJE?@:!E;F!NBDOK>@A@!NK5D?!AB!N?B=!E!L>E;@!BC!BKA?>EMJh!E;F!`9W!fN?B=@!E!N?BL<@>!BC!?>@AB?EA;>XEDg!XJ!EMT;BXD>FP<;P!AJEA!@KMJ!E;!>YN>?<>;M>!XD6!A>@A!AJ>!>;FK?E;M>!E;F! MJE?EMA>?!BC!AJ>!;EA!VdW9!86!>;EMA<;P!@KMJ!E!@N>>MJ:!N?> @;A@!ME;! fF>LB;@A?EA>!D>EF>?@JA>;M>:!E;F!MBLNE@@?>56!5BD@A>?!AJ>NKAEA!ED@B!N?B=:!@KNNB?A:!E;F!?>MBP;! ECC>MA>F!56!E!;EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?g!V.M3DK?>IIW9!)!C<;F!?>@A<;P!AJEA!.M3D K?>!CK?AJ>?!F<=@! AJ>!?J>AB??!<;AB!AXB!@>NE?EA>!MEA>PB?<>@/!;EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?@!E;F!>=>?6AJ<;P!>D@>9! +JBKPJ!BC!MBK?@>:!F<@E@A>?@!MBKDF!CK?AJ>?!5>!MEA>PB?<[>F i CB?!>YELND>:!A>??B?<@L:! @JBBA<;P@:!EMM;A@:!>AM9!)!XB;F>?!EMJ!MEA>PB?6!XBKDF!AJ >;!L>?AB?!DE?P>?!NJE@>@!BC!AJ>!?>@NB;@>!XBKDF!DD6!5>!OK!@!BC!AJ>!

PAGE 50

Qd C<;>?!NB<;A@:!E@!<;!AJ>!E@@;A!BC!5DEL>!B?!AJ>!MBK?@>!BC!EMA!F<@E@A>?! XBKDF!=E?69! +JBKPJ!.M3DK?>!CBMK@>@!B; B;>!@<;PKDE?!>Y

;M6:!8B;;<>!]9!(BX\@!E?PKL>;A! CBMK@>@!B;!AJ>!;>>F!AB!K;F>?@AE;F!JBX!LKDA!>Y

;M<>@!BN>?EA>!<;!<;CB?L<;P!E! N?>@;A\@!?>@NB;@>!AB!M?<@<@9!,@!(BX!E?PK>@:!AJ>!f@AKF6!BC!M?<@<@!F<@MBK?@>!@JBKDF!5>! <;CB?L>F!56!E;!K;F>?@AE;F<;P!BC!AJ>!F< CC>?<;P!>Y

;M<>@!AJEA!P<=>!?<@>!AB!?>;A! M?<@<@!@?>;A!?J>AB?@NB;@>@:!E;F!dW!AJ>!LB@A!C?K!M?<@<@!?J>AB?P<;!X?@AE;F<;P!BC!JBX!AJ>!?J>AB?@NB;F! AB!AJ>!>Y

;M>!M?>EA>F!56!AJ>!@!>Y

;M<>@!AJEA!(BX!;A@! <;MDKF>!fAJ>!>=>;A@:!AJ>!;>>F@!BC!AJ>!EKF<>;M>:!E;F!AJ>!NK?NB@>@!BC!AJ>!?J>AB?g!VGU`W9!$J>! MB;A<;K>@!AB!>DE5B?EA>/!f?J>AB?=>;A@!<@!MJE?EMA>?< [>F!56! >NP<>@g!XJ!N?>@;AAB?=BT>!E!M?<@<@!<@!fMJE?EMA>?<[>F! 56!F>D<5>?EA<=>!@A?EA>P<>@g!VGU`W9!+J>!?J>AB?@NB;F@!AB!>=>;A@!KDAD6!KA@! A>MJ;@!L>E;A!AB!fIW!F<@@BM!AJ>!;EA@NB;@<5 !M?<@<@:!GW!NDEM>!AJ>! >=>;A!X ^ DEF>;!MB;A>YA!BC!@!N>?@>=>?E;M>!<;!N?>@>;A! NBD?!AJE;!MJE;P>@!<;!NBD?!AB!fM?>EA>!E!MBLLK;ED!L>E;<;P!CB?!AJ>!>=>;A! XJ;A!X!MBLLK;< A6l@!>Y<@A<;P!5>D<>C@!E;F!=EDK>@!E;F!XJ@!AJ>! ?>@NB;@>!BC!L5>?@g!VGUaW9!1J>;!MB;@?<;P!JBX!E;!EKF<>;M>\@!;>>F@:!AJ>!>=>;A! DC:!E;F!AJ>!N?>@;A\@!PBED@!E@!@BK@!>Y

;M<>@:!)!ME;!M>?AE<;D6!@>>!JBX! N?>@;AAB?!E!=E?<>A6!BC!@A?EA>P<>@!<;!B?F>?!AB!EMMBLND<@J!@9!,@!E!?>@KDA:!@MJBDE?@!X!C<>DF!BC!N?>@;AAB?!EXE?>!

PAGE 51

QQ BC!AJ>@>!>Y

;M<>@!<;!B?F>?!AB!K;F>?@AE;F!AJ>!CKDD!@MBN>!BC!XJEA!N?>@;AAB?=>9 ,@!E!?>@KDA!BC!@KMJ!E!MBLND>Y!X>5!BC!>Y

;M<>@:! M>?AE<;!?J>AB?ED@!<;! ?>@NB;@>!AB!M?<@<@!LE6!5>!<;@KCC;A9!$N>M@!AJEA!?J>AB?@! LE6!5>!B=>?@F!E;F!F;!ENND<>F!AB!@KMJ E!LBF>?;:!MBLND>Y! P>;?>!E@!N?>@;AAB?!NK?NB@>!BC!M?<@<@!?J>AB?@@@;A! N?B5D>L@!XD<5>?EA<=>!E;F!>N;?>@! <;!MB;ZK;MA!LBF>?;! P>;?>@:!D!N?>@;AAB?!;BA>@!AJEA!">EPE;\@!@N>>MJ>@! B@M!5>AX>>;!F>D<5>?EA<=>!E;F!>N@:!FK>!AB!AJ>!CEMA!J>!F<@MK@@>@!LKDA! >=>;A@!X!@EL>!@N>>MJh!AJ>!K@> BC!LKDA!@A?EA>P<>@!<@!FF!56!AJ>!>Y

;M>!CB?! AJ>!@N>>MJ!VdH`W9!,@!LB?>!E;F!LB?>!>Y

;M<>@!A>;F!AB!MBL>!<;AB!NDE6!AB!<;CB?L!E! N?>@;A\@!?>@NB;@>:!?J>AB?;?>@!LE6!5>!J>DNCKD!CB?!K;F>?@AE;F<;P!XJEA!<@!JENN>;<;P! X!A>YA@!E;F!AJ>!D >=>D!BC!?J>AB?YF!X!A>YA9!+JBKPJ!)! EP?>>!X!MBLND>Y@;AAB?@!E!=E?<>A6!BC! MBLND>Y!CEMAB?@!<;!AJ>!L!?J>AB?@:!AJ>!=>?6!B5@>?=EAY!LB?>!<;@!?>@NB;@>!DC9 8>MEK@>!M>?AE<;!>Y

;M<>@!LE6!L>?!K@>!BC!M>?AE<;!N>?@B;E@!B=>?!BAJ>?@:! @MJBDE?@!ED@B!>YEL<;>!AJ>!=E?<>A6!BC!?BD>@!AJEA!?J>AB?@!>L5BF6!<;!AJ>!L@NB;F<;P!AB! E!M?<@<@9!SED>?<>!$MJ?E>F >?!E;ED6[>@!"B;EDF!">EPE;\@!?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!3JEDD>;P>?!F<@E@A>?!E;F! 8@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!&TDEJBLE!3EPE;!E;F! 3D<;AB;!AET>!B;!AJ>!?BD>!BC!AJ>!A>EMJ>?!XJ!>KDBP<[<;P!AJ>!A?EP>F<>@9!$J>!E?PK>@!AJEA!5BAJ!

PAGE 52

Q_ N?>@;A @!K@>!A>EMJE5D>!LBL>;A@:!XJ!F>C<;>@!E@!E!LBL>;A!AJEA!fN?B=@!E;! BNNB?AK;EMJ!AJ>!EKF<>;M>:!B?!NE?A!BC!E;!EKF<>;M>:!E!D>@@B;!BC!@BL>!@B?Ag!VdW:!<;! B?F>?!AB!CB?L!E!f?J>AB?D<5>?EA<=>!E;F!CB?>;@D>L>;A@!AB!E;! >N>MJ:!AB!MB;;>MA!X;M>@:!E;F!AB!KDAD6!NDEM>!AJ>!N?>@;A!<;!AJ>! ?BD>!BC!A>EMJ>?g!VQW9! +J<@!@!JBX!?>NK?NB@<;P!LKDA!?J>AB?D>L>;A@!56! >;EMA<;P!AJ>!?BD>!BC!A>EMJ>?@!ME;!N?B=!E!LB?>!C;M> ^ M>;A>?>F!?J>AB?@NB;@>:!N>?JEN@!@KPP>@A<;P!AJEA!AJ>!C<>DF!BC!N?>@;AAB?!LB?>!<;AB!AJ>!K@>@! BC!J65?AB?;?>@9 ,@!$MJ?E>F>?!>YEL<;>@:!3D<;AB;!EKDBP<[>!AJ>!&TDEJBLE!3! >;@K?<;P!AJEA!AJ>!N>?N>A?EAB?!BC!AJ>!EAAEMT!X!ZK@Ah!@EPE;!>KDBP<[>@!AJ>! 3JEDD>;P>?!F<@E@A>?!XJ!EAA>LNA<;P!AB!ZK@AF!<;=>@AL>;A!<;!AJ>!@NEM>!N?BP?EL9! 4<;EDD6:!AJ>!EKAJB?!;BA>@!AJEA!f56!<;A>?X>E=<;P!AJ>!NE@A!X!N?>@>;A!E;F!AJ>!CKAK?>:! ">EPE;!E;F!3D<;AB;!E?>!E5D>!AB!L B=>!AJ>;M>:!EA!D>E@A!?J>AB??>! AJ>F!B;>@!E;F!AJ>?B>@!D<=>F:!AB!E!N?>@>;A!E;F!CKAK?>!XJ>?>!AJ>6!LK@A!D<=>!AJ>@!XLg!VIaW9!+JBKPJ!)!L@A?!E@@>?A@;AAB??E A>@!E@!E!>KDBP6!BC!E;!>=>;A:!>L@!AJEA!$MJ?E>F>?\@!E;ED6@<@!<@!J>DNCKD!<;! F>A>?L<;<;P!JBX!AET<;P!B;!E!M>?AE<;!?BD>!LE6!J>DN!AJ>!N?>@;A!<;!ZKPPD<;P!FKED!NK?NB@>@! X>MJ!AJEA!?>@NB;F@!AB!M?<@<@9!,FFE?!C?BL!J>?!E;ED6@<@!AJEA N?>@;A@!CBMK@!<;!B;!AJ>!CEL!DB@A!<;!AJ>!M?<@<@:!XJ@!AJ>!N?>@;A\@! ;>>F!AB!ZKPPD>!;BA!B;D6!LKDA!NK?NB@>@:!5KA!LKDA!EKF<>;M>@:!XJ! MBLND>YYA@9 !

PAGE 53

Q` *LDHD'%C?8:9>= .KMJ!BC!&5ELE!?J>AB?@!B;!;BA!B;D6!?EM>:!FK>!AB!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!J>!<@!AJ>!C@;A:!5KA!ED@B!JBX!J>!K@>@!?>D!F?>;AD6!C?BL!MB;@>?=EA<=>! N?>@;A@!<;!B?F>?!AB!ZK@A?ED!5>D<>C@!E;F!NBD@9! );!BAJ>?!@N>>MJ>@:!AJBKPJ!)!X!E;ED6 [<;P!EDD!J<@!?>@NB;@>@!AB!A?EKLE!XM>:!&5ELE!JDC!EFF?>@@>@!AJ>!?EM?6!E@!X>DD!E@!BAJ>?!A?EKLE@:! >=>;!AJBKPJ!AJ>6!LE6!;BA!@>>L!MB;A>YAKEDD6!?>DEA>F!EA!C!(E=;M>!F<@EP?>>!B=>?!AJ>!>CC>MA< =>;>@@!BC!&5ELE\@!@N>>MJ!<;!?>PE?F@!AB!?EMMB;M6!5BAJ!EMT;BXD>FP>!&5ELE\@!@KMM>@@!<;!AJ>!K@>!BC!E!?J>AB?;M>9!);!J<@!EFF?>@@!AB!AJ>!GHHQ!(>LBM?EA;A@!AJ>! A?EKLE@!BC!@DE=>?6!E;F!?EM<@L!AB!MB;A>YAK ED<[>!AJ>!@A?KPPD>@!BC!,L>??@:!PE6@:! ,?E5!,L>??FP>@! AJ>!P>BP?ENJYKED!F?>;M>@!<;!AJ>!-;
F!$AEA>@!E;F!@@! AJ>L!<;!XJEA!AJ>6!@JE?>!<;!MBLL B;g!V4?E;T!E;F!2EX?>;M>!_aUW!E;F!BCC>?@!E!?J>AB?;M>!56!<;=!EKF<>;M>!AB!MBL>!ABP>AJ>?!<;!CE=B?!BC!MBLLB;!=EDK>@!E;F! E@NM>!<@!LB@A!MB;M>?;>F!X!@N>>MJ\@!>;F!PBED!BC!?EMMB;M!EKAJB?@!EMT; BXD>FP>!JBX!&5ELE\@!@N>>MJ!<@!?>NK?NB@<;P!A?EKLE!K@<;P!E! LB?>!NBD;M> ^ CBMK@>F!ENN?BEMJ:!EDDBX<;P!AJ>!E?A!AB!F<@AE;M>!DC!C?BL!A>YA@! AJEA!>LNJE@<[>!AJ>!?J>AB?\@!N>?@B;ED!>YN>?<>;M>!X?! E@!)!>YEL<;>!J BX!&5ELE!ZKPPD>@!J<@!BX;!PBED@!<;!5BD@A>?<;P!J<@!M?>F<5!ED@B! ?>@NB;F<;P!AB!AJ>!;>>F@!BC!AJ>!EKF<>;M>:!<;MDKF<;P!@K?=<=B?@!BC!AJ>!A?EKLE!EA!JE;F9

PAGE 54

Qa 8>MEK@>!?>DAB?;!EDF!X?=EA<=>!NBD@! AJEA!E?>!A6NX>F!E@!LB?ED:!D!E5B?A:!LE;6!@MJBDE?@!JE=>!E! T>>;!<;A>?>@A!<;!AJ>!XE6!8E?EMT!&5ELE!?>C?EL>@!A?EF@!<;!@KNNB?A!BC! E!D<5>?ED!EP>;FE9!,@!'EAJE;!3?@:!&5ELE!<;MB?NB?EA>@!f8<5D@!E;F! NE@@E P>@!E?>!K@>F!<;!A?EFDAENJB?@!E;F!LEY?!AB! !AJ>!MBLLB;D6!J>DF!E@!E;F!=EDK>@!BC!E!NDK?ED<@AA6g!Vd`W9!+J>!EKAJB?! >DE5B?EA>@!B;!AJ<@!NB<;A:!@E6<;P:!fXJEA!MJE?EMA>?<[>@!&5ELE\@!?J>AB?DYNDC>?>;M>!AB!*BF!B?!J<@!K@EP>!BC!A>?L<;BDBP6!E@@BMF!X@AE5D<@J>F!?>D!MB;@A?KMA@!F?ELEA@!AJEA!ELND!?>D!MBLLB;!?>ED<[EA=>L>;A@!BC!B?F<;E?6!M
;@!E@!AJ>6!@A?KPPD>! ABP>AJ>?!AB!ME?=>!E!JBL>!BKA!BC!E;!BCA>;!JB@A!>;=;Ag!Vd`W9! 3??<[>@!&5ELE\@!@A6D>!E@!E!@K5MEA>PB?6!BC!>NAB?F! f?J>AB?DYN>?<>;M>g!VdaW!E;F!F>C<;>@!!B?! ENN>ED!AB!AJ>!EKAJB??;EAK?ED!5><;P!5KA!AB!N?BFKM>!<;!E;!EKF<>;M>!E!C>>D<;P!BC! F?ELEAL>;A!ABXE?F!E!@JE?>F!>YN>?<>;M>!<;!XJ!C>>D@!MB;;>MA>F:!AJ?BKPJ! MB;ZB<;A!EMA?!K;<=>?@>!XJCD>MA@!MBLLB;!=EDK>@!E;F! E@!AJ<@!F>C<;X>6!E;F!>YNDE<;@!AJEA!f5>MEK@>!BC!;F>;M6!AB! MBLL>LB?EA>!M>?AE<;!@JE?>F!>YN>?<>;M>@!AJEA!BMMK?!X!@NEM>:!AJ>! ?J>AB?DYN>?<>;M>!AJK@!A>;F@!AB!CE=B?!AJ>!>N ;?>!BC!@N>>MJ!B=>?!AJ>! LB?>!NE?A<@E;!F>D<5>?EA<=>!@NJ>?>g!V3?E?!AJEA!LKMJ!BC!AJ>!@ MJBDE?@JAB?=BD=>@!E?BK;F!JBX! &5ELE!?>NK?NB@>@!?>DAB?!E;AAF>M>@@B?@9!,@!

PAGE 55

Qb ,;F?>!#9!] BJ;@B;!E?PK>@:! &5ELE\@!?>DAB??EA>@!LKMJ!F?>;AD6!AJE;!AJEA!BC! J<@!N?>F>M>@@B?@!<;!AJEA!@!B;!JBX!?>DEA?!N>BND>!@JBKDF!LBA<=EA>! EMA!5>AA>?L>;A!BC!AJB@>!LE?P<;ED<[>F!56!@BM<>A69!]BJ;@B;!@AEA>@!AJEA:!f&5 ELE\@! CE=>?:!FB>@!;BA!D<;>!KN!X!@AE;FE?F!NBD!?>PE?F<;P!CE! F>M@!AB!A<>!CE!N?>=E!JE@!5>>;!E!CE!E;F!AJ>!D9!+J<@!CE i XJEA!E;@!AB!5>! NBD?L>EA>@!AJ>!NBDg!V_GW9!0BX>=>?:!&5ELE\@! ?>DD<>C@!fC<;F!?>@B;E;M>!<;!?>DEA;A>F!CELNJE@<[<;P!DB=>! E;F!AJ>!>AJEAL>;A!BC!B;>\@!;>@KDA:!]BJ;@B;!E?PK>@!AJEA! &5ELE\@!?J>AB?BDBP?>;A!C?BL!AJ>!N?>=E i B;>!AJEA!<@!?>DEALNEAJ>A@!CB?!AJ>!NBB?:!E;F!B;>!AJEA!@AE;F@! X!BC!AJ>!LE?P<;@!BC!@BM <>A6g!V_GW9!)A\@!>=;A!C?BL!]BJ;@B;\@!E;ED6@<@!AJEA!&5ELE\@! K@>!BC!?>D?=>@!F?>;A!NK?NB@>@!AJE;!MB;@>?=EA<=>!NBDMEK@>!&5ELE\@! <;A>?N?>AEA@!FB>@!;BA!C?=EA<=>!;E??EA<=>@:!)!XBKDF! E?PK>!AJEA!J >!LK@A!KA!=>?6!F?>;A!@A?EA>P<>@!<;!B?F>?!AB!@JBX!AJEA!J>!JE@!E??<=>F!EA! AJ<@!BDBP6!AJ?BKPJ!E!N?BM>@@!BC!ME?>CKD!AJBKPJA!E;F!F>D<5>?EA@A! AJEA!&5ELE\@!>LNJE@<@!B;!AJ>!LE?P<;ED<[>F!>YA>;F@!5>6B;F!ZK@A!AJ>!NBB?h!!XJB!E?>!LE?P<;ED<[>F!E@!E!?>@KDA!BC!A?EP>F69! &AJ>?!@MJBDE?@!ED@B!;BA>!JBX!&5ELE!ZK@A@!J<@!MEDD!CB?!,L>?EMJ!BKA!AB! AJB@>!LE?P<;ED<[>F!56!@BM<>A6!X=;M>!C?BL!AJ>!8<5D>9!]9$9!$?!M
@!JBX!&5ELE! KA@!fAJ>!8 ?BAJ>?\@!7>>N>?!:g!E!?>C>?>;M>!AB!3E<;!E;F!,5>D!<;!AJ>!5BBT!BC!*>;>@<@:! AB!>L5BF6!J<@!5>D<>C!AJEA!f>EMJ!BC!K@!<@!<;!CEMA!KDAD6!?>@NB;@<5D>!<;!E!MBDD>MA<=>!LE;;>?!

PAGE 56

QU CB?!AJ>!X>DD ^ 5><;P!BC!AJ>!D>E@A!E;F!LB@A!=KD;>?E5D>!ELB;P!K@:!XJ>AJ>?!@KMJ!=KD;>?E5< D@!<;!AJ>!CB?L!BC!?EM6:!NB=>?A6:!B?!E!AJ ?>EA!AB!M<=?A<>@g!V_UQW9 ,@!]BJ;@B;! ECCAB?@!5<5D!<;MDK@<=>!MDE??!CK;FEL>;AEDD6!D<;T>F!E@!5?BAJ>?@!E;F!@<@A> ?@:!A?E;@M>;F<;P! F<=<@<=>!5BK;FE?<>@!BC!NBD:!MDE@ @!E;F!P>;F>?:!E;F!>=>;!?>D?AE<;D6!LET>!AJ>!ME@>!AJEA!;EA?!AJEA!@JBKDF!5>!MB;@?>F!<;!A>?L@!BC!JBX!,L> ?!LE?P<;ED<[>F:!LKMJ!D! AJ>!CEMAB?@!]BJ;@B;!L>;A?>9 ]BJ;@B;!CK?AJ>?!F>LB;@A?EA>@!JBX!&5ELE\@!?J>AB?CD>MA@!J<@!5>D<>C@!AJEA!CE!AJ>!N?J<;F!NBDP<@DEA@:!f1J! &5ELE!JE@!E! LB?ED!=<@!T<;F!BC!;EA!@JBKDF!5>:!J>!ED@B!?>MBP;<[>@!AJEA!AJ>?>! E?>!MBLN>A<;P!=<@A<;P!MB;@A;M<>@!AJEA!L>!LK@A!>;PEP>!<;!AJ>!?>ED! XB?DFg!V`HHW:!XJYNDE<;@!XJ6!&5ELE!f@K5B?F<;EA>@!MDE@! 5E @>F!B;!?>DED!AB!?>E@B;>F!E?PKL>;A@!AJEA!@AE;F! OK
!ENE?A!C?BL!?>D=>?:!)!XBKDF!E?PK>!AJEA!&5ELE!K;F>?L<;>@!J<@! BX;!NBDBDBP6!56!?>D6<;P!@BD>D6!B;!3J?<@A?@AE;F<;P@!BC!A?EKLE!E; F!A?EP>F6! XJ>;!?>@NB;F<;P!AB!AJ>@>!>=>;A@9!)C!J<@!NBD@!AET>!<;AB!EMMBK;A!E!LB?>!?>E@B;>F! ENN?BEMJ!E@!BNNB@>F!AB!E!@BD>D6!CEF!?>@NB;@>:!AJ>;!>L@!MBK;A>?<;AK!AJEA! J<@!?>@NB;@>@!AB!M?<@>@!@JBKDF!CE=B?!E!N? ?@AE;F<;P!BC!A?EP>F69!);!B?F>?! AB!ED?@AE;F<;P!BC!AJ>!-;F!$AEA>@!BC!E!@BM<>A6!AJEA!@JBKDF!A?E;@M>;F! 5BK;FE?<>@!BC!?>D;F!AJEA!&5ELE\@!?>@NB;@>@!AB!A?EKLE!@JBKDF!5>!LB?>!EXE?>! BC!AJ>!=E?@NB;@>@!AB!E;F!K;F>?@AE;F<;P @!BC!A?EKLE@!AJEA!FB!;BA!C
PAGE 57

_H ,@!@MJBDE?@!>YEL<;>:! &5ELE\@!?>DD<>C@!<;CDK>;M>!AJ>!XE6!J>!>@AE5D<@J>@! >AJB@:!@N>M@@!AB!AET>!B;!AJ>!?BD>!BC!NE@AB?9! ,@!]BJ;@B;!@:! &5ELE\@!K@>!BC!@M? F>LB;@A?E A>@!AJEA:!CB?!J!N?>@;M6!<@!fE!NE@AB?ED!NKDN@@<;P!XB?F@!BC!MBLNE@@?<;P!E!A?EPLB?@@!ECA>?!AJ>!]E;KE?6!b:!GHII:!@JBBA<;P@!<;!+K@MB;:!,?<[B;E:!fJ<@!F! ENN>ED!AB!AJ> ?>D!BC!AJ>!L>LB?F!J!ELB;P!AJ>!DE?P>! LEZB??D<>=>!<;!AJ>!>CC?:!E@!E!C>DDBX!MB;P?>P E;A:!E;F!6>A! NE@AB?!AB!E!;EA=>?:!<;!AJ>!CEM>!BC!<;A>;@>!F>5EA>!B=>?!XJ>AJ>?! EF FP<@DEAM>@@E?6:!f%E@AB?!&5ELE!MB;A<;K>F!56!MEDD<;P!CB?! J>ED<;P!E;F!;BA!F<=<@;!E!?>AK?;!AB!$M?:!CB?!$M?!@N>ET@!;BA!B;D6!BC! CE:!5KA!BC!A J>!?>ED=!XB?DF g!V ]BJ;@B;! `H`W 9 $MJBDE? @!JE=>!ED@B!;BA>F!AJEA!&5ELE\@!X@@!AB!5>!M??CB?LE;M>!F>C<;>@!J<@!?J>AB??!@AKF6!B;!JBX!&5ELE\@!?J>AB?P6!F?@!C?BL!BAJ>?!N?>@;A@:!.E;C?>F!7<>;NB<;A;>?!E?PK>@:!fI9W!&5ELE\@! F<@NB@@:!5BAJ!EA!E!N>?@B;ED!E;F!EA!E!PB=>?;L>;AED!B?!;EA=>D9! G9W!&5ELE\@!K;<=>?@ED<@A!E;F!MB;@>;@K@ ^ B?<>;AEA>F!N>?@N>MA<=>g!Vd`_W!@>A@!J<@!@A?EA>P<>@! ENE?A9!0>!<@!E5D>!AB!>@AE5D<@J!>AJB@!LB?>!>E@MEK@>!J<@!@>DC ^ M?@!J<@! E?PKL> ;A@!LB?>!5EDE;M>F!E;F!?EANAE5D>g!Vd``W9!#=>;!<;!AJ>!XET>!BC!AJ>!+K@MB;! @JBBA<;P:!f&5ELE!MEDD>F!CB?!E;!>;F!AB!EPP?>@@<=>!NE?A6!?J>AB?X!NBD! BC!LKAKED!?>@N>MA!E;F!MBBN>?EA;NB<;A;>?!d`aW9!0BX>=>?:!EPE<;:!)!XBKDF!E? PK>!AJEA! E!MEDD!CB?!EP?>>L>;A!E;F!K;!E;!>E@6!XE6!BKA!BC!>CC>MA<;P!?>ED:!@K5@AE;A<=>!

PAGE 58

_I NBD!AJEA!MBKDF!KDAD6!JE=>!LB?>!BC!E!NB@!!MBK;A?6!E@!E! XJBD>9 +J>!@MJBDE?@J@!@BL>!OKE;A!@AKF<>@!AJEA F>LB;@A?EA>!&5ELE\@! LE@A>?6!BC!?J>AB?DD!@!<;!J<@ E;ED6@<@!BC!f@AE?A ^ KN!?J>AB?>MJ>@:!fJ>!K@>@!AJ<@!C:!5>P<;;<;P!X!C!KAA>?E;M>!B;! J<@!NE?A:!AB!@T@AE5D<@J!E!F>C>?>;ALNJE@<@!BC!AJ>L>@!EM?B@@! AJ>!5BE?F9!+J>!LB@A!@ED<>;A!BC!AJ>@>!<@!J<@!AJ>L>!BC!P?EAg!VQH`W9!+J<@!<@!>=;A!<;! &\3B;;>DD\@!@ELND>!@N>>MJ>@/!fXJ>?><;!@NB;AE;>BK@!EKF<5D>!EKF<>;M>!?>EMA!;BA! EDDBXE5D>:!J>!K@>@!E@!E!@AE?A ^ KN!F> =!AJ>!@<;PD<;P!BKA!56!;EL>!BC!<;F<=@>;A!<;!AJ>! EKF<>;M>/!AB!AJE;T!AJ>L!CB?!AJ>@>;M>:!CB?!AJ>DN!FK?<;P!J<@!=<@@A!J<@! ?>@N>MA!CB?!AJ>Lg V &\3B;;>DD! QHbW9!);!MB;A?E@A:!CB?!@N>>MJ>@!AJEA!L>?!@BL5>?!AB;>:! ,@!&\3B; ;>DD!@AEA>@:!&5ELE\@!?J>AB??<[>F!56!J<@/ C?>OK>;A!K@>!BC!C

?@rE;F!56!AJ>!E5@>;M>!BC!E;6!<;A?BFKMAB?6!NJ?E@>@!EA!AJ>! BN>;<;P!BC!J<@!@N>>MJ9!+J<@!E5@>;M>!<@!MD>E?D6!BMME@F!56!E!DEMT!BC!EKF<>;M>! ?>EMAE?E;M>!EA!AJ>!NBF>N<;P!X! @B5?<>A6 i <;F>>F!@BL5>?;>@@ i BC!AJ>!@>AA<;P!E;F!AJ>L>!<;=BD=<;P!AJ>!J<@AB ?6!BC!E! 11))!MB;M>;A?EADD\@!?>@>E?MJ!F>LB;@A?EA>@!AJEA!&5ELE!<@!MENE5D>!BC!@KMM>@@CKDD6!?>@NB;F<;P!AB!E! =E?<>A6!BC!MBLND>Y!>Y

; M<>@!E;F!ME;!AE;PEP>L>;A!X!EKF<>;M>!EMMB?F<;P!AB! AJ>!ENN?BN?!MB;=>;A
PAGE 59

_G &2!3$-%' 44 0-$2*.*,*/M +J>!A>YA@!)!EL!DBBT<;P!EA!CB?!AJ<@!AJ>@<@!<;MDKF>!AJ>!=B@!E;F!A?E;@M?@;A!8E?EMT!&5ELE\@!@N>>MJ>@!<;!?>@NB;@>!AB/!I9W!AJ> ,K?B?E!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P:!G9W!AJ>! 8B@AB;!.E?EAJB;!5BL5<;P:!E;F!d9W!$KN>?@AB?L!$E;F69!.6!@KNND>L>;AE?6!A>YA@!<;MDKF>/!I9W! &5ELE\@!MELNE>MJ!AK?;>F!,K?B?E!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P!?>@NB;@>:!E;F!G9W!J<@!@N>>MJ!<;! ?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!$E;F6!0BBT!@JBBA<;P9!.6!L>AJBF!< ;=BD=>@!E!A>YAKED:!?J>AB?B?<>@!BC!AJ>!?J>AB?@AB?EA<=>!?J>AB?!LE<;A>;E;M>:!E;F!AJ>! F<@MBK?@>!BC!?>;>XED!B;AB!L6!MJB@>;!A>YA@9 4YNDE<;!JBX!)!PEAJ>?>F!L6!FEAE:! MJB@>!L6!?J>AB?EAK?>@:!E ;F!E;ED6[>F!L6!FEAE9!+J>;:!)!X!?J>AB?AJBF:!E;F!>YNDE<;!XJ6!?>@AB?EA<=>!?J>AB?!LE<;A>;E;M>:!E;F!AJ>! F<@MBK?@>!BC!?>;>XED!X>?>!=EDKE5D>!AJ>B?<>@!<;!J>DN<;P!L>!E;ED6[>!L6!?J>AB?EAK?>@9 /D8C?9>7J'0E'.D8D )!MJ B@>!AJ>!ECB?>L>;AF!A>YA@!5>MEK@>!)!XE@!<;A>?>@A>F!<;!DBBT<;P!EA!JBX!B;>! NE?AAB?:!8E?EMT!&5ELE:!?>@NB;F@!AB!=E?=>;A@!<;!B?F>?!AB! F>A>?L<;>!XJ>AJ>?!AJ>?>!X>?>!MD>E?!NEAA>?;@!EM?B@@!AJ>@>!@N>>MJ>@!<;!@N
!BC!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA! AJ>6!E ?>!LBA<=EA>F!56!=>?6!F?>;A!A?EKLE@9!+J>@>!@N>>MJ>@!JE;P!ABP>AJ>?!N?MEK@>!BC!AJ>!MBLLB;!?J>AB?9!0BX>=>?:!)!F>!JBX!8E?EMT!&5ELE! ?>@NB;F>F!AB!B;>!NE?A!BC!A?EP>F6h!)!XE;A>F!AB!@>>!JBX!J>!K@>@!@P<>@! <;!?>@NB ;F<;P!AB!F?>;A! M?<@>@!E;F!BAJ>?! >Y

;M<>@9!)!@>D>MA>F!AJ>@>!>=>;A@!5>MEK@>!AJ>6 EDD!BMMK??>F!X!DE@A!I ^ G!6>E?@!E;F NDE6>F!LEZB?!?BD>@!<;!@JEN<;P!8E?EMT!&5ELE\@! ?J>AB?@;M69! $KN>?@AB?L! $E;F6!XE@!&5ELE \@!C? AB F>ED!

PAGE 60

_d X?LB?>:!!<;!AJEA!F!E!;>X!MEA>PB?6!BC!JK?? i AJ>! @KN>?@AB?L9 $E;F6!ED@B!BMMK??>F!EA!AJ>!J>E@B ; i ZK@A!E!X>>T!E;F!E!JEDC! 5>CB?>!>D>MA!E;F!<;CDK>;M>!X!M B;A>YA!BC!AJ>!GHIG! >D>MA@;M69! ,FF!BC!AJ>!C@NB;F>F!AB!E@!N?>@;A:!)!@>D>MA>F! AJ>! ,K?B?E!@JBBA<;P!AB!DBBT! EA! <;@A>EF!CB?!CBK? ?>E@B;@/!I9W!F!EA!AJ>!J>!M ELNEE@B;!E;F! NBA>;ADF!LB?>!MEDD@!C B?!PK;!MB;A?BD!D>P<@DEA!CX@ ^ XB?AJ6!@JBBA<;P!BC!GHIG:!E;F!N?>M>F>F!BAJ>?!LEZB?:!J>EFD<;> ^ LET<;P!@JBBA<;P@:!D!AJ>! $LND>!@JBBA<;P!E;F!$E;F6!0BBT:! d9W!,K?B?E!>YNB@>F!E =KD;>?E5@B;EA>F! X?@KDA<;P!<;!MJE;P<;P!@>MK?@!<;!LB=<>!AJ>EA>?@!E?BK;F!AJ>! MBK;A?6:!E;F!Q9W!AJ>!>=>;A!K;CBDF>F!<;!L6!BX;!5EMT6E?F:!EDDBX<;P!L>!AB!@>>!AJ>!XE6!E! MB LLK;@NB;F@!AB!E!DBMED<[>F 5KA!;EA! 8B@AB; .E?EAJB;!5BL5<;P XE@!AJ>!C??B?<@A!EAAEMT!B;!,L>?!Uc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

PAGE 61

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

PAGE 62

__ N?B;BK;@:!J:g!f):g!f6BK:g!fK@:g!E;F fBK?:g!<;!F?>;A!MBDB?@9!) @AE?A>F!NKDD<;P! BKA!AJ>!LBL>;A@!XJ>?>! X> :!K@:!E; F!BK?!X>?>!K@>F9!+J>;:!E@!)!5>PE;!DBBT<;P!EA!AJ>!NEAA>?;@! X!K@>!BC!>EMJ!N?B;BK;:!)!5>MEL>!LB@A <;A>?>@A>F!<;!X>!E;F!K@: E@!AJ>6!BCA>;!X>?>! K;F>C<;>Fh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

PAGE 63

_`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

PAGE 64

_a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

PAGE 65

_b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

;M<>@:!E;F!N?>@KNNB@!)!JEF!M?>EA>F! E;!<;=>;AB?6:!)!AJ>;!@F!AJ>@>!L@!X !?J>AB?EMJ!BC! L6!E?A?>@A>F!<;!AJ>!LKDA!MBLN>A<;P!>Y

;M<>@:!@B!)! NEM;AF!NBA>;AY

;M<>@!AB!@AE?A!AJ<;T<;P!E5BKA! MBLND>L>;AE?6!EKF<>;M>@!E;F!N?>@K NNB@!AJ>!A>YA!LB?>!N>?@KE@<=>!

PAGE 66

_U <;!?>PE?F@!AB!@KMJ!>Y

;M<>@!XJ>;!FMA>F!EA!M>?AE<;!EKF<>;M>@9!+J<@!ED@B!PBA!L>!AJ<;T<;P! E5BKA!JBX!EKF<>;M>@!LE6!5>!EA!BFF@!X!E;BAJ>?:!MB;@?<;P!AJEA!AJ>?>!E?>!LE;6! NBA>;A;M>@!AJEA!@K MJ!E!@N>>MJ!MBKDF!5>!EF!EA9!+J>!?J>AB?;E5D>F! L>!AB!MD>E?D6!;AD!XJEA!>D@>!XE@!JENN>;<;P!@BK@D6!AB!LBA<=EA>!E;F! <;CDK>;M>!AJ>!A>YA@9!+J<;P@!D!?>DD<>C@:!AJ>!M?<@<@ DC : E;F AJ>!GHIG!MELNEE@!EFF;A@!BC!AJ>!?J>AB?D6!AJ>!;BA@KNNB@DN>F!L>!MB;@?>F!AJ>! BMME@;>@@!BC! AJ>!LBF> CB?!L6!A>YA@:!>@N>MPE?F@!AB!&5ELE\@ MELNE>MJ c,K?B?E!?>@NB;@> 9 +J<@! ENN?BEMJ!>;E5D>F!L> AB!@J>F!D!?>DEAAX>>;!&5ELE!E@!AJ>! ?J>AB?:!&5ELE\@!@N>>MJ>@!<;!?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!M?<@>@:!E;F!AJ>!LKDA!EKF<>;M>@!AJEA!&5ELE! LK@A!ZKPPD>!X>MJ>@9!,@!8?!>YNDE<;@:!fE!XB?T!BC!?J>AB?@!<;AB!>Y<@A>;M>!CB?!AJ>!@ET>!BC!@BL>AJ<;P!5>6B;F!DCh!D6!AB! N?BFKM>!EMA!<;!AJ>!XB?DFh!?CB?L@!@BL>!AE@Tg!V_W9!+J<@!MB;M>NA!<@!?!AB!K;F>?@AE;F!AJ>!NK?NB@>!BC!>EMJ!BC!&5ELE\@!@N>>MJ>@!<;!?> @NB;@>!AB!M?<@>@!E;F! JBX!AJ>@>!A>YA@!ECC>MA!MJE;P>!E@!E!?>@KDA9!0BX>=>?:!AB!CKDD6!K;F>?@AE;F!?J>AB??EA<=>!AB!DBBT!EA!;BA!B;D6!AJ>!A>YA!DC:!5KA!AJ>! BMME@=>;A:!B?!MB;F!AJ<@!A>YA9!+ J<@!<@!AJ>!?J>AB??!MEDD@!@!AJ?>>!>D>L>;A@/!AJ>!>Y

;M>:!EKF<>;M>:!E;F!MB;@A?E<;A@!V`W9! 8?!F>C<;>@!>Y

;M>!E@!fE;!?C>MAF!56!K?P>;M6h!C>MA:!E;!B5@AEMD>:! @BL>AJ<;P!XE!FB;>:!E!AJ< ;P!XJ?!AJE;!g!V`W9!3B;=>?@>D6:!!;BA>F!AJEA!8?!F<@A<;PK<@J>@!5>AX>>;!E!?J>AB?Y

;M>:!XJ!BC! fNB@!LBF!F<@MBK?@>!V`W:!E;F!B;>!AJEA!fME;!5>!LBFF!B;D6!56!

PAGE 67

`H L>E;@!BAJ>?!A JE;!F<@MBK?@>g!V`W!B?!B;>!AJEA!ME;;BA!5>!LBFF!EA!EDD9!)!X!8?\@! AJ>B?6!BC!>Y

;M>!AB!ZK@AYEL<;EA!=E?@!A JEA!LBA<=EA>!&5ELE\@! ?>@NB;@>@9 I );!EFF!>D>L>;A@!BC!AJ>!?J>AB?!C?B L!8?\@! E?PKL>;A!AJ>!;BAAB?!C@NB;@>@9!8?!NB@AB?@!?>@NB;@>:!@!;BA!<;=!ZK@A!E;6! ?>@NB;@>9!+JK@ AJ>!@>MB;F!MJE?EMA>?<@AAB?@!E! B'!!'.A# ?>@NB;@>:!E!?>@NB;@>!AJEA!C!@E?D6:!AJ<@!<@!E;!;AYA@:!AJ>!ED!BC!E!C@NB;@>!<@!MJEDD>;P>F!FK?<;P!&5ELE\@!C@NB;@>!AB!AJ>! ,K?B?E!@JBBA<;P:!XJ;F>F AB!5>!E!MELNE=>;A9! ,@!8?!JDC! ;BA>@:!fN?EMA@;A@!;KL>?BK@!MBLND>Y! ?J>AB?E!BC!MBLND>Y!?J>AB?F!JBX!&5ELE EAA>LN A@!AB!fN?>@M?< 5>!AJ>!?>@NB;@>!XJ;A<;P! AJ>!XE6!J>!?>EMA@!AB!EKF<>;M>!<;A>??KNA>MJ!E;F!JBX!J<@!?>EMA=BD=>!AB! ?>CD>MA!AJ>!LKDA!>Y

;M<>@!EA!JE;F9! #YNE;F<;P!B;!AJ>!E!BC!AJ>!?J>AB??!E ;F!1EDT>?!JE=>! MB;M>NAKED<[>F!AJ>!?J>AB?LNDEA>!AJEA!)!ME;!LEN!B;AB!L6!BX;!A>YA@9! +J>6!E?>!E5D>!AB!MBLNE?AL>;AED<[>!AJ>!E@N>MA@!BC!8?\@!?J>AB?! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I 0BX>=> ?:!<;!B;>!?>@N>MA:!8?\@!AJ>B?6!CEDD@!@JB?A:!E;F!)!LBFF!J<@!ENN?BEMJ!<;!@>?=! BC!L6!E;ED6@<@9!+JBKPJ!8?!E@@>?A@!AJEA!fE;!>Y

;M>!XJ!MJE;P>F i F>EAJ:! X<;A>?:!E;F!@BL>!;EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?@:!CB?!<;@AE;M> i E?>!>Y

;M<>@!AB!5>!@K?>:!5KA!AJ >6!E?>!;BA! ?J>AB?!FELEP>!E;F!F>@A?KMAF!56!@KMJ!;EAK?ED!F<@E@A>?@:!E@!<;!AJ>!ME@>! BC!$KN>?@AB?L!$E;F6:!E?>!>Y

;M<>@!<;!E;F!BC!AJ>L@>D=>@!AJEA!ZK@A!?>@NB;@>!P<=>;!56! &5ELE9!+JK@:!AJ<@!NE?A?!@>?=>@!E@!E;!> Y

;M>!E;F!B;>!AJEA!)!XYEL<;>!?J>AB?
PAGE 68

`I LE;EP>E5D>!C?EL>XB?T!AJEA!N?B=>F!M?KM!E@!)!B?PE;< [>F!AJ>!>D>L>;A@!BC!L6!A>YA@9! ,@!AJ>6!>YNDE<;:!AJ>!?J>AB?@!fE!@N>ET>?!XJB!N?BFKM>@!E!@N>>MJ!VAJ>! @N>ET>?\@!XB?F@W!CB?!E;!EKF<>;M>!VAJ>!N>?@B;!B?!N>?@B;@!AB!XJBL!AJ>!@N>ET>?\@!XB?F@!E?>! EFF?>@@>FW9!+J>!@N>>MJ!<@!N?BFKM>F!56!AJ>!@N>ET>? :!E;F!<;A>?N?>A>F!56!AJ>!EKF<>;M>:!<;! ?>@NB;@>!AB!@BL>!BMME@!@N>ET>?\@!@N>>MJ!E;F!AJ>!EKF<>;M>\@! <;A>?N?>AEAN>;F!B;!N?>@KNNB@E@!V5>D<>C@:!=EDK>@:!T;BXD>FP>:!>AM9W!AJEA! LET>!AJ>!@N>>MJ!5>D<>=E5D>g!VIIW9!,@!AJ>6!>DE5B?EA>!LB? >:!fX;K<;>!?J>AB??>!<@!E;!>Y

;M> i @BL>AJ<;P!AJEA!AJ>!@N>ET>?!E;F!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!XE;A!AB! F<@MK@@g!VIGW9!+JBKPJ!8?\@!XB?T!N?B=F!L>!X!EFFYA!)!;>>F>F!AB! ;A!BAJ>?!TEF!AJ>!A> YA@\!?J>AB?ED@:!2B;PET>?!E;F! 1EDT>?!N?B=F!L>!X!N?EPLEA!AJ<@!<;CB?LEA?N?>A<;P!AJ>!?J>AB?EMJ!BC!L6!A>YA@9 ! 4 HDJ? 0 D>78?7D7=? .6!E;ED6@<@!LEN@!AJ>!AJ>B?6!BC!!LE<;A>;E ;M>!B;AB!AJ>!@N>>MJ>@!XJ>?>! &5ELE!<@!?>@NB;F<;P!AB!NE?A@9!+J>!N??EAK?>!<@! 1;BF!AJ>!AJ>B?6!<;! <$$"+.!85#01$+8&85#*./#<2"%"A'&83# <#4>&")9#"B#K,*A&#E&8!")*!'".#=!)*!&A'&8 9!);!J <@!E?A! >;AF!f)LEP>!">NE!E;F! 3?<@ <@!3BLLK;!N?>@>;A@!E! C?EL>XB?T!CB?!!?>@AB?EA!@A?EA>P<>@/!fF>;=EF<;P!?>@NB;@<5FKM<;P!BCC>;@<=>;>@@!BC!AJ>!>=>;A:! MB??>MA<=>!EMA;B!AJ>!M?<@>@!AJEA!@>?=>!E@! AK@>@!CB?!L6!E?AM>@@E?!E!AJ?>EA!AB!AJ>!!BC!AJ>!@N>ET>?:!)!

PAGE 69

`G X!ENND6<;P!AJ>!?J>AB?P6!BC!fMB??>MA<=>!EMA?!AB!@>>!JBX! AJ>!A>YA@!E!?>MB=>?6!56!N?>@>;A<;P!@A?EA>P<>@!CB?!J>ED<;P!EA! 5BAJ!E!DBMED!E;F!E!D>P<@DEA<=>!D>=>D9 )A!<@!ED@B!!AJEA!8>;BB?6!BC!< LEP>!?>NE=BD=>F!<;AB!E! N?BL<;>;A @K5@>A!BC!?J>AB?B?69!,@!(B;6ED>!"9!*?< CC<;!%EFP>AA!E;F!.EAAJ>X!19! $>>P>?!>YNDE<;:!f)LEP>!?>@AB?EAB?6!JE@!P?BX;!C?BL!E!@N>MF!E?>E!BC!P>;?>! M?AB?J>;@<=>!5BF6!BC!AJ>B?6!E;F!?>@>E?MJ!F>AE!NB@AM?<@<@!MBLLK;P<>@!B?PE;<[EA!AB!?>NE!FELEP>!FB;>!56! @BL>!N>?M><=>F!X?B;PFB<;Pg!VIdIW9!4K?AJ>?LB?>:!"B5>?A!39!"BXDE;F!m!,;P>DE!.9!]>?BL>! F<@A<;PK<@J!5>AX>>;!AXB!MELN@!X?>;A!E@!BC!AJ>!C<>DF\@!NK?NB@>/!!?>NELNJE@<[>@!AJ>!N?BM>@@!BC!?>@AB?<;P!E;!!AJEA!JE@!5>>;!@>=>?>D6!MBLN?BL<@>F! 56!E!M?<@<@:!E;F!!LE<;A>;E;M>:!B?!fLE<;A>;E;M>!BC!E;!B=>?EDD!NB@!g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cB?!<;F!AJEA!AJ>! B?PE;<[EA;!@A>N@!AB!N?>=>;A!E!?>MK??>;M>!BC!AJ>!@D<>F!N?!CP<>@9!,@!)!5>PE;!;BA!EKF<>;M>@!L6!A>YA@!X>?>!

PAGE 70

`d AE?P>A< ;P:!)!XE@!E5D>!AB!M?!E;F!>=EDKEA>!XJ>AJ>?!&5ELE!XE@!A?KD6!F>LB;@A?EA<;P! MB;M>?;!CB?!AJ>!?;M> i @K?=<=B?@!BC!AJ>!A?EKLE i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h!CEM!J>ED<;P!CB?!=MAD6 ECC>MA>F!56!AJ>!M?<@<@!E;F!X?!EKF<>;M>@!XJB!@>?=>!E@!X@@>@!AB!AJ>!

PAGE 71

`Q F>@A?KMAEA>!E!@>;@>!BC!@>MK?< A6!FK?<;P!AJ>!?>@BDKA!M?<@<@h!E;F!AB! >@AE5D<@J!E!=<@!CKAK?>9!VdbHW! ! +J<@!NK?NB@>!PE=>!L>!E!5>AA>?!K;F>?@AE;F<;P!BC!XJEA!AB DBBT!CB?!E@!)!NE?@>F!L6!A>YA@:! N?BLNA<;P!L>!AB!CBMK@!B;!<@@K>@!BC!AJ>!MB?>!=EDK>@!E;F!5>D<>C@!N>?N>AKEA>F!56!AJ >!A>YA@!E;F! AJ>!XE6!AJ>@>!5>D<>C@!X>?>!C?EL>F!?J>AB?ED!AB!LKDA!EKF<>;M>@9! 4K?AJ>?LB?>:!*?AA!E;F!,DD<@B;!>@AE5D<@J!E!J>K?<@A@AB?EA<=>!?J>AB?DN>F!L>!MB;M>NAKED<[>!AJ>!@A?EA>P<>@!E;F!N?BM>@@>@!KAF!XF!L6!E;ED6@<@9!+J<@!J>K?<@A!CBDDBX<;P!@AEP>@/!VIW!<;EMA@@L>;A!BC!AJ>!M?<@<@:!VdW!<@@K>@!BC!5DEL>:!VQW!J>ED<;P!E;F!CB?P<=>;>@@:!E;F!V_W!MB??>MA<=>! EMA5KAA!E ;F!,DD<@B;!dbHW9!);!BAJ>?!XB?F@:!AJ>!?J>AB?! @KLLE?<[>@!J<@cJ>?!<;EMA!>=>;A!CBDDBX>F!56!E;!>YNDE;EA!@!;EAK?>!BC!AJ>!M?<@<@:!EDDBX<;P!AJ>!?J>AB?!AB!PEKP>!AJ>!@>?@@!BC!AJ>!>=>;A9!'>YA:! AJ>!@N>>MJ!P?ENND>@!X;A@!BC!5DEL>!E;F!EMMBK;AE5!A?EP>F6:!AJ>;! LB=>@!B;!AB!F<@MK@@<;P!AJ>!N?BM>@@!BC!J>ED<;P!E;F!NBA>;A!;>>F!CB?!CB?P<=>;>@@:! F>N>;F<;P!B;!XJB!B?!XJEA!<@!<;=BD=>F!E;F!AJ>!;EAK?>!BC!AJ>!5DEL>9!4<;EDD6:!AJ>!?J>AB?! N?>@>;A@!E@ E;F!?>MBLL>;FEA=>;A!AJ>!>=>;A!C?BL!JENN>;<;P! EPE<;!<;!AJ>!CKAK?>!E;F!F<@MK@@>@!JBX!AB!N?BM>>F!X!@N>M!N?BM>@@!BC!?>5K@AB?EA!CEM>!BC!AJ>!M?<@<@9! );!E!N?>=F!K@<;P!AJ>!J>K?<@AL>;A!5>MEK@>!AJ>!J>K?<@AAA!E;F!$>>P>?\@!MDE;@>LET<;P!<@!E!F6;EL!N?BM>@@:!;>?!D<;>E?:!;B?!K;MA! ?>@AB?EAB?6!C?EL>XB?T@!L@Ag!VIddW9!!,@!)!EAA>LNA>F!AB! >;EMA!AJ>!J>K?<@A=@AF!AJ>!B?F>?!BC!AJ>@>!@A>N@!E;F!

PAGE 72

`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g!V*?AA!E;F!,DD<@B;!dbHW9!86!CBMK@<;P!<;!B;!JBX!AJ>!@N>>MJ!EFF?>@@>@! @KMJ!F?>;A!EKF<>;M>@!@BK@D6:!)!XE@!E5D>!AB!EAA>;F!AB!&5ELE\@!A?>EAL>;A!BC!AJ>! ;>> F@!BC!AJB@>!XJB\=>!>YN>?<>;M>F!AJ>!A?EKLE!FMAD6!MBLNE?>F!AB!E!DE?P>?!EKF<>;M>! A?EKLEA<[>F!56!AJ>!M?<@<@!<;!E!LB?>!?>LB=>F!XE69!+J<@!AJ>B?>A;@!ED@B!EDDBX>F!L>!AB! EMT;BXD>FP>!AJ>!?>ED?!MBLN>A<;P!EKF<>;M>@!@KMJ!E@/!NBD;A@:!NB D
PAGE 73

``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fEFF?>@@>@!5BAJ!AJ>!F! EKF<>;M>!BC!AJB@>!ECC>MA>F!56!AJ>!M?<@<@!E;F!E!DE?P>?!L>FF!EKF<>;M>!BC!B5@>?=>?@!XJB! JE=>!AJ>!NBA>;A!@KNNB?Ag!V$>>P>?!E;F!*?AA!IdQW9 +J<@!AJ>B?6! EDDBX @ L>!AB!>YEL<;>! AJ>!XE6!&5ELE!;>PD>MA@!B?!MEN@!B;!AJ>!BNNB?AK;@!N?>@>;A>F!AB! J!F!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!>EMJ!A?EP>F69! +JK@:!AJ>!EKF<>;M>@!CB?!@KMJ!A>YA@!@NE;! AJ>!@N>MA?KL!<;!A>?L@!BC!AJ>DEA!M?<@<@!EA!JE;F:!XJ>AJ>?!AJ>6\=>!5>>;! @>=>?>D 6!F!B?!J<;F>?>F!56!AJ>?!AJ>6!E?>!MBLN>DD>F!AB!N?B=!E@@<@AE;M>! E;F!DBBT<;P!CB?!XE6@!AB!FB!@B9! ,MMB?F<;P!AB!$>>P>?!E;F!*?AA:!F <@MBK?@>!BC!?>;>XED! JE@!D>@@!AB!FB!X!E;F!LB?>!AB!FB!X!MBLND>Y!ECA>?LEAJ!BC! E!LEZB?!

PAGE 74

`a M?<@<@ i E@@!E;F!L>E;<;P!AB!AJ>!M?<@<@!<;!D!?>EDED<;P!E;F! ?>MB=>?6!E?>!F ^ MB;@KL<;P!N?BM>@@>@!VId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fN?B@N>MA<=>!CBMK@h!AJ>!BNNB?AK;@!<;J>?>;A!<;!AJ>!M?<@<@h!N?B=<@?!AJE;!@A?EA>P@NB;@>@h!E;F!>AJF!<;!MB?>!=EDK>@g! VIdaW9! DAD6:!AJ>!N?B@N>MA<=>!CBMK@!L>E;@!AJEA!AJ>!?>@NB;@>!>LNJE@<[>@!AJ>!M?<@<@!E@!E;! >Y

;M6!CB?!E!F<@MK@@!EMAJE=!BNNB?AK;@!<;J>?>;A!<;! AJ>!M?<@<@g!?>C>?@!AB!AJ>!NBA>;A;K>@!CB?!MJE;P>!AJEA!LE6!E?<@>!BKA!BC!AJ>! A?EP=>;A! <;!EFF!MJE;M>!AB!D>E?;!C?BL!AJ>!M?<@<@9!+JBKPJ!AJ<@!<@!BCA>;!NE?AD>=E;A!<;! ME@>@!XJ>?>!L<@AET>@!JE=>!5>>;!LEF>:!C>?!AB!AJ>!XE6!E!M?<@<@!ME;!5>! ?>NK?NB@>F!<;!@>?=!BC!E!NB@!D>@@B;!B?!AET>EXE69!-DAD6:!AJ>!BMMK??>;M>!BC!@KMJ! BNNB?AK;@!<;!AJ>!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!E!M?<@<@!fLE6!?>@KDA!<;!E!;>X!5>P<;;<;P:!E!?>5
PAGE 75

`b ;>X!NB<;A!BC!F>NE?AK?>!CB?!BN>?EA>P>?!E;F!*?AA!IdaW9! (<@MBK?@>!BC! ?>;>XED\@!>LNJE@<@!B;!MJE;P>!E;F!P?BXAJ!<;!AJ>!CEM> BC!M?<@<@!@A>>?>F!L>!ABXE?F!CBMK@<;P! B;!=>?5!A>;@>:!@N>M!CKAK?>!A>;@>:!AB!>YEL<;>!JBX!AJ>!A>YA@!N?>@>;A!@BDKA!M?<@>@!EA!JE;F9!,@!)!5>PE;!A?EMT<;P!=>?5!A>;@>:!)!;AF!NDEM>@!XJ>?>!AJ>!A>YA!BCC>?>F! E!N?>=<>X!BC!F!EMA!AET>;!<;!AJ>!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!E!M?<@<@9!)!ED@B!;BA>F! LBL>;A@!<;!AJ>!A>YA!AJEA!@NBT>!AB!E!LB ?>!F<@AE;A:!K;F>A>?L<;>F!CKAK?>!XJ>;!NBD5EA>!XBKDF!AJ>B?>A@KDA!<;!AJ>!>;EMAL>;A!BC!D>P<@DEAF!AB!MK?5!AJ>@>!>=>;A@! E;F!AJ>!FELEP>! AJ>6!MEK@>9 -DAD6:!F<@MBK?@>!BC!?>;>XED!EDDBX>F!L>!AB!CBMK@!B;!JBX! L6!A>YA@!F<@A<;PK<@J!5>AX>>;!AJ>!LB?>!F!E;F!EMM>@@<5D>!CKAK?>!E;F!E!LB?>!F<@AE;A! E;F!NBD?AE<;!CKAK?>!<;!B?F>?!AB!LEN!BKA!AXB!=>?6!F?>;A!MBK?@>@!BC!EMA
PAGE 76

`U & 2!3$-%' 444 !)'!)!,M#4#'*1'*"!0!O#'%-#3*)#-#'$*'$2-'!5%*%!'$2-!$-%'#2**$4)/P' #53-%#$*%0'#!).MP'!).'$2-'"*#$*)'0!%!$2*)'"*0"4)/ +J?BKPJ!E;!>YEL<;EA@NB;@>@!AB!AJ>!,K?B?E!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P:! $KN>?@AB?L!$E;F6:!E;F!AJ>!8B@AB;!.E?EAJB;!5BL5<;P:!L6! E;ED6@<@!JE@!AJ?>>!LEZB?! MB;MDK@PE?F @ AB!?J>AB?ED<;P:!?J>AB?A<;P!>Y

;M<>@:!E;F! ?J>AB?DLB;@A?EA>F!AJ?BKPJ!L6!E;ED6@<@!BC!;E??EA<=>:!L>AB;6L6:! E;F!L>AENJB?:!)!@JBX!JBX!?J>AB?ED<;P!BCA>;!N> ?N>AKEA>!;E??BX ^ L<;F>F! K;F>?@AE;F<;P@!BC!XJEA!E;@!AB!J>ED:! NB?A?E6<;P!D6!NJ6@! AJEA!AJ?BKPJ!MD!=AB?ED<;P!N?>@>;A!K;?>ED<@AYN>MAEAE;@!AB!@K?=<=>!E;F!?>MB= >?!C?BL!E!A?EKLE9! 4<;EDD6 :!56!>YEL<;<;P! EKF<>;M>!<;A>??KNA@NB;F@!AB!LKDA!MBLN>A<;P!>Y

;M<>@!<;!E! XE6!AJEA!CE=B?@!EKF<>;M>@!XJB!FYN>?<>;M>!AJ>!A?EKLE!EA!AJ>!>YN>;@>!BC!AJB@>!XJB! F=G':B'2?DI>7J +J>!OK>@A!NB?A?E6ED!BC!AJB@>!XJB!JE=>!@K?=<=>F!E!A?EKLE!?><;CB?M>@!E! ;E??BX ^ L<;F>F!N>?M>NA;PAJ!BC!MJE?EMA>?!E;F!>;FK?E;M>!DBBT!D!<;!AJ>! CEM>!BC!E!A?EP>F69!+J>!?J>AB?!XJB!JE=>!@K?=<=>F!A?EKLE!@KPP>@A!AJEA!XJ>;! ,L>?!ABP>AJ >?!<;!B?F>?!AB!L>>A!AJ>!F!;>>F@!BC!A?EKLE!@K?=<=B?@:!E! MBDD>MA<=>!@>;@>!BC!?>MB=>?6!ME;!5>!EMJ<>=>F9!86!E;ED6[<;P!AJ>@>!?J>AB?
PAGE 77

aH AJEA!AJ>6!NB@!F!56!AJ>!A?EP>F6!<;!XE6@!AJEA!N>?N>AKEA>!;E??BX! F>C<;ED<;P! E;F!?>MB=>?6!XJ!?B@!B;!@K?=<=B?@!BC!A?EKLE@9 +J>!f?J>AB?!J>?>!<;MDKF>!AJ>!<;=>;AB?6!BC!E;>MFBA>@!&5ELE! M?>EA>@!<;!?>@NB;@>!AB!$KN>?@AB?L!$E;F69!+JBKPJ!AJ>!<;A>;AJ<;F!AJ>@>!ENN>ED@!LE6! 5>!EFL:!AJ>6!E?> N?B5D>LEA!?>E@B;@/!I9W!>EMJ!N>?@B;\@!@AB?6!<@!PDB@@>F! B=>?!OK6>F!<;!;B!LB?>!AJE;!E!@>;A>;M>!B?!AXB:!G9W!>EMJ!@AB?6!<@!>@@>;AOK<=ED>;A!AB!AJ>!BAJ>?@:!?>LB=<;P!E;6!F>P?>>!BC!;KE;M>:!E;F!d9W!AJ>!N?C<;<;P! CEMAB?@!CB?! >EMJ!BC!AJ>!@K5Z>MA@\!;A@!E?>!AJ>FD6!CBDDBX<;P!AJ>! A?EKLE9!)!ED@B!E;ED6[>!&5ELE\@!L>;A;!XJB!@K?=<=>F!AJ>!,K?B?E!AJ>EA>?! @JBBA<;P9!)!AJ>;!CBMK@!B;!JBX!&5ELE\@!CELF!<;AB!J<@!?>@NB;@>@!AB!,K?B?E:! $KN> ?@AB?L!$E;F6:!E;F!$E;F6!0BBT9!4<;EDD6:!)!DBBT!EA!AJ>!K@>!BC!AJ>!N?B;BK;@!fX>g!E;F!fK@g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

PAGE 78

aI 5>MEK@>!AJ>!A>YA!JE@!F>MF!XJ>;!E;F!JBX!AB!MBLLK;!AJ>YN>?<>;M>@! X?@9!$BK@D6:!AJ>!A>YA!@! K;?>ED<@AYN>MAEA!N>?N>AKEA<;P!B=>?@F!K;F>?@AE;F<;P@!BC!J>ED<;P!E;F!?>NK?NB@<;P!,DD<>! E;F!$A>NJE;<>\@!;E??EA<=>!CB?!NBD@9!"J>AB?=>F!N?!A>YA\@!NB?A?E6ED!BC!,DD <>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>!E@!J>?B>@!<;!E!F?ELEA:!E@!ABDF! 56!&5ELE!E;F!<;A>;F>F!AB!5>! L>AB;6L?!>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!AJB@>!XJB!@K?=<=>F! AJ>!@JBBA<;P9!,FF=;A!AJ?BKPJ!AJ>!A>YA\@!K@>!BC!L>AENJB?!AB!F?EX! MB;;>MAAX >>;!AJ>!XE6!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>!B=>?MEL>!AJ>!A?EKLE!E;F!AJ>!XE6! ,L>?=>;AKEDD6!5>!E5D>!AB!LB=>!NE@A!AJ>!@JBBA<;P9 +J<@!5>P <;@!XJ>;!&5ELE!L>;A\ @!JEF!AJ>!MJE;M>!AB!<;A>?EMA!X!@JBBA<;P!EA!AJ>! -;<=>?@YA:!J> D>EF@!<;AB!AJ>! @AB?6!BC!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<> 9!0>?>!<@!&5ELE\@!=>?@=>;A@/ +J>?>l@!B;>!NE?ADD!5>MEK@>!AJ<@!XE@!AJ>!DE@A!=<@N?>@>;AEA<=>!BC!>=>?6AJ<;P!AJEA!)!@EX!E;F!J>E?F!ABF E69 ! )!JEF!E! MJE;M>:!ZK@A!;BX:!E5BKA!C<=>!L<;KA>@!EPB:!AB!=<@!eBK;P! ^^ ,DD<>!<@!IU!6>E?@! BDF! ^^ E;F!)!ED@B!JEF!E!MJE;M>!AB!=<@l@!5>@A!C?<>;F:!$A>NJE;<>!(E=<>@:!XJBl@! GI9 ! $A>NJE;<>!XE@!EMAKEDD6!FBX;@AE!E@!X>DD!E@!,DD <>l@!NE?>;A@!XJ>;!)! XEDT>F!<;AB!AJ>!?BBL9!,;F!)!FB;l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l@!AD6!EMA
PAGE 79

aG MB;=>?@EA!FBX;@AE!<@!PB<;P!AB!5>!C<;>9!)!FB;lA!T;BX!JBX! LE;6!N>BND>!EA!E;6!EP>!XBKDF!JE=>!AJ>!N?>@>;M>!BC!L<;F!AJEA!$A>NJE;<>!F! MBK?EP>!AJEA!,DD<>!@JBX>F9 ! ,;F!@B:!E@!A?EP!M@!BC!XJEA!X>\=>! @>>;!ABFE6!E?>:!E@!J>E?A5?>ET< ;P!E@!!CEL@:!;F<;P!LB@A! BC!BK?!A!?>CD>MA<;P!B;!6BK;P!,L>?!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>:!5>MEK@>!AJ>6! ?>N?>@>;A!XJEAl@!5>@A!<;!K@:!E;F!AJ>6!E@@K?>!K@!AJEA!BKA!BC!AJ<@!FE?T;>@@!E!5??! FE6!<@!PB<;P!AB!MBL>9 +J>!A>YA N KA@!K;?>ED<@AYN>MAEAN!E;F!$A>NJE;<>\@! ;E??EA<=>!E@!?>N?>@>;AEA<=>!BC!>=>?6B;>!XJB!@K?=<=>F!AJ>!A?EP>F69!1J>;!&5ELE!@AEA>@! AJEA/!f AJ>?>l@!B;>!NE?ADD!5>MEK@>!AJ<@!XE@!AJ>!DE@A!=<@N?>@>;AEA<=>!BC!>=>?6AJ<;P!AJEA!)!@EX!E;F!J>E?F!ABFE6:g!J>\@!LET<;P!E?!AJEA! AJ>?>\@!E!?>E@B;!XJ6!J>\@!A>DD<;P!AJ<@!@AB?69!)A!@JBX@!AJEA:!@<;M>!J>!JEF!ZK@A!=<@
F!,DD<>!E;F! $A>NJE;<>:!J>! N?B5E5D6 ?>L>L5>?@!AJ>!5>@A:!5KA! AB;6LYN>?<>;M>@!BC!AJ>!,K?B?E!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P:!E@!F>LB;@A?EA>F!AJ?BKPJ!J<@!K@>!BC! AJ>!XB?F!f?>N?>@>;AEA<=> 9g!3D>E?D6:!)!XE;A!AB!ECC!K@>!BC!@KMJ!E!XB?F!XJ>;! F>@M?<5<;P!AXB!N>BND>\@!>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!A?EKLE!FB>@ ;\A!@K!;>>F@!BC!AJB@>!XJB!@K?=<=>F! AJ>!A?EKLE i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

PAGE 80

ad @N>ET<;P!B;!5>JEDC!BC!;BA!ZK@A!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>:! 5KA!AJ>!BAJ>?!@K?=<=B?@!E@!X>DD9! -DAD6:!AJ>!@K?=<=B?@!BC!AJ<@!A?EKLE!E?>!>YNDB
F!<;!B?F>?!AB!ENN>ED!AB E!DE?P>?!EKF<>;M>! BC!,L>?;!<;!?>ED!A>YA!@JBKDF!5>!?>@NB;F<;P!AB!AJ>!M?<@<@!E;F!AJ>!;>>F@!BC! AJB@>!XJB\=>!@KCC>?>F!E@!E!?>@KDA!BC!AJ>!@JBBA<;P9!3B;@>OK>;AD6:!AJ>!NK?NB@>!CB?!AJ<@!@N>>MJ! <@!EL5;F>F!E@!E!?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!, K?B?E!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P9 86!@!A>YA!@;A!@AB?6A>DD> ?!X!NE?EFBY6 <;P E!CEMAKED!?>N?>@>;AEA!@AB?6!EA!JE;F XJ!P<=<;P! &5ELE! AJ>!D<5>?A6!AB!>F!E@!J>!@>>@!C!;EL> @ 5BAJ!$A>NJE;<>!E;F!,DD<>:! X@!E;F!EP>@:!@JBX<;P!AJ>!=>?EM!>=>;A@!J>\@!E5BKA!AB!F>@M?<5> E;F! =ED!E@!E!NK?=>6B?!BC!A?KAJ9!8KA!AJ<@!<@!E!FBK5D> ^ >FP>F!@XB?F/!E;B;6L!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!AJ>!A?EKLE9!86!P<=<;P!AJ>@:!AJBKPJ!N?>@KLE5D6!X?L<@@!A>YA!?<@T@!>YNB@<;P!$A>NJE;<>!E;F! ,DD<>!AB!E;!B;@DEKPJA!BC!@M?KA<;6!B;!5>JEDC!BC!AJ>!L>F!>D@>!XJB!MBKDF!A?EMT! AJ>L!FBX;9!+J>!A>YA\@! ;>YA!LB=>!<@!AB N?B=!E;!B=>?A! @!;EAK?>!BC!AJ>! ;E??EA<=>!E5BKA!AB!5>!ABDF :!E@!<;FF XJ>;!&5ELE!@E6@/!f ,;F!)!FB;lA!AJ<;T!AJ<@!@AB?6!JE@! 5>>;!J>E?F i EA!D>E@A!)!JEF;\A!?>EF!A i 5KA!)!XE;A>F!AB!@JE?>! B5@>?=EA @AB?6!<@;\A!BKA!<;!AJ>!NK5DA!F>LB;@A?EA>@ E!N>?M><=>F!MBLL;A! AB! E;!EMMK?EA>!NB?A?E6ED!BC!>=>;A@:!B?!LB?>!EMMK?EA>D6:!!BC!EMMK?EM6!E;F! EMMBK;AE5@!&5ELE!E;!>YMK@>!CB?!<;MDKF<;P!AJ<@!@AB?6!<;!J<@!@N>>MJ i AJ>! N >BND>!XE;A!AB!T;BX:!E;F!&5ELE!<@!@!;>>F!CB?!<;CB?LEA?A<;P! XJ6!AJ<@!@AB?6!;>>F@!AB!5>!ABDF :!AJ>!@N>>MJ!NB@!AJEA!<@;\A!;>M>@@E?F!CB?!<;!AJ<@!@M>;E?!<@!>YN>MA>F!AB!?>@NB;F!AB!AJ>!>=>;A@:!;BA ;>M>@@E?A>DD!

PAGE 81

aQ AJ>L 9 ! 0BX>=>?:!56!>@AE5D<@J<;P!AJ<@!;>>F!CB?!<;CB?LEA!N?>L<@>!CB?!XJ6!AJ>!@AB?6! <@!<;MDKF>F:!AJ>!A>YA!<@!L<@D>EF<;P!,L>?6<;P!AJ>!?>ED!A?EKLE:!XJ;!K ;F>?L<;>F!56!JBX!J>!>F@!<;!J<@! BX;!?>A>DD<;P!BC!>=>;A@9! 1 J!@>AA<;P!AJ>!@M>;>!CB?!AJ>!@JBBA<;P:!AJ>!A>YA!<@!E5D>!AB! LB=>!5>6B;F!E!@! ?>A>DD<;P!BC!>=>;A@!56!>;JE;M<;P AJ>!F?ELE!BC!AJ>!@;AE?6!B;! ,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;< >\@!L<;F@>A@!FK?<;P!AJ>!@JBBA<;P :!CK?AJ>?! NB?A?E6<;P!AJ>?B;!&5ELE!@E6@!AJEA:!fXJ>;!AJ>!PK;LE;!<;!<;!E;F!AJ?>X!AJ>! ME;<@A>?@:!J>!AJ?>X!AJ>L!B;D6!E!C>X!C>>A!EXE6!C?BL!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>:g!J>!>LNJE@<[>@!AJ>! F<@AE;M> 5>AX>>;!AJ>!PK;LE;!E;F!AJ>!AXB!XBL>;9!+J?BKPJ!AJ>!K@>!BC!AJ>!XB?F!fB;D6:g! &5ELE!<@!E5D>!AB!J!E;F!$A>NJE;<>!X>?>!@B!MDB@>!AB!AJ>!ME;<@A>?@!AJEA!AJ>6! X>?>!N?B5E5D6!<;MENEMF!56!XJEA>=>?!MJ>LD>E@>F9!86!J>;<;P!AJ>!FE;P>? BC!AJ>!M@!AJEA!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>!JEF!AB!CEM>:!AJ>!A>YA!<@!E5D>!AB!>D>=EA>!AJ>! A>;@!F?ELE!BC!&5ELE\@!=>?@=>;A@9 &L!XB?F!fB;D6g!B?!K@<;P!E! F?>;A!EF=>?5:!D!fENN?BYD6:g!XBKDF!5>!LB?>!MB;FKM<=>!AB!E;!>AJB@! BC!B5Z>MA<=EF:!E?!C?BL!&5ELE\@!>YNDE;EA!PK;LE;\@!<;!A>YA! EDDBX@!CB?!B;D6!B;>!?>EF<;P!BC!$A>NJE;<>!E;F!,DD<>\@!>YN>?<>;M>@!E@!NE?A!BC!E!J>?BA! N?>F>A>?L<;>F!;E??EA<=>9 ,@!&5ELE!F>@M?<5>@!,DD<>\@!EMA!A>YA!EAA>LNA@!AB!P>A!<;AB!J>?!L<;F:!AET<;P! D<5>?A<>@!X?!@AB?6!56!BCC>?<;P!<;@?!<;A>;A@!AB!CK?AJ>?!ZK@A?B@M?9 +J>!A>YA!>YNDE<;@!AJEA! ,DD<>!@ABBF!KN!5>MEK@>!@J>!?>MBP;<[>F! AJEA!f @J>! L>F!A B!FB!@BL>AJ<;P!B?!EA!D>E@A!XE?;!A J>!BAJ>?!N>BND>!XJB!X>?>!AJ>?>9g!

PAGE 82

a_ );!BAJ>?!XB?F@:!AJ>!A>YA!<@!MDE!@ABBF!KN9!+J<@!<@!CBDDBX>F!56!AJ>! B5@>?=EA?;EA<=>!MBK?@>!BC!EMA MBKDF!JE=>!AET>;/!AB f EA!D>E@A!XE?;! AJ>! BAJ>?!N> BND>!XJB!X>?>!AJ>?>9 g! ,A!AJ<@!LBL>;A!<;!AJ>!@AB?6:!AJ>!@N>>MJ!@KPP>@A@!AJEA!,DD<>! JEF!AXB!NBA>;AE@B;@!CB?!@AE;F<;P!KN!<;!AJ>!L!=;M>/!AB!fFB!@BL>AJ<;Pg!B?! A?6!E;F!XE?;!AJ>!?>@A!BC!AJ>!NEA?B;@!<;!AJ>!AJ>EA>?9!4@A@! AJEA!AJ >!D>E@A!,DD<>! MBKDF!FB! <;!AJ<@!@!5>>;!XE?;<;P! EDD!AJ>!BAJ>?!NEA?B; @!BC!XJEA!XE@! JENN>;<;P:!?!?>EMA!5>>;!<;ENN?BN?!B?!@>DC<@J9 )A\@ N?>@>;A<;P E!;E??BX!@N>MA?KL!BC!NBA>;A!MBKDF!JE=>!A ET>; <;!B?F>?!AB!@A! =<>X>F!E@!E!J>?B9!3D>E?D6:! AJ>!@N>>MJ!@!LB?>!DBP!CEM>!BC! =;M>:!D!CD>><;P!B?!FKMT<;P!5>J<;F!@BL>AJ<;P:!N?>A>;F<;P!E@!AJBKPJ!,DD<>!;>=>?!B;M>! AJBKPJA!BC!J>?!BX;!@EC>A69! $BK@D6: @KMJ E!@AEA>L>;A!;>PD>MA@!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA:!EL=>?6B;>!XBKDF!;>M>@@E?!E5D>!AB!EMA!@B!OK?! NEA?B;@!BC!AJ>!FE;P>? 9! 86!LENN<;P!?N?>AEA=>;A@!B;AB!AJ>!@AB?6:!AJ>!A>YA! @A?E6@!C?BL!E!@A?=>;A@!E;F!K;F>?L<;>@!&5ELE\@!?BD>!E@!E!NK?=>6B?! BC!A?KAJ9!.B?>!!@N>>MJ!NKA@!>YA?EB?F<;E?6!N?>@@K?>!B;!@K?=<=B?@!AB!D<=>!KN! AB!AJ>!J>?BYN>MAEAF!B;!AJ>L:!XJ!LE?P<;ED<[<;P!@K?=<=B?@!XJB!FB;\A!CKDC@>!>YN>MAEA!CEMA!AJEA!,DD<>!@ABBF!KN:!@>>T<;P!AB!BCC>?!J>DN!E;F!E@@<@AE;M>!AB! BAJ>?!N>BND>:!X!CEMA!AJEA!@J>!XE@!fFD6!@JBA:g!AJ>!A>YA!NB@?!;B5D>! <;A>;A!MEK@>!BC!J>?!<;ZK?<>@9!8>MEK@>!,DD<>!XE;A>F!AB!J>DN!BAJ>? @:!@J>!NKA!J>?@>DC! <;!FE;P>?!E;F!LEF>!J>?@>DC!=KD;>?E5D>!AB!AJ>!=;M>!K;CBDF<;P!<;!AJ>!AJ>EA>?9!#CC>MA<=>D6:! AJ>!A>YA!LE?A6?@!,DD<>!E;F!NB@!EMA!BC!@AE;F<;P!KN!E@!E!@EM?;F>E=B?9 '>YA:!

PAGE 83

a` A J?BKPJ!E!P?ENJ@M?\@!XBK;F@:!AJ >!A>YA!<@!CK?AJ>?!E5D>!AB!J! P?E=!A?EP>F6:!XJ;@!AJ>!>YA?EB?F<;E?6!;EAK?>!BC!AJ>!6BK;P! XBL>;\@!EMA\@!;>MT!f@AE?A>F!@NK?A<;P!5DBBF:g!AJ>!A>YA!<@! J!>YA>;A!BC!J>?!<;ZK?69!+JBK PJ!&5ELE!ZK@A!E@!>E@!@E! @AE?A>F!5D>>F<;P:!AJ>!=>?5!f@NK?A<;Pg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f,DD<>!ABDF!$A>NJE;<>!@J>!;>>F>F!AB!?K;g!5KA!AJEA!f$A>NJE;<>!?>CK@>F!AB!PB9g!+J> EKF<>;M>! ME;!>;=<@?@EA?>!D!E;F!F>EAJ!JE;P!<;!AJ>!5EDE;M>:!>EMJ! XBLE;!DBBT<;P!BKA!CB?!AJ>!@EC>A6!BC!AJ>!BAJ>?9!1J>;!,DD<>!A>DD@!$A>NJE;<>!AB!PB:! E?! AJEA AJ>!@AET >@!E?>!JEMJ!XBLE;!<@!XD<;OK<@J J>?!BX ;!@EC>A6!<;!CE=B?!BC! AJ>!BAJ>? 9!$<;M>!,DD<>!<@!@>=>?>D6!<;ZK?>F:!F!AJEA!@J>!XBKDF;\A!5>!E5D>!AB!CD>>!AJ>! PK;LE;h! AJ>?>CB?>: 56!A>DD<;P!$A>NJE;<>!AB!?K;:!@J>\@!>@@>;A?!C?<>;F!N>?L<@@A!J>?!F<>!<;!B?F>?!CB?!J>?!C?<>; F\@!D!AB!5>!@NE?>F9!86!@E6<;P!AJEA!$A>NJE;<>!f?>CK@>F!AB! PB:g!&5ELE!<@!>LNJE@<[<;P!$A>NJE;<>\@!B5@A<;EA>!MBLL;A!AB!@AE6<;P!X?!C?<>;F:!<;!

PAGE 84

aa @N
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f$A>NJE;<>!AJ>;:!X!J>DN!BC!@>=>?ED!BAJ>?@:!ME??<>@!,DD<>! EM?B@@!AXB!NE?T<;P!DBA@!AB!XJ>? >!AJ>!EL5KDE;M>!<@!XE;A!<;!AJ>! @AB?6!E@!$A>NJE;<>!LK@A!C<;<@J!AJ>!ZBK?;>6!E;F!P>A!,DD<>!AJ>!J>DN!@J>!;>>F@!<;!B?F>?!AB! @K?=<=>9!+J>!ZBK?;>6!<@!MD>E?D6!FD<>@!B;!E!@NEA@M?!FEK;A<;P!;EAK?>!BC!AJ>!ZBK?;>6!EJ>EF9!+J<@!<@!AJ>! NB<;A!XJ>?>!AJ>!<;A>?=>;A=>?ED!BAJ>?@g! 5>MBL>@!M?6!J>DN!$A>NJE;<>! MBLND>A>!E!ZBK?;>6!@J>!LE6!B?!LE6!;BA!5>!E5D>!AB!MBLND>A>!EDB;>9!8 KA! AJ<@!LBL>;A!<@ ED@B! E;!BNNB?AK;!A>YA!AB!ME?=>!BKA!E!NDEM>!<;!AJ>!;E??EA<=>!XJ>?>!AJ>!EKF<>;M> ME;! >;=<@L@>D=>@9!-DAD6:!AJ<@!NB<;A!<;!AJ>!;E??EA<=>!<@!E5D>!AB!CK;MA@M?D6! 56!LBF>D<;P!E!?BD>!CB?!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!AB!CKDC!?>@A!BC!AJ>!;EA< B;!<@!E5D>!AB!MBL>!

PAGE 85

ab ABP>AJ>?!E;F!?>EMJ!BKA!AB!AJB@>!XJB!JE=>!@K?=<=>F!AJ>!A?EKLE:!AJ>;!MBDD>MA<=>D6:!AJ>!;EA!E5D>!AB!CD6!ME??6!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>:!E@!X>DD!E@!BAJ>?!@K?=<=B?@:!AJ?BKPJ!AJ<@! F69! +J<@!LBL>;A!<@!<;F!BC! E;!EKF<>;M>!BC!AJB@>!XJB!FYN>?<>;M>! AJ>!A?EKLE!FMAD6:!E;F!D6!@>?=>@!AB!?>L<;F!AJ>L!BC!AJ>!C?BL!AJ>! A?EKLE!56!?><;CB?M<;P!AJ>!E;F!P<=>!5EMT!AB!AJ>!@K?=<=B?@9! );!&5ELE\@!MB;MDK@!@AB?6:!J>!FB> @!$A>NJE;<>!E;F!,DD<>!E;!>P?>P?=!56!E@@KL<;P!AJEA!NJ6@EDAJ!<@!<;F!BC!B=>?EDD!J>EDAJ:!AJK@!;>PD>MA<;P! AJ>!?>ED!?>MB=>?6!N?BM>@@!EJ>EF!CB?!5BAJ!XBL>;9! +J<@!<@!>=;A!XJ>;!&5ELE! @AEA>@!AJEA:!f)!ZK@A!JEF!E!MB;=>?@EA!FBX;@AE!<@!PB<;P!AB!5>!C<;>9g!+J>! @AEA>L>;A!AJEA!f@J>!<@!PB<;P!AB!5>!C<;>g!N?B=@!E!@>;@>!BC!?>@BDKA! EKF<>;M>!AB!5?>EAJ>!E!@D<>C:!T;BX<;P!AJEA!,DD<>!JE@!E!NB@!CKAK?>!EJ>EF!BC!J>?9! 0BX>=>?:!AJ>!E@@>?A!X!fC<;>g!<@!N?B5D>LEAMEK@>!OKEA>@!J>?! X>DD5><;P!@BD>D6!XEDAJ!E;F:!LB?>!@N>MPD>MA@!AJ>!?BD>! BC!L>;AED!E;F!>LBAEDAJ:!NB@ED<;P!@A??:!<;!@N
!B C! AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!,DD<>!XD6!5>!@ME??>F!56!AJ>!A?EP>F6!E;F!NBA>;A!X@@!F<@B?F>?!E@!E!?>@KDA!BC!AJ>!@JBBA<;P9!+J<@!CK?AJ>?!LE?P<;ED<[>@!@K?=<=B?@!XJB! XB;\A!f5>!C<;>g!56!F>L>E;<;P!AJ>!;E??EA<=>@!BC!BAJ>?@!XJB!@K@AE<;!F <@E5@!B?!L>;AED! J>EDAJ!<@@K>@!MEK@>F!56!AJ>!@JBBA<;P9 &;M>!&5ELE!MBLND>A>@!AJ>!@AB?6:!AJ>!@N>>MJ!N?B=@!MBLL>;AE?6!B;!AJ>! ;E??EA<=>:!>;MBK?EP<;P!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!AB!?>EF!AJ>!@AB?6!<;!E!M>?AE<;!XE6!E;F!AB!D>E?;!C?BL! ,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>\@!EMA!@AB?6:! &5ELE!@AEA>@!AJEA!f;F<;P!LB@A!BC!BK?!A!?>CD>MA<;P!B;!6BK;P!,L>?!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>:!5>MEK@>!

PAGE 86

aU AJ>6!?>N?>@>;A!XJEAl@!5>@A!<;!K@9g!);@A>EF!BC!AJ<;T<;P!E5BKA!AJ>!DB@@!B?!AJ>!P?<>C:!B?!>=>;! XJEA!MBKDF!5>!FB;>!A B!E=BN>EA<;P!@KMJ!A?EP>F<>@:!AJ>!A>YA!>;MBK?EP>@!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!AB! f?>CD>MAg!B;!AJ>@>!<;F<=?@!D!AJ>L i ;BA!;>M>@@E?MEK@>!BC!AJ>!A?EP>F6! AJ>6\=>!@K?=<=>F:!5KA!5>MEK@>!BC!XJEA!AJ>LEA MEK@>!@!K;?>ED<@AYN>MAEAMEK@>!,DD<>!E;F! $A>NJE;<>!JE=>!5>>;!NKA!B;!E!N>F>@AED!E@!>YELND>@!BC!AJ<@!MBK;A?6\@!P?>EA;>@@:!EDD!BAJ>?! @K?=<=B?@!BC!A?EKLE!XJB!FB!;BA!D<=>!KN!AB!AJ<@!>YN>MAEA!<;C>?YELND>@!BC! XJEA!AJ>! -;
F!$AEA>@!JE@!AB!BCC>?!E;F!NBA>;A@@!,L>?@KDA9!$>MB;F:!AJ<@!<@!XJ>?>! AJ>!A>YA!@J!CBMK@!BC!AJ>!@N>>MJ!C?BL!AJ>!@K?=<=B?@!BC!AJ>!A?EP>F6!AB!AJ>!MBK;A?6!E@!E! XJBD>!56!?>NK?NB@<;P!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>\@!;E??EA<=>!E@!CBF F>?!CB?!E!NBD!BC! ,L>?YM>NA!E;F!$A>NJE;<>!AB!?>N?>@>;A!EDD!,L>?D6!@A?BT<;P!AJ>!EKF<>;M>\@!MBDD>MA<=>!>PB@!56!E@@BML!X!J>?B<@L!BC! AJ>@>!AXB!XBL>;9!,@!E!?>@KDA:!A J>!EKF<>;M >!XEDT@!EXE6!XF!CEsEF>!BC!XJEA!E;@!AB!5>!,L>?E;@!AB!@K?=<=>!E!A?EP>F69 ! 4<;EDD6:!AJ>!@N>>MJ!MBLND>A>@!AJ>!;E??EA<=>!56!K@<;P!?!MDE!CKAK?>!BC!AJ>!MBK;A?6!X!<;!AJ>!ECA >?LEAJ!BC!AJ>!,K?B?E!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P9! $A>NJE;<>!E;F!,DD<>\@!@AB?6!FB>@;\A!ZK@A!@>?=>!E@!E;!>YELND>!BC!AJ>!MBK;A?6\@!P?>EA;>@@:!5KA! ?=>@!E@!ZK@A!<;!E!5??!CKAK?>9!);!B?F>?!AB!FMA! AJ>!EKF<>;M>!AB!?>EF!AJ>!A>YA <;!E!M>?AE<;!XE6:!&5ELE!@AEA>@!AJEA!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>:!E;F! AJ>!,L>?!AJ>L:!fE@@K?>!K@!AJEA!BKA!BC!AJ<@!FE?T;>@@!E!5??!FE6!<@!PB<;P!AB! MBL>9g!);!BAJ>?!XB?F@:!AJ>!A>YA!K@>@!AJ>!L>AENJB?!BC!FE?T;>@@!AB!?>N?>@>;A!=;M>:!NE<;:! E;F!>=@!@@!AJ>!MBK;A?6!XMA<=>D6!

PAGE 87

bH >L>?P>!C?BL9!+J>!>=;M>!CB?!@KMJ!BNA@@:!,DD<>!E;F! $A>NJE;<>!X>?>!@A!>LE;EA>!D?!XB?F@:!D?=>@!E@!E!L>AENJB?!CB? AJ>@>! XBL>;\@!J>?B<@L:!5?E=>?6:!E;F!C?<>;F@JYJ<5
F!<;!AJ>!LB@A!A?6<;P!BC!M@9! +JBKPJ!LKMJ!BC!AJ>!D?EAK?>!B;!AJ>!?J>AB?YEL<;>@!AJ>!K@>!BC!L>AENJB?!E@!E! J>DNCKD!ABBD! AJEA! @K?=<=B?@!ME;!K@>!AB!MB;=>6!AJ>?XB?DFD6!>YN>?< >;M>@!BC!A?EKLE:!E! @>NE?EA>!?J>AB?!XJB!JE@!;BA!@K?=<=>F!AJ>!A?EKLE!5KA!K@>@!L>AENJB?!AB!?>A>DD!E!@K?=<=B?\@! >YN>?<>;M>@!?<@T@!F>L>E;<;P!AJ>!?>A>DD<;P9! +JBKPJ AJ>!K@>!BC!@KMJ!F>=@!FB>@!;BA! @<;PD>JE;F>FD6!>;@K?>!AJEA! E!@K?=<=B?!BC!A?EKLE X

!E5D>!AB M B;=>6!AJ>!>YN>?<>;M>! L>E;<;PCKDD6 AJ?BKPJ!L>AENJB?:!E!?J>AB?\@! ?>D!B;!A?BN>@!B?!L>AENJB?@!?<@T@! F>N?>M!>YN>?<>;M>!AB!LET>!@@<5D>!AB!E;!EKF<>;M>!AJEA!JE@;\A!>YN>?<>;M>F! AJ>!A?EKLEA=>;A9 -DAD6: <;!AJ<@!ME@>: AJ>!A>YA!ZKYAENB@>@ AJ>!B=>?MBL<;P!;E??EA<=>! LENN>F!B;AB!,DD<>!E;F!$A>NJE;<>\@!>YN>?<>;M>!X!XE6!,L>?!E5D>!AB! B=>?MBL>!AJ>!A?EKL E!E;F!>L5?EM>!E!5??!CKAK?>9!86!K@<;P!AJ>!L>AENJB?!BC!E!5??! CKAK?>:!&5ELE!;>>FD>@@D6!?>D<>@!B;!A?BN>@!E;F!L>AENJB?@!XJ> ;!AJ>?>!E?>!LB?>!MBLND>Y! XE6@!BC!MENAK?<;P!AJ>!>YN>?<>;M>!XFKM<;P!AJ>!A?EKLE!J>!F=>;!>YN>?<>;M>!AB! E!@9 ! :*!)'"!8#*8#<,&)'$*.#7&)"&83#7&*%'.A#!>)"+A>#7'8!")9# # +J>!K@>!BC!AJ>!J>?B!;E??EA<=>!AET>@!E!F< CC>?>;A!CB?L!<;!?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!8B@AB;! LE?EAJB;!5BL5<;P:!MB;@?<;P!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!&5ELE!JE@!DD6!;BA!JEF!AJ>!BNNB?AK;ET!AB!=!A?EP>F6:!E@!J>!FB>@!EA!AJ>!-;<=>?@EF:! AJ>!A>YA!EAA>LNA@!AB!@!AJ>!>;A !M?B
PAGE 88

bI !AJEA!?>@B;EA>@!LB?>!MDB@>D6!X!J<@AB?6!E;F!MJE?EMA>?!BC!8B@AB;9!86!E@M?<5<;P! AJ>!?BD>!BC!NEA?MA<=>D6:!&5ELE!<@!E5D>!AB!KA!E!?J>AB?! @!J>?B!;E??EA<=>!B;AB!AJ>!A?EP>F69!0BX>=>?:!AJ>!NEA?! >;E5D>@!J>A<;P!E;6!BC!AJ>!=! K;;>@@!BC!8B@AB;\@!J<@AB?6!E;F!!<;!AJ>!CBK;F<;P!BC!AJ>!MBK;A?6!AB!N?>@M?<5>! @A?EA>P<>@!CB? JBX!AB!J>ED9 86!ENN>ED<;P!AB!AJ>!J<@AB??B<@L!BC!AJ>!NEA?;E5D>@ EKF<>;M>@!AB!C!A?EKLE!<;AB!AJ>MB;M><=>F!;BA!A?EKLE! <;=BD=>@!E;F!JBX!?@B;ED!BDBP<>@!E;F!@>;@>!BC!;EA:!&5ELE!;BA>@!AJEA!,N?!FE6!BC!AJ>! 5BL5<;P!ED@B!MB<;M@!X!AB!AJ>!@AEA>!BC!.E@@EMJK@>AA@/!%EA?!>;F!BC!AJ>!@N>>MJ:!&5ELE!;BA>@!AJ>!MB<;M;M>!XJ>;!J>!@AEA>@/! +BFE6!<@!E!JBDAA@! ^ %EA?D>5?EA>@!AJ>!C?>>! E;F!C<>?M>D6!<;F>N>;F>;A!@NEA!,L>?CD>MA>F! C?BL!AJ>!>E?D<>@A!FE6@!BC!BK?!;EA!XB?DF!AB!8B@ AB;\@! @A?>>A@!<;!E!@N;FD6!MBLN>A@;A!ABX;9!$B!E?>! BND>9!)lL!@KN?>L>D6!MB;C;A!AJEA!8B@AB;AJ>?:!AET>!ME?>!BC! >EMJ!BAJ>?:!E;F!LB=>!CB?XE?F! E@!B;>!N?BKF!M6! FB:!AJ>!,L>?BND>!X!XL!>=>?6!@<;PD>!@A>N!BC!AJ>!XE69 ! +J<@!NE=>@!AJ>!XE6!CB?!&5ELE!AB!?>NDEM>!AJ>!J>?B!;E??EA<=>!X!AJEA!J>! AJ>;!LEN@!B;AB!AJ>!>;A!M!JBD>!E;F! C<>?M>D6!<;F> N>;F>;A!@N!A>YA!J@>!OKED@!CB?!E!?>E@B;/!AJ>6!E?>!;BA! B;D6!XJEA!LET>@!8B@AB;!P?>EA:!5KA!AJ>6!E?>!ED@B!AJ>!OKED@!AJEA!X;E5D>!8B@AB;!AB! B=>?MBL>!AJ>!A?EP>F69!+J>!!BC!AJ>!NEA?ECC!OK<;A>@@>;A?< ME;;>@@g!AJEA!8B@AB;!>L5BF<>@:!>@N>M?<;P!!?BD>!E;F!NB@
PAGE 89

bG X?!A>YA!CK?AJ>?!<;=BT>@!AJ>!NBX>?!BC!J<@AB?6!E;F!D>PEM6!XJ>;!J>! EMT;BXD>FP>@!AJEA!8B@AB;!JE@!5>>;!@B!C?>>!E;F!<;F>N>;F>;A!fC?BL!AJ>!>E?D<>@A!FE6@!B C!BK?! ;EAC>??<;P!5EMT!AB!AJ>!NE@A!E;F!8B@AB;\@!J<@AB?6!E;F!D>PEM6:!&5ELE!<@!AJ>;!E5D>! AB!ZK@A!B;!E@!E!@A?B;P!,L>??!EDD:! AJBKPJ!XM;A!A>YA!@!AJEA!!AB!@AE;F!@A?B;P! E;F!X!=;A!CB?M>@!BC!AJ>!>E?D6!CBK;F<;P!BC!AJ<@!MBK;A?6:!D!AJ>!,L>?=BDKA;!@K?>D6:!AJ>6!X!E5D>!AB!X!5DBX!AJ>!E@!E!?>@KDA! BC!AJ<@!F>=E@AEAL<;F<;P!AJ> N>BND>!BC!8B@AB;!AJEA!AJ>!8B@AB;!.E?EAJB;!<@!fE!FE6!AJEA!F?EX@!AJ>! XB?DF!AB!8B@AB;\@!@A?>>A@!<;!E!@N;FD6!MBLN>A!A>YA!E@>?=>!AJ>! B?P?;A!BC!AJ>!LE?EAJB;!56!A6<;P!!ECB?>L>;AF!@A?>;PAJ@! BC AJ>!fC?>>!E;F!C<>?M>D6!<;F>N>;F>;Ag!MLNA@!AB!?><;CB?M>!AJ<@!;AMDE!>=>;A!<;!EMMB?FE;M>!X?!AJE;!EDDBX<;P!! F>C<;>F!56!=;M>9!0>!<@!>@@>;A!LE?EAJB;!DC! E@!>=;M>!BC!8B@AB;\@! K;!;A!X?!N?>=;AF! OKED@:!AJ>!A>YA!E@@>?A@!AJEA!f8B@AB;!<@!E!ABKPJ!E;F!?>@;A!ABX;9!$B!E?>!BND>9g!);! AJ<@!NB?A!@N>>MJ:!8B@AB;!5>MBL>@!E!LEM?BM B@L!BC!@B?A@!CB?!AJ>!N>BND>!BC!8B@AB;:! <;FAB;6LDEAAX>>;!AJ>!AXB9!+J>?>CB?>:!@<;M>!AJ>!M;@!BC! 8B@AB;!E?>!MB;AE<;>F!X!>;AET<;P!BC:!AJ>6!ABB!E?>!E@@F!AJ>! @EL>!F>@M?<;CB?M<;P!AJ>!E! AJEA!AJ>!OKED@!E@M?<5>F!AB!8B@AB;!E?>!ED@B!C@;A@:!AJ>!A>YA!<@!AJ>;!E5D>!AB!MB;C;AD6!E@@>?A!AJEA!f 8B@AB;AJ>?:!AET>!

PAGE 90

bd ME?>!BC!>EMJ!BAJ>?:!E;F!LB=>!CB?XE?F! E@!B;>!N?BKF!M!E!F!AB! LET>!E @!AJ>!@N>>MJ!JEF!N?>=@AE5D<@J>F!AJEA!B;>!BC!AJ>!@A?>;PAJ@!BC!8B@AB;!<@!?M>D6!<;F>N>;F>;A!;EAK?>9!0BX>=>?!<;!AJ<@!D<;>:!AJ>!A>YA!>LNJE@<[>@!AJ>!;>>F!CB?!K;AJ>?;>@@!<;!AJ>!CEM>!BC!E!A?EKLE9!+JBKPJ!AJ>@>!OKED@!L>L!EA!BFF@ X!AB!5D>;F!AJ>L!56!NB@!T>6!AB!8B@AB;!?> ^ >@AE5D<@J<;P!DC! E@!fB;>!N?BKF!M!K@>!BC!fN?BKFg!<@!>@@>;A?>:!E@!fC<>?M>D6!<;F>N>;F>;Ag!LE6!ED@B! MB;ZK?>!LB?>!@PEA<=>!OKED@!D!N?!E;F!;E? M<@@<@L9!8KA!?EAJ>?:!&5ELE!<@! ?>NK?NB@<;P!AJ>!;BAD6!@E6<;P!AJEA!8B@AB;!L>?@M?@N>M! ^ >L>?P>@!C?BL!AJ>!A?EP>F6!EA!JE;F9!-;!AET>EXE6/!fB;>g!N?BKF! MAJ>?!56!!?BD>:!J <@AB?6:!E;F!MJE?EMA>?9! +J>!K@>!BC!AJ>!L>AENJB?!fLB=>!CB?XE?Fg!<@!ED@B!M?!@N>>MJ!AB! F?EX!NE?EDD>D@!5>AX>>;!AJ>!=>?6!A?EP>F6!AJEA!MEDD>F!AJ>!@N>>MJ!<;AB!5><;P!E;F!AJ>!@A?EA>P<>@! AJ>!M!AB!J>ED9!+J>!MJB!BC!fLB=>!CB?XE?Fg! <@!K;D6!>CC>MA<=>!MB;@?<;P!5BAJ! AJ>!>Y

;M6!BC!AJ<@!NE?A??B?<@A!EAAEMT!EA!AJ>!8B@AB;!LE?EAJB;!E;F!AJ>!;AEF6!F!B;!AJ>!M@!AJ>!L>AENJB?!LB?>!>CC>MA<=>! CB?!AXB!?>E@B;@9!4ET@!AB!AJ> NK?NB@>!E;F!;EAK?>!BC!AJ>!LE?EAJB;!DC9!)A!>=BT>@! AJ>!D?ED!EMA!BC!LB=<;P!CB?XE?F:!?>@B;EA<;P!X!NK?NB@>!BC!E!LE?EAJB;/!AB!?K;!AJ>! MBK?@>!E;F!>YJ<5;FK?E;M>!<;!NK?@K!C<;<@J!D<;>9!+JK@:!AJ<@!L>AENJB?!NB@MB=>?6!E@!E!C<;<@J!D< ;>!BC!@B?A@9!+J>B?>A@B;EA>@!LB?>!X!XJB! NE?AF!<;!AJ>!LE?EAJB;9!$>MB;F:!<;CB?M>@!AJ>!E!BC!AJ>!;>M>@@@N>M?A<;>;A!AB!?>NK?NB@<;P!8B@AB;\@!<;F>N>;F>;A!;EAK?>!<;!CE=B?!BC! K;!PBED9!+BP>AJ>?:!<;!B?F>?!AB!LET>!N?BP?>@@!E;F!MBLL
PAGE 91

bQ FMAM!>=>;A!E;F!ABXE?F@!J>ED<;P!E;F!?>MB=>?6:!8B@AB;! LK@A!>CC>MA<=>D6!DBBT!BKA!CB?!>EMJ!BAJ>?!E;F!5>!XCCB?A9 ! +J>!K@>!BC!AJ<@!L>AENJB?!CK?AJ>?!>@AE5D<@J>@!AJ>!N?>@>;M>!BC!E!DE?P>?!MBLLK;?!EFF!AB!AJ>!M@;A@9!+J<@! <@!>=;A!XJ>;!&5ELE!@E6@!AJEA!f AJ>!,L>?BND>!X!XL!>=>?6! @<;PD>!@A>N! BC!AJ>!XE69 g!+J>!>LNJE@<@!B;!f>=>?6!@A>Ng!F?<=>@!JBL>!AJ>!?>ED;PAJ6:!>YJEK@A<;P:! E;F!F69!8KA:!LKMJ!D!E!LE?EAJB;:!AJ>!,L>?BND>!E?>!ED@B!AJ>?>!AB! @KNNB?A!8B@AB;!E;F!>;MBK?EP>!AJ>L!EDB;P!AJ>!XE69!&;!AJ>!B;>!JE;F :!@KMJ!EDDK@! LE?EAJB;!LE6!5>!E!LB?>!JB;>@A!?>N?>@>;AEA!J>ED<;P!E;F!?>MB=>?6!N?BM>@@:!@<;M>! AJ>6!J!BC!AJ>!>CCB?A!E;F!MBLL;A!<;=BD=>F!AJE;!AJ>!f5?@@!BKA!BC!AJ>! FE?T;>@@g!L>AENJB?!K@>F!<;!,K?B?E9!&;!AJ>!BAJ>?!JE;F:! AJ>!K@>!BC!AJ<@!L>AENJB?!NB@>@! N?B5D>LEA?@AE;F<;P@!BC!J>ED<;P!56!B=>?@!?>MB=>?6!N?BM>@@9! 4K?AJ>?LB?>:!AJ>!E5D><@A!;EAK?>!BC!AJ<@!L>AENJB?!LE6!ED@B!@>?=>!AB!LE?P<;ED<[>!AJB@>!XJB! XD6!CEM>!F>5@!E;F!F<@E5@!E @!E!?>@KDA!BC!AJ>!>=>;A9!3B;@?<;P!AJ>! CEMA!AJEA!LE;6!BC!AJ>!<;ZK?<>@!@K@AE<;>F!E@!E!?>@KDA!BC!AJ>!5BL5<;P!X>?>!DBX>? ^ 5BF6!<;ZK?<>@:! <;MDKF<;P!LE;6!ELNKAEA!C>>A!E;F!D>P@:!@KMJ!E!L>AENJB?!LE6!<;!CEMA!;BA!?>@B;EA>! X=>;A:!5 KA!?EAJ>?!@>?=>!AB!JXCBK;F!>YMDK@AENJB?9 ! NC&#L"+.$&#L*$OP3#7&*%'.A#*8#*#@>*)'!*;%&#*./#@",,+.*%#0BB")! # ,@!N?>=;AF:!@AB?<>@!BC!A?EKLE!E?>!KDAD6!BCC>?>F!;BA!E@!@BDEM>!AB! =@!AB!>LNEAJ<[ >:!5KA!E@!>=;M>!BC!AJ>!@A?>;PAJ!BC!AJ>!,L>?BND>9!

PAGE 92

b_ &5ELE\@!@N>>MJ!<;!?>@NB;@>!AB!$KN>?@AB?L!$E;F6!@T?!AJ>!@A>N@!EMAKEDD6!;>>F>F!AB! J>ED:!MDE!E?>!f5BK;M<;P!5EMTg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d9W!AJ>!N?C<;<;P!CEMAB?@!CB?!>EMJ!BC!AJ>!@K5Z>MA@\!;A@!E?>!AJ>FD6!CBDDBX<;P! AJ>!A?EKLE9!+J<@!KDAD6!?>FKM>@!AJ>!@K?=<=B?@!AB!MD?B>@!XJB!JE=>!B=>?MBL>!AJ>! A?EKLE:!LE?P<;ED<[<;P!>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!@K?=<=B?@!XJB!FB!;BA!CBK@D6 :!AJ>! K@>!BC!@KMJ!E;>MFBA>@!<;!MB;ZK;MA!f5BK;M>!5EMTg!L>AENJB?!LET>@!J>ED<;P! @>>L!>E@<>?!AJE;!EDD6!<@!XJ!5D>;F<;P!ABP>AJ>?!=E?6<;P!>YN>?<>;M>@!BC!AJ>!A?EKLE!E;F! BAJ>?!EDA>?;EA<=>!L>E;@!BC!NK?@K<;P!?>MB=>?69 +J?BKPJ!AJ> K@>!BC!AJ?>>!@>NE?EA>!E;>MFBAED!>YELND>@:!&5ELE!<@!E5D>!AB!J!f@A?>;PAJ!E;F!?>@;M>g!BC!AJ>!,L>?L5BF<>F!56!AJ>!6BK;P!N>BND>! =BDK;A>>?<;P:!AJ>!?>@AEK?E;A!BX;>?:!E;F!AJ>!I_ ^ 6>E? ^ BDF!5B69!0>?>!<@!AJ>!>YM>?NA!C?BL!AJ>! @N>>MJ!XJ> ?>!&5ELE!?>C>?>;M>@!AJ>@>!N>BND>/ ,@!)!XE@!ZK@A!PEAJ>?<;P!E?BK;F:!)!JEF!E!MJE;M>!AB!AEDT!AB!@BL>!BC!AJ>!6BK;P!N>BND>! J>?>!XJB!JE=>!5>>;!=BDK;A>>?<;P:!PB<;P!KN!E;F!FBX;!AJ>!5DBMT!MD>E;<;P!KN!

PAGE 93

b` F>5?<@9 ,;F!XJ>;!X>!X>?>!B=>?!EA!AJ>!MBLLK;;A>?:!AJ>?>!XE@!E ?>@AEK?E;A! BX;>?!XJB:!CB?!AJ>!DE@A!Ib!JBK?@:!JEF!5>>;!MBBT<;P!L>ED@:!ZK@A!E@!J<@!MB;A?<5KA!?>MB=>?6!N?BM>@@9 ,;F!@BL>!BC!AJ>!CBDT@!X>?>!@E6<;P!AJ>!CBBF!XE@!5>AA>?!AJE;! AJ>6!PBA!EA!JBL>9 eBK!JEF!E!I_ ^ 6>E? ^ BDF!6BK;P!LE;!XJB@>!LBAJ>?!XE@!F<@E5D>F:! E;F!J>!XE@!LET<;P!@K?>!AJEA!@J>!XE@!BTE6:!E;F!AET<;P!B;!>YA?EB?F<;E?6! ?>@NB;@<5@!CB?!JDC!5KA!ED@B!CB?!J<@!LBL9 +J>!<;=>;AB?6!BC!>YN>?<>;M>@!5>P<;@!X@>!E;>MFBA>@!X?<;P!E?BK;F:g!N?>@>;A<;P!J<@!<;A>?E MA!CBDDBX<;P!N>BND>!E@!;EAK?ED!E;F! B?PE;?!AJE;!NDE;A>F!B?!N>?CB?L>F:!XJ@>!E;>MFBA>@!X;A!A>YA!>LNJE@<[>@!AJEA!&5ELE!fJEF!E!MJE;M>!AB!AEDT!AB!@BL>!BC!AJ>!6BK;P! N>BND>!J>?>9g!.KMJ!D!<; J<@!@N>>MJ!B;!,K?B?E:!&5ELE!<@!J!EMABND>!<;!?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!A?EP>F6:!?EAJ>?!AJE;!E;6!BAJ>?!P?BKN!BC!N>BND>:!BL! >YN>?<>;M>@!BC!fBDF>?g!,L>?6!E?>!NBA>;AA>DD<;P9!+J>! @N>>MJ!N? >@>;A@!6BK;P!,L>??B<@L!E@!LB?>!<;@N?!,L>??LB?>:!AJ>!N>BND>!C>EAK?>F!<;!AJ<@!<;=>;AB?6!E?>!F>C<;>F!56!AJ>@!BKA!BC!J<@!XE6!AB!;BA>!AJEA!AJ>@>!6BK;P!,L>??>!f PB<;P!KN!E;F!FBX;!AJ>!5DB MT! MD>E;<;P!KN!F>5?<@ 9g!'BA!B;D6!FB>@!AJ<@!J!MBLL;A!E;F!A>;EM@>!6BK;P! N>BND>!JE=>!E@!AJ>6!FB!E!AJB?BKPJ!ZB5!BC!MD>E;<;P!KN:!5KA!@!AJEA!AJ>!?>MB=>?6! N?BM>@@!<@!E!DE5B?:!AJEA!?>OK@!P>AA<;P!6BK?!JE;F@!F! <;=BD=>F!<;!AJ>!?>MB=>?6!N?BM>@@!<@!E?PKE5D6!LB?>!JB;>@A!AJE;!&5ELE\@!BAJ>?!@N>>MJ>@!<;! ?>@NB;@>!AB!,K?B?E!E;F!8B@AB;:!E@!AJ<@!@N>>MJ!N?>@>;A@!E!=<@KED!BC!XJEA!?>MB=>?6!EMAKEDD6! DBBT@!D/!N5?<@9! +J<@!K@>!BC!AJ>!XB?F!fF>5?< @g!ED@B!>=BT>@!@!BC!F<@E??E6!E;F!F>@A?KMA! @J>>?!@A?>;PAJ!E;F!CB?M>!BC!AJ>!@AB?L!?>@KDA>F!<;!ND>;A6!BC!=<@KED!>=;M>!BC!FELEP>9! $@!E!=<@KED!NB?A?E6ED!BC!AJ>!F>NAJ!E;F!P?E=!=;M>!<;!

PAGE 94

ba AJ>!,K?B?E!@JBBA<; P!56!NDEM<;P!AXB!C<;P>?@!B;!J<@!;>MT!AB!@JBX!,DD<>\@!PK;@JBA!XBK;F:!AJ>! K@>!BC!AJ>!XB?F!F>5?<@!EDDBX@!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!AB!N!@!BC!A?E@J:!FELEP>F!N?BN>?A6:! E;F!AJ>!?>LE<;@!BC!XJEA!@ABBF!5>CB?>!AJ>!@AB?L!J@!AJ>!?>ED! F>=E @AEA!NBX>?CKD!E;F!LB?>!5>D<>=E5D>:!E@!EKF<>;M>@!E?>!E5D>!AB!f@>>g!AJ>!A?EP>F6! AB!@BL>!>YA>;A9!&;!AJ>!BAJ>?!JE;F:!AJ<@!?>FKM>@!AJ>!!A?EP>F6!AB!XJEA!ME;! @!@>>;:!@A?KMA:!B?!;BA!>E@F!<;AB! L>;AED!@9 86!PB<;P!AJ?BKPJ!E!DEK;F?6!D<@A!BC!AJ>!F?>;A!XE6@!N>BND>!NKA!AJ>;PAJ@!AB!K@>!FK?<;P!AJ>!?>MB=>?6!>CCB?A:!AJ>!A>YA!EAA>LNA@!AB!>;MBK?EP>!,L>?!ABP>AJ>?!E;F!P<=>!5EMT!<;!@!XE6@!MB??>@NB;F! X@9!4B?!>YELND>:! XJ>;!&5ELE!L>;A@AEK?E;A!BX;>?!XJB:!CB?!AJ>!DE@A!Ib!JBK?@:!JEF!5>>;!MBBT<;P! L>ED@:!ZK@A!E@!J<@!MB;A?< 5KA!?>MB=>?6!N?BM>@@:g!J>!<@!E5D>!AB!JMYELND>!BC!E!?>ED!,L>?!MBLLK;!XE6!J>!T;BX@!JBX9!+J>! @N>>MJ!@N>M@!BKA!BC!!AJEA!AJ>!LE;!JEF!5>>;!XB?T<;P!CB?!Ib!JBK?@:! F>LB;@A?EA<;P!J<@!MBLL;A!AB!AJ>!MEK@>!E;F!J<@!X@@!AB!J>DN!XJ>;!;>>F>F9! +J>! CEMA!AJEA!AJ<@!>YELND>!NB<;A@!BKA!E ?>@AEK?E;A!BX;>?!MBBT<;P!L>ED@!LET>@!AJ>!;BAMB=>?6!>CCB?A@!LB?>!EMM>@@<5D>!AB!AJ>!,L>?BND>9!,CA>?!EDD:!AJ>! ?>@AEK?E;A!BX;>?!<@!FB<;P!XJEA!J>!N?>@KLE5D6!FB>@!5>@A/!MBBT<;P9!)A!<@!EA!AJ<@!NB<;A:! N>?M>NA<5D6!E!@EC>!NB<;A!<;!AJ >!;E??EA<=>!@<;M>!:!XJ>?>!&5ELE!C>>D@!MBLCB?AE5D>! K@<;P!JKLB?9!+J>!ZBT>!<@!?>DEA<=>D6!JE?LD>@@:!5KA!&5ELE!PB>@!BKA!BC!J<@!XE6!AB!A?6!E;F!LET>! N>BND>!DEKPJ!56!@E6<;P!AJEA Q @BL>!BC!AJ>!CBDT@!X>?>!@E6<;P!AJ>!CBBF!XE@!5>AA>?!AJE;!AJ>6! PBA!EA!JBL>9 g!+J>!@N>>MJ!AK?;@!XJEA!XBKDF!@>>L!D!E!J>E?A5?>ET<;P!!<;AB!E!

PAGE 95

bb JKLB?BK@!B;>:!<;F!BC!AJ>!<;@NA!DE?A>F!;EAK?>!BC!AJ<@!NE?A=>;!<;!AJ>!LYELND>:!&5ELE!CK?AJ>?!EAA>LNA@!AB!J

!EDA?K<@L!BC!6BK;P! N>BND>!<;!AJ>!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!$KN>?@AB?L!$E;F69!&5ELE!?>C>?>;M>@!AJ>!f I_ ^ 6>E? ^ BDF!6BK;P! LE;!XJB@>!LBAJ>?!XE@!F<@E5D>F:!E;F!J>!XE@!LET<;P!@K?>!AJEA!@J>!XE@!BTE6:!E;F!AET<;P!B;! >YA?EB?F<;E?6!?>@NB;@<5@!C B?!JDC!5KA!ED@B!CB? J<@!LBL9g!1J>;!ZKYAENB@>F!X! N?>=YELND>@:!AJ>!@AB?6!BC!AJ<@!I_ ^ 6>E? ^ BDF!FB>@;\A!@>>L!AB!5>!B;!AJ>!@EL>!NE?9! 3B;@?<;P!AJEA!AJ>!BAJ>?!AXB!>YELND>@!5BAJ!<;=BD=>!B=>?A!F<@NDE6@!BC!MBLL;A!AB!AJ>! X>DD5><;P!BC!AJ>!MBLLK;?!AJ?BKPJ!NED@:!AJ<@! NE?AYELND>!<@!ZK@A!E!5B6!J>DN<;P!J<@!LBL9!+JBKPJ!K;K@KED!XJ>;!MBLNE?>F!AB!AJ>! N?>=YELND>@:!AJ<@!@>>L@!NK?NB@>CKD i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

PAGE 96

bU ;E??EA<=>@:!XJEA!<@!LB?>!N?B5D>LEA!XE6!AJ>@>!E;>MFBA>@!5>MBL>!@KNNB?A<;P! >=;M>!AJEA!EDDBX!AJ>!A>YA!AB!?><;CB?M>!MD!MBK;A?6!E@!E!XJB D>9 86!K@<;P!AJ>!N?>=MFBA>@!E@!>=;M>!CB?!E;!E@@>@@L>;A!BC!AJ>!;EA?:!AJ>!A>YA!K@>@!AJ>!L>AENJB?!fX>!5BK;M>!5EMTg!AB!NB?A?E6!J>ED<;P!E@!E;!<;>=! NK?@K>L<;PD6!NKA@!AJ<@!L>@@EP>!EA!BFF@!X!;BA?!AB ?>MB=>?! E@!E!MBLLK;BND>!LK@A!FB!AJ>!E;>MFBA>@!BC!AJB@>! XJB\=>!FB;>!P?>EA!AJ<;P@!<;!AJ>!L?@AB?L!$E;F6!X@@L>;A!BC!AJ>! ;EA?/ ,;F!XJ>;!6BK!@>>!CBDT@!D!AJEA!?>@NB;F!X;PAJ!E;F!? >@;M>:!XJ>;!6BK!@>>! ;>DN<;P!;>;!6BK\?>!?>L<;F>F!E5BKA!XJEA!,L>?!PB!AJ?BKPJ!ABKPJ!A@:!5KA!X>!5BK;M>!5EMT9!,;F!AJ>!?>E@B;!X>!5BK;M>!5EMT!<@! 5>MEK@>!X>!DBBT!BKA!CB?!B;>!E;BAJ>?!E;F!X>!FB;\A!D>E=>!E;65BF6!5>J<;F 9 ! 1J>;!&5ELE!@E6@!AJEA:!f1>!PB!AJ?BKPJ!ABKPJ!A@:!5KA!X>!5BK;M>!5EMT9!,;F!AJ>! ?>E@B;!X>!5BK;M>!5EMT!<@!5>MEK@>!X>!DBBT!BKA!CB?!B;>!E;BAJ>?!E;F!X>!FB;\A!D>E=>!E;65BF6! 5>J<;F:g!J>!<@!;BA!B;D6!A>DD<;P!,L>?ED:!5KA J>!<@ ED@B!@>AA<;P!K ;?>ED<@A YN>MAEAED<;P!ME;!DBBT!D9!#EMJ!BC!AJ>!N>BND>!?>C>??>F!AB!<;!AJ>!N?>M>F<;P! E;>MFBA>@!E?>!AJB@>!XJB!>Y>LNDE;@ AB!fDBBT!BKA!CB?!B;>!E;BAJ>?9g! -DAD6:!AJ>!>YELND>@!BC!AJ>!MBLLK;AJ>?!<;!AJ>!CEM>!BC!@KMJ!E! F >=E@AEA<;P!@AB?L!E?>!EF!AB!@JBX!,L>?!!BC!DBBT<;P!BKA!CB?!>EMJ! BAJ>?!E;F!;BA!fD>E=<;P!E;65BF6!5>J<;F9g!8KA!LB?>!!A>YA!@!E!MEK@>! E;F!>CC>MA!?>DEAAX>>;!AJ>!B5@>?=EA?EMJ!BKA!AB!>E MJ!BAJ>?! E;F!AJ>?>;A!XE6@!E;F!AJ>!MBK;A?6\@!E5!5EMT9g!+J<@! ?>DEA!f5BK;M>!5EMTg!L>AENJB?:!N?>@>;A@!J>ED<;P!E@!E!DBP@KDA!BC!,L>?AJ>?:!PDB@@<;P!B=>?!AJ>!BAJ>?!NBA>;A< ED!?>ED@!BC!JBX!

PAGE 97

UH J>ED<;P!BMMK?@9!)A!LET>@!J>ED<;P!@>>L!<;>=:!E@!AJBKPJ!?>!KN!AB!AJ>!CB?M>@!BC! P?E=AENJB?!NB@ED<;P!E@!E!;EAK?ED!>=>;A:!PDB@@<;P!B=>?!AJ>!>CCB?A:!A:! E;F!>LBA@!<;=BD=>F9!86!K@<;P!AJ>@>!N >?@B;ED!E;>MFBA>@!E@!>=;M>:!AJ>!A>YA! @>;F@!AJ>!L>@@EP>!AJEA!?!X!ME?>!BC!BAJ>?!,L>?!X! E5D>!AB!5BK;M>!5EMT9!$KMJ!E;!E@@>?AE?D6!;>PD>MA@!AJ>!D>=>D!BC!?>5K!ELBK;A! BC!LB;>6:!E;F!AJ>!EFFM>@@E?6!<;!B?F>?!AB!5BK;M>!5EMT:!XJ@@>;A!=<>X>F!E@!NEA?B;<[<;P!AB!J<@!EKF<>;M>9!)C!DBBT<;P!BKA!CB?!BAJ>?@!<@!EDD!@!AB!5BK;M>! 5EMT:!AJ>;!?>MB=>?6!<@!@K?>D6!EAAE<;E5D>9!+JBKPJ!f5BK;M>!5EMTg!<@!=EPK>!>;BKPJ!AB!LET>!;B! N?BL<@>@!E5B KA!XJEA!AJEA!?>MB=>?6!L:!AJ>!NJ?E@>!DC!@KPP>@A@!AJEA!J>ED<;P!<@! >E@:!B?!?EAJ>?:!>E@<>?!AJE;!B;>!LYN>MA9!'BA!B;D6!<@!AJ<@!@NB;@<5D>!<;! AJ>!@>;@>!AJEA!NE?AP?>!J?!56!$E;F6!AJE;!BAJ>?@:!5KA!PD>MACKD!BC!AJ>!A6N>@!BC!A?EKLE@!AJEA!N>BND>!>YN>?<>;M>F!E@!E!?>@KDA!BC!AJ<@!@AB?L9!8>MEK@>! DB@@!DD6!ABBT!LE;6!CB?L@!<;!AJ>!ECA>?LEAJ!BC!$E;F6:!XJ>AJ>?!F!B;>:! JBL>:!5K@<;>@@:!B?!;>!=E?6<;P!NEAJ@!ABXE?F!J>ED<;P E?>!KDAD6!5D>;F>F! <;AB!B;>:!XJ?@@!@KMJ!E!LKDAA>F:!MBLND>Y!A?EP>F69 !

PAGE 98

UI %C?8:9>= G :B'&:HF?8>7J'-R>J?7=>?G );!L6!A>YA@!CB?!E;ED6@<@:!>EMJ!@N>>MJ!N?@NB;F@!AB!E!@<;PD>! LEZB? M?<@<@:!5KA! XJEA!AJ<@!@>MA @!B;!<@!AJ>!BAJ>?!MBLN>A<;P!>Y

;M<>@!EA!JE;F:!AJ>! LB@A!;BAE5D>!>YELND>!5><;P!AJ>!GHIG!N?>@;AMEK@> *?AA:! ,DD<@B;:!E;F!$ >>P>?\@!E;ED6@>@!EDD!B=>?DBBT AJ>!NBA>;AY

;M<>@!AB! 5>!MBLN>A<;P!X!E; BAJ>?!<;!A>?L@!BC!F>MAB?\@!ENN?BEMJ!CB?!5BD@A>?<;P! !B?!M?>EA<;P!E!L B?>!EKF<>;M> ^ M>;A>?>F!F<@MBK?@>:!AJ<@!@>MA@ B; JBX!AJ>@>! MBLN>A<;P!>Y

;M<>@!@NB;@>!AB!,K?B?E AJ>!A>YA!56!>YEL<;<;P!AJ>! XE6! J>! ;>PBA@! 5>AX>>;!=E?@>;A!E;F!;B; ^ N?>@>;A!EKF<>;M>@!CB?!J<@!@N>>MJ>@9 86! CE=B?<;P!AJ>!N?>@>;A!EKF<>;M>!BC!J<@!NBD?@ E;F!NDEM<;P!AJ>!MELNE! AJ>!>Y

;M>!BC!AJ>!@JBBA<;P :!&5ELE!CK?AJ>?!L E?P<;ED<[>@!@K?=<=B?@!BC!A?EKLE@!E;F!@>;F@! AJ>!L>@@ EP>!AJEA!NBD!!M?<@<@!EA!JE;F9 +B!@JBX! AJ<@:!)! X!EKF<>;M>!<;A>??KNAEF<;P!KN!AB!AJ>!<;A>??KNA!?>@NB;F@!AB!AJ>!<;A>??KNA!GHIG!>D>MA;M>@!&5ELE\@!?>@NB;@ >!AB!A?EP>F6!56!CB?M<;P!J!5BAJ! AJ>!EKF<>;M>\@!;>>F@!E;F!J<@!B5DAJB@!<;!B?F>?!AB!LE<;AE<;!AJ>!BCC!BC! AJ>!%?>@;A:!XJ@N>M;A!<;!J<@!MELNE>MJ!<;!4DB?MBL>@!E! ?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!,K?B?E!AJ>EA >?!@JBBA<;P9!8>MEK@>!AJ<@!@N>>MJ!XE@!@MJ>FKD>F!AJ>!LB?;<;P! BC!AJ>!@JBBA<;P:!KDAD6:!AJ>!>Y

;M6!BC!AJ>!@JBBA<;P!5>MEL>!ABB!K?P>;A!E;F!ABB! @JBMT<;P!AB!:!E;F!&5ELE!?>NK?NB@>F!AJ>!BMME@@NB;F!AB!AJ>!A?EP>F69! 3B;@>OK>;AD6:!AJ<@!@N>>MJ!<@!K;D !E;6!BC!AJ>!BAJ>?!A>YA@!)!E;ED6[>:!5KA!N?>@>;A@!E;!

PAGE 99

UG <;A>?>@A<;P!MB;CDLB;@A?EA>@!AJ>!TE;M>!BC!AJ>!GHIG!N?>@;A@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!,K?B?E!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P9! &5ELE\@!MBLNDF!<;A>?EMA!EKF<> ;M>!?>CD>MA!E!A>;@AX>>;!AJ>! B?;A!@N>>MJ!E;F!;!@J:!XJD6!NB@!5B<@A>?BK@!MELNE=>;A!EA!BFF@!X!LKMJ!LB?>!@BD>L;!?>@NB;@>!AB!AJ>!,K?B?E! AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P9!8>CB?>!&5ELE!>=>;!5>P<;@ @N>ET<;P:!J>!<@!P?>>A>F!X;AJK@:!XJ@!<;!@N
!BC!J<@!>CCB?A@!AB!JK@J!AJ>!EKF<>;M>9!+J?BKPJBKA!AJ>! @N>>MJ:!L>L5>?@!BC!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!F>LB;@A?EA>!E!X@@!AB!<;A>??KNA!AJ>!N?>@;A!X>?<;P!E;F!@JBKA<;P:!@>>L<;PD6!K;E XE?>!BC!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!AJ>!EALB@NJ>?>!BC!AJ>!@N>>MJ! JE@!MJE;P>F!F?ELEA?>!E?>!U!T>6!LBL>;A@!XJ>?>!AJ<@!JENN>;@!<;!AJ>!@N>>MJ9!+J>! AE5D>!5>DBX!>YNDE<;@!XJ>;!AJ>@>!<;A>??KNAJEDC!BC!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!BMMK?!<;!AJ>! @N>>MJ:!JBX!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!<;A>??K NA@!AJ>!@N>>MJ:!E;F!JBX!&5ELE!?>@NB;F@!AB!AJ>! <;A>??KNA>?<;Ph!fX>!DB=>!6BK:! &5ELEtg 1E=>@h!@E6@!fAJE;T!6BK! >=>?65BF6:g!DDBX!AJ>! @JBKDF>?:!NEDL@!CEM<;P! FBX; h!@AKAA>?@ I/d_ ^ I/da ,KF<>;M>!L>L5>?!@JBKA@! f6E6tg )P;B?>@ I/__ ^ I/_b f6E6tgh!@JBKA<;Ph!ENNDEK@> 2?h!@AKAA>?@h!?E<@>@!J<@! =B G/IU ^ G/GI );EKF<5D>!@JBKA<;P +K?;@!J<@!J>EF!AB!AJ>!D>CA! E;F!?E<@>@!B;>!JE;F!VNEDL! BKAW!AB!AJ>!D>CA!A BXE?F!AJ>! FMA!;B<@>!J>EF! AB!J<@!D>CA

PAGE 100

Ud ! 1!CX!L<;KA>@:!&5ELE!<@!<;A>??KNA>F!B;!LKDA!BMME@A!AJ>!A>YA!A?>EA@! AJ>L!E@!BKA5K?@A@!AJEA!LK@A!5>!OK>DD>F9 &5ELE!P>@A@!<;!E;!>CCB?A!AB!>D! EKF<>;M>\@!@;M>!E;F!MBBN>?EA;AKEDD6:!AJ>!A>YA!MBL>@!AB!A>?L@!X! <;A>??KNAEF!BC!C@!E;F!EDDBX@!AJ>!EKF<>;M>\@!?>EMA:!LKMJ!D!<;!E!A6N>MJ9!)A\@!>=;A!AJEA:!EA!C! X!;BABND>!MJ>>?<;P!CB?!J>MJ!AJEA!E@NB;F!AB!E! A?EKLEA=>;A:!5KA!@BB;:!J>!CEDD@!5EMT!<;AB!AJ>!NEAA>?;@!BC!E!A6N>MJ:!XB?T<;P!X!M?BXF\@!>;>?P 69!+J>!K;K@KED!;EAK?>!BC!AJ>!@LB;@A?EA>@!AJEA!&5ELE!E@!E! ?J>AB?!<@!E5D>!AB!EFENA!AB!AJ>!EKF<>;M>\@!;>>F@9!-DAD6:!AJ>!EKF<>;M>!MEL>!AB!AJ>!>=>;A! >YN>MA<;P!E!MELNE?!E!C>X!L<;KA>@!BC!?>@<@AE;M>:!<;!E;!>CCB?A!AB! ?>C? EL>!AJ>!>=>;A!E@!E!?>@NB;@>!AB!A?EP>F6:!&5ELE!P<=>@!<;!E;F!EMMBLLBFEA>@!AJ>!M?BXF9! 0>!EDDBX@!AJ>L!AB!MJ>>?:!@JBKA:!E;F!ENNDEKF:!<;!@N
!BC!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!>L@!BFFD6! <;ENN?BN?!CB?!@KMJ!E!@BD>L;!BMME@!B?;A!BC!AJ >! @N>>MJ!VE@!E!MELNE=>;AW!E;F!AJ>!?>=<@>F!NK?NB@>!BC!AJ>!@N>>MJ!VE@!E!?>@NB;@>!AB!M?<@<@W! d/Gb ^ d/d_ ,NNDEK@>h!MJ>>?<;P %EK@>@ _/Ha ^ _/HU fe>EJhg!=ED>L>;A )P;B?>@ _/G_ ^ _/d` 3J>>?<;Ph!ENNDEK@> %EK@>@ `/_b ^ a/II f1>!DB=>!6BK!&5ELEt! ,NNDEK@>g %EK@>@h!?>N>EA@!f@Bgh! ?E<@>@!J<@!=B a/ db ^ b/HI $;M>h!5E56!M?6<;Ph! NJBABP?ENJ>?!@;EN@h! 5BX>F!J>EF@h!MDB@>F!>6>@h! AJ>!$!3?B@@ 8BX@!J>EFh!MDB@>@!>6>@

PAGE 101

UQ EA!BFF@:!LB;@A?EA>!E!M>?AE<;!F>P?>>!BC!?J>AB?@@:!E@!J>! ;E=@!5>AX>>;!MBLN>A<;P!>Y

;M<>@!XJ!B5D!EKF<>;M>9! DA>?;EA<=>D6:!56!5>MBL<;P!LB?>!MBLCB?AE5D>!X!EKF<>;M>\@!<;A>??KNA! A>YA!CE=B?@!AJ>!;>>F@!BC!AJ>!N?>@>;A!EKF<>;M>!E@!BNNB@>F!AB!AJB@>!BC!AJ>!E5@>;A!EKF<>;M>@:! <;MDKF<;P!AJB@>!XJB!E?>!MB;;>MA>F!AB!AJ>!A?EP>F6!<;!@BL>!XE69!+B!E!CK?AJ>?!>YA>;A:! @KMJ!E! MJB!<;F@!AJEA!AJ>!A>YA!<@!KDAD6!@EM?!;>>F@!BC!AJB@>!XJB!@K?=<=>F!AJ>! @JBBA<;P!<;!B?F>?!AB!NEM!;>>F@!BC!E;!EKF<>;M>!N?>@KLE5D6!C

F!X?@:! MB;@?<;P!AJ>6!EAA>;F>F!AJ>!@N>>MJ!X!K;F>?@AE;F<;P!AJEA!!E!MELNE=>;A9!+J<@!KDAD6!@KPP>@A@!AJEA!X!MB;A>YA!BC!AJ<@!@N>>MJ:!AJ>!GHIG!N?>@;A!LB?>!Y

;M6!XJ>;!ZKYAENB@>F!X!>Y

;M6!BC!AJ>! ,K?B?E!AJ>EA>?!@JBBA<;P9 +J>!@N>>MJ!EA!AJ>!-;<=>?@!AB!ME?>CKDD6!MB;A>YAKED<[>! AJ>!@JBBA<;P!X!DE?P>?!NBD!BC!PK;!MB;A?BD!XMC>?>;M<;P!E! NBDLB;@A?EA>@!E;!EXE?>;>@@!BC!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!&5ELE\@!NBD;A@!E?>!D<@A>;<;P!M E?>CKDD6!AB!J<@!@N>>MJ:!<;!@N!BC!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!AJ<@!<@!;BA!;>M>@@E?;F>F!EKF<>;M>9!3B;@?<;P!AJ>!CEMA!AJEA!AJ<@!@N>>MJ!< @!P<=>;!D>@@!AJE;!CBK? LB;AJ@! 5>CB?>!AJ>!GHIG!>D>MA;>@@!BC!AJ<@!EKF<>;M>!<@!>=;A!AJ?BKPJ!AJ>!MEDD!AB!EMA !NB@!>;F!BC!AJ>!@N>>MJ!XJ>;!J>!@E6@/! )!JBN>!AJEA!B=>?!AJ>!;>YA!@>=>?ED!FE6@:!;>YA!@>=>?ED!X>>T@:!AJ>!;>YA!@>=>?ED!LB;AJ@:!X>! EDD!?>CD>MA!B;!JBX!X>!ME;!FB!@BL>AJ<;P!E5BKA!@BL>!BC!AJ>!@>;@>D>@@!=;M>!AJEA!>;F@! KN!LE??<;P!AJ<@!MBK;A?6:! 5KA!ED@B!?>CD>MA!B;!EDD!AJ>!XB;F>?CKD!N>BND>!XJB!LET>!AJ<@!AJ>! P?>EA>@A!MBK;A?6!B;!>E?AJ9 ! 0>?>:!AJ>!A>YA!<@!NE=<;P!AJ>!XE6!ABXE?F!E!NBA>;A5EA>!B=>?!XJEA!ME;!5>!FB;>!AB! N?>=>;A!LE@@!@JBBA<;P@!56!>;MBK?EP<;P!,L>?;A!

PAGE 102

U_ f@>;@>D>@@!=;M>!AJEA!>;F@!KN!LE??<;P!AJ<@!MBK;A?69g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

PAGE 103

U` 4K?AJ>?LB?>:!AJ>!@N>>MJ!<@!E5D>!AB!!E!;>>F!CB?!L>E;<;PCKD!MJE;P>!E;F! EMA!ED@B!F>LB;@A?EA<;P!E!X@@!AB!MB;@?!EDD!NBA>;AD6:! ,L>?!D>CA!X!@@F!AB!?>5K!CEM>!BC! AJ<@!A?EP>F6!E;F!AJEA!J>!@>>@!AJ<@!N?BM>@@!E@!E!MBDD>MA<=>!>CCB?A:!B;>!XJOK@!AJ>! MBLL;A!E;F!??!AB!>CC>MA!L>E;<;PCKD!MJE;P>9 !

PAGE 104

Ua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f1J6!<@!"K@@!=F!OK>@A!)!XE@!;BA!N?>NE?>F!AB!E;@X>?9!)!CKL5D>F!AJ?BKPJ!E! 5?BEF!>YNDE;EA;@>!?>DEAAX>>;!AJ>!AXB MBK;A?<>@ :!5KA!FEDD6!C>>D! MBLCB?AE5D>!>YNDE<;<;P!AJ>!=E@A!!3BDF!1E?!E;F!JBX!AJE A!J>DN>F!@BD?9!+ J<@!XE@!J>?! MKDAK?>:!J>?!J<@AB?6:!J>?!NE@A:!5KA @J>!MBKDF;\A!K;F>?@AE;F!AJ<@!@A?E;P>!N?>@KNNB@F!@B!LE;6!NBD?@EAM;A!.6!J EF!LEF>! E5BKA!"K@@<;P!E!AJ?>EA! AB!AJ>!-9$9! );!AJ>!@EL>!XE6!AJEA!L6!@AKF>;A@!5>PE;!E@T<;P!OK>@A!K;F>?D6<;P! E@@KLNA!NBD:!)!C<;F!L6@>DC!XE;A<;P!@AKF>;A@!AB!M?=EDKEA> AJ>!N?>@KNNB@YA@!AJEA!?>@NB;F!AB!A?EP>F6 i A>YA@!AJEA!@>>L!AB! 5>!!AB!@KMJ!E;ED6@<@!5>MEK@>!BC!AJ>>L<;PD6!F9 !

PAGE 105

Ub );!AJ<@!E;ED6@<@:! )! EF!AB!>LNJE@<[>!AJ>!!BC!M?;PEP<;P!XYA@:!XJ BCA>; ;BA!@K5Z>MA!AB!AJ>!M?!AJ>6!;>>F 9!-;D!E!$AEA>!BC!AJ>!-;@@:!@N>>MJ>@!<;!?>@NB;@>!AB!A?EKLE!E?>!;BA!BCA>;!N>?M><=>F!E@!<@@K>@!BC!NBD?!B5D@NB;@>@!AB!>=>;A@! AJEA!MEDD!BKA!CB?!E!?>EMA=>?:!?!AJEA!AJ>@>!E FF?>@@>@!@>A!E!AB;>/ AJ>6!<;=
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

PAGE 106

UU AJ>YN>?<>;M>@9!)!XE;A!AJ>L!AB!5>!X?@AE;F! AJ>!=EDK>!BC!>LNEAJ6!<;!@!AJ<@9!)!XE;A!AJ>L!AB!X?
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fMB;AEMA![B;>@:g!E@! E?PK>F!56!(ENJ;>!">EF: AJ>6!@>?=>!E@!NDEM>@!XJ>?>!BDBP<>@!MDE@J!E;F!XJ>?>!D>E?;<;P!ME;! AET>!NDEM>!E@!E!?>@KDA9! 6!@AKF>;A@ ME;!D>E?;!AB!>LNEAJ<[>!X?@!E;F!F?EX!B; AJ>YN>?<>;M>@!AB!F?ECA!5>AA>?!?>@NB;@>@ AB!AJ>!A?EP>F<>@!AJEA!AJ>6!J>E?!E5BKA!EDD!AJ>! A 9!)A!ME ;!5>!E;!BNNB?AK;L!AB!OK>@A!N?>@KNNB@!BCA>; ZK@A! E@@KL>F!<;!@KMJ!?>@NB;@>@!E;F!JBX!AJ>@>!N?>@KNNB@?!F9!4B?!>YELND>:!< C! ,L>?YM>NA@!C?@AE;F<;P!BC!XJEA!BK ?! MBK;A?6!@AE;F@!CB?o!,;F!XJEA!X>! E@!<;F<=!8B??BXLE;\@! E;AJBDBP6!>YNDB?>@:!;EA!E!AE;PD>F!X>5!BC!F<=>?@>!?>@NB;@>@!E;F! ?>EMA!MDE@@?BBL!@>?=>@!E@!E!LMBL>!J>EA>F:!E;F!MBLNB@
PAGE 107

IHH F<@@>;A9!+JBKPJ!@KMJ!MB;=>?@EA!F?EA>:!AJ>6!N?>@>;A!E;! BNNB?AK;EMJ>?@!AB!;BA!B;D6! N?>NE?>!@AKF>;A@!AB!5>!5>AA>?!M ;@!E;F! NE?ALBM?EM6:!5KA! AB ED@B!@JBX!AJ>L!JBX!AJ>6!ME;!LET>!@A?@!<;!M?>EA<;P! NBD AJEA! 5>AA>? ?>CD>MA @!AJ>;A@!E;F!EAA>;F@!AB AJ>>F@!E;F! PBED@9! ! ! ' ' ' ' ' '

PAGE 108

IHI "4",4*/%!32M ,D=<:!$BC>?9!f,;!,;ED6@<@!BC!8E?EMT!&5ELE\@!$N>>MJ!n7>6;BA>! ,FF?>@@!EA!AJ>!GHHQ!(>LBM?EA;A?@B;:!3JE?D>@!.:!E;F!.E?EMJ>?@!BC!#;PD<@J:!GHHH9!%?<;A9 ! ,?;>AA:!"B;EDF!39!f3<=AB?>A<;P!AJ>!3BLLK;ED!);A>?NDE6!BC!AJ>!%?B=<;M!3B@LBNBD!(EL>!$N>>MJ:!.E6!Ia:!GHHU9g! E>&!")'$#S# :+;%'$#;B&")9#"B#K,*A&#E&8!")*!'".# =!)*!&A'&8 9!,D5E;6/!$AEA>!-;<=>?@X!eB?T!%?>@@:!IUU_9!%?<;A 9 ! 8>?P>?:!]EL>@9!f+?EKLE!19g! T"+).*%#"B#?TBX!)?B;?B!BC!SMJ/!0>ED<;P!+?EKLE!+J?BKPJ!.6AJ!E;F!3BDD>MA<=>!.>LB?69g! T"+).*%'8, II9`!VGHIHW/!`Qd ^ `_U9!%(49 ! 8>?TBXX@!E;F!,F=>?A<@<;P!3B ;A>;A ^^ $K!8BL5>?@!E@!1BL>;!1E??X@!AJ?BKPJ!.6AJA6N>@9g! T"+).*%'8,#* ./#?*88#@",,+.'$*!'".# U+*)!&)%9 # bG9d!VGHH_W/ `Ha ^ `IU 9!%(49 8>?TBX!)?B;?B!BC!SMJ/!0>ED<;P!+?EKLE!+J?BKPJ!.6AJ!E;F!3BD D>MA<=>!.>LB?69g! T"+).*%'8, II9`!VGHIHW/!`Qd ^ `_U9!%(49 ! 8>?;E?F ^ (B;ED@:!.D9!f+J>!"J>AB??!E;F!AJ>!)LN>?EA<=>!BC!1?&!")'$# ="$'&!9#U+*)!&)%9 dI9I!VGHHIW/!ad ^ UQ9!%(49 ! 8>?;E?F ^ (B;ED@:!.D : E;F!"Z[>?9 C'!.&88'.A # !>& # D'8*8!&)3#088*98#". # E&2)&8&.!*!'".#*./#!>"%"$*+8!R# .EF<@B;/ # -;<=> ?@@@:!GHHd9! %?<;A9 ! 8?:!2DB6F!49!u+J>!"J>AB?'%"8"2>9#S#E>&!")'$ G_!VIUUGW/!I ^ IQ9! %(49 ! 8B??BXLE;:!$JE;>9! 4)*+,*#*./#!>&*$>'.A#"B#C)'!'.AR ,D5E ;6:!'e/!$AEA>!-;<=>?@X!eB?T!%?>@@:!GHH_9!%?<;A9 ! 3E?KAJ:!3EAJ69! 4)*+,*3#012%")*!'".8#'.#?&,")9R 8EDA:!.(/!]BJ;@!0BNT<;@!-;<=>?@@@:!IUU_9!%?<;A9 !

PAGE 109

IHG 3E?KAJ:!3EAJ69! -.$%*',&/#012&)'&.$&3#4)*+,*5#6*))*!'(&5#*./#7'8!")9R 8EDA:!.(/!]BJ;@! 0BNT<;@!-;<=>?@@@:!IUU`9!%?<;A9 ! 3JB<:!$KJ<9!f3BLLK;LED>!$K?=<=B?@\!1@@<;P!AJ>!'B!*K;!"?>L6!29!f%BD!BC!.B=>L>;A!.>AENJB?@9g! < ,&)'$*.#@",,+.'$*!'".#T"+).*% IQ9G!VGHIGW/!I ^ Id9!%(49 ! 3?!"J>AB?D?<>;M>9g! T"+).*%#"B# @",,+.'$*!'".#S#E&%'A'".# d_ 9I!VGHIGW/!d_ ^ QU9!%(49 ! (E;<@MJ:!"B5>?A9!f+J>!"BBA@!E;F!4B?L!BC!&5ELE\@!"J>AB?&!")'$#E&('&F dI9G!VGHIGW/!IQb ^ I`b9!%(49 ! (>%EDLE:!.D ^ ]BJ;:!]>CC?>6!.9!"<;P>?:!E;F!]55>?9!fV">W3JE?A<;P!AJ>!V(<@W3BK?@>@! BC!4EAB?LBM?EM6!<;!AJ>!8K?T>E;!8E?;6E?F9g! E>&!")'$# ="$'&!9#U+*)!&)%9# db9d!VGHHbW/!dII ^ ddQ9! ! (:!$K@E;;E9!f"EM>!"J>AB?@;A/!-;NEMT<;P!AJ>!$!BC! 8E?EMT!&5ELE\@!n,!.B?>!%>?C>MA!-;>MJ9g! E>&!")'$#S#:+;%'$#!]9!f+J>!4K;MAD<5>?E A<=>!$A?EA>P<>@!<;!%?>@;AAB?#@",,+.'$*!'". _d9d!VIUbUW/!GUQ ^ dIH9!%(49 ! (?KMTLE;:!]EL>@!'9 : E;F! ]K@A<;!19!0BDL>@9!f(B>@!%?>@;AAB??o!%?@;A?:!(>=<;9!f%DE;;>F!%E?>;AJBBF!EA!3>;A>?!BC!8KFP>A!$JKAFBX;!+J?>EA9g! X@!);A>?;>A!S>;AK?>@:!b!,N?59!I!.E6!GHIQ9 # #FT<;@:!]>;;69! 4)*+,*#*./#!>&#?&,")9#"B#:"%'!'$8R '>X!eB?T/!3EL5?!-;<=>?@
@@:! GHHd9!%?<;A9 ! #DD!$MJX;EA>!3E;F!%?B=BT>@!)?>!1P!"EN>\! 3BLL>;A9g! 4>&F#W")O#4',&8R +J>!'>X!eB?T!+@!3BLNE;6:!IU!,KP9!GHIG9!1>59! I!.E6!GHIQ9 ! 4?E;T:!(E=AB?/!3B@LBN BDD! %?>@;A@@:!]E;KE?6!GH:!GHHU9g! E>&!")'$#S#:+;%'$#
PAGE 110

IHd 4?E;T:!(E=;M>9!f8E?EMT!&5ELE\@!,FF?>@@!AB!AJ>!GHHQ!(>LBM?EA;A :!3B;@;M>:!E;F!AJ>!V)LWNB@@<5MB;M&!")'$#*./#:+;%'$#AA:!(B;6ED>:!E;F!(B;;>A?!,DD<@B;9!f.ET<;P!E!3E@>!CB?!">@AB?EA<=>!"J>AB?@NB;@>!AB!(<@E@A>?9g! @",,+.'$*!'".# ?"."A)*2>8 # aa9d!VGHIHW/!da` ^ dUG9!%(49 ! ]BJ;@B;:!,;F?>!#9!f,=BD!"J>AB?BDBP6!BC!&5ELE\@!GHIG! 'EA?!8?>ETCE@A!,FF?>@@9g! T"+).*%#"B#@".!&,2")*)9#E>&!")'$ G9G!VGHIGW/! QQ ^ _d9!%(49 ! 7E?FA!ED 9!f(<@MK@@<;P!AJ>!-;CEAJBLE5D>/!3DE@@?BBL ^ 8E@>F!">@NB;@>@!AB! +?EP>F69g! @>*.A& dQ9I!VGHHGW/!Ib ^ GG9!%(49! ! 7>;;>F6:!"B5>?A!1EF>9!f+J>!%J>;BL>;BDBP6!BC!(<@E@A>?/!+BXE?F!E!"J>AB?F69g! :>'%"8"2>9#*./#E>&!")'$ dU9I!VGHH`W/!Ua ^ IGQ9!% (49 ! 7<>;NB<;A;>?:!.E;C?>F9!f$A?EA>PK=>?<;P!<;!AJ>!%BDAB?;:!,L69!fn)!1E@!">EF6!CB?!E!.>;F<;P\/!"J>AB?MB=>?6!<;!(BKP! %>EMBMT\@!*?<[[D6! e>E?@!E;F!1EDT<;P!)A!&CC9g! E>&!")'$#E&('&F dH9Q!VGHIIW/!QH` ^ QGG9! %(49 ! 2>E=6:!%EA?69!f,L>?NB?A<;P!BC!$MJBBD!S;M>!E;F! n%>BND>!2!-@\/!,!3BLNE?<@B;!BC!'>X@NEN>?!3B=>?EP>!BC!AJ>!3BDKL5<;>!E;F!">F! 2ET>!$MJBBD!$JBBA<;P@9g @)'!'$*%#="$'"%"A9 d_9G!VGHHUW/!Gad ^ GUG9!%(49 ! 2>E=6:!%EA?LB?6!<;!&AJ>?!%BD@/!,L>?M?>@A!*?BKN@!E@!3BLND?@!<;!UcII!%BD&#<.!' X K.!&%%&$!+*%#:)&8'/&.$93#4>&#D&$%'.&#"B#:)&8'/&.!'*%#E>&!")'$#B)",# M&")A&#C*8>'.A!".#!"#M&")A&#CR#L+8>R '>X!eB?T/!&YCB?F!-;<=>?@@@:!GHHb9! %?<;A9 ! 2<@A9! f &5ELE!$N>>MJ!B;!,?>E@!"E=EP>F!56!0K?? $E;F6 X 9 g &;D<;>! =B!MD:!I!'B=9!GHIG9!1>59!I .E6!GHIQ9! JAAN@/ccXXX96BKAK5>9MBLcXEAMJo=v;)%S$2NOIPe ! ! 2B;PET>?:!.E?T!* 9 :!E;F!]>CC?>6!1EDT>?9 E>&!" )'$*%#<.*%98'83#<#L)'&B#M+'/&#B")#C)'!&)8 9! 8B@AB;/!2B;PLE;:!GHII9!%?<;A9

PAGE 111

IHQ .EM3K?F6:!.E?&#?'./Y8#09&3#K,*A&#*./#?&,")9#'.#C)'!'.A#<;"+!#4)*+,* 9! ,LJ>?@A/!-;<=>?@AA@!%?>@@:!GHHa9!%?<;A9 ! .M3DK?>:!7>=<;9!f+J>!"J>AB??/!+J>!%?>@;A?!,FF?>@@!E@!E;! #L>?P>;A!*>;?>9g! E&%&(*.!#E>&!")'$ G!VGHIIW/!I ^ I_9!%(49 .

?:!'E;M6!79!u+J>!*!%JBABP?ENJ/!AJ>!S<>A;EL!1E?!E;F!AJ>!.ET<;P!BC!'EALB?69u T"+).*%#"B#&!")'$*%#4>&")9# *./#@",2"8'!'".#:&/*A"A9R '>X!eB?T/!.>DD>;!% ?>@@:!GHIH9!%?<;A9 ! '>XMBL5:!.EAAJ>X!]9!f+ET<;P!,AA>;FE;M>/!,5@>;A!1?!SEDK>!BC!$KCC>?<;P9g! T"+).*%#"B#T:!0
D:!E;F!(E;!8>?TBXDD<;P!n&K?\!$AB?6!AJ?BKPJ!'>X@!BC!+>??B?<@L9g! T"+).*%' 8,#=!+/'&8# a9_!VGHH`W/!`UI ^ aHa9!%(49 ! &\3B;;>DD:!(E;<>D!39!>A!ED9! f$AE?A ^ KN!"J>AB?>MJ>@!BC!8E?EMT!&5ELE9g! T"+).*%#"B# :89$>"%'.A+'8!'$#E&8&*)$> dU9_!VGHIHW/!dUd ^ QHU9!%(49 ! %8$!'>X@0BK?9!f1EAMJ!%?>@;A!&5ELE\@!4KDD!$N>>MJ!B;!,K?B?E!+J>EA>?!$ JBBA<;P9g!&;D<;>! =B!MD:!GG!]KD6!GHIG9!1>59!I!.E6!GHIQ9 JAAN@/ccXXX96BKAK5>9MBLcXEAMJo=v`.CJ6bZ2T ^ ! ">EF:!(ENJ;>9!f1?!3DE@@V?BBLW!E@!8B?F>?DE;F9g! T"+).*%#"B# 59 ! "BXDE;F:!" B5>?A 39 : E;F! ,;P>DE!.9!]>?BL> 9!f &;!&?PE;<[EAMB;M>NAK ED<[EA&")9 IQ VGHHQW / IUI w GII9!%(49 ! $ELK>D@:!"9(9! f+J>!"J>AB?EMJ<;P!E5BKA!AJ>!0BDBMEK@A!E;F!%B@ALBF>?;! ,CC>MA!<;!E;!,F=E;M>F!3BLNB@9g! T"+).*%#"B#?:! SED>?<>9!f+>EMJE5D>!.BL>;A@!<;!%?>@;A@/!,!3BLNE?EA<=>!,;ED6@<@!BC! "B;EDF!">EPE;\@!,FF?>@@!AB!AJ>!'EA!3JEDD>;P>?!(<@E@A>?!E;F!1CC>?@B;!3D<;AB;\@!&TDEJBLE!3LB??!$>?=!,FF?>@@9g! Z>'"# @",,+.'$*!'".#T"+) .*% Qa!VGHHUW/!GI_ ^ GdI9!%(49 ! $>DD;BX:!+X!$>>P>?9!u#YNDB?<;P!AJ>!8BK;FE?<>@!BC!3?<@<@! 3BLLK;!3E@>!BC!AJ>!IUUa!">F!"<=>?!SEDD>6!4DBBF9u @",,+.'$*!'".# =!+/'&8 _G9G!VGHHIW/!I_d ^ I`a9!%(4 9

PAGE 112

IH_ $>>P>?:!.EAAJ>X:!E;F!(B;6ED>!*?AA9!f4?BL!)LEP>!">@AB?EA;>XED/! ,NN?BEMJ>@!AB!-;F>?@AE;F<;P!%B@A ^ 3?<@<@!3BLLK;?:!]9$9!u%?>@;A!&5ELE:!AJ>!8<5D>:!E;F!%BDAB?&"%"A9 I d9_! VGHIGW/!_b` ^ `H U9!%(49 ! $A>?9!f+J>!$A?>>A@!BC!2E?>FB/!.>?MK?AB?!&5ELE!3ELNE? ^ $NEM>@!BC!*?<>C/!&;D<;>!.>LB?!3BDKL5<;>!0KF>LE;:!.D!]9!f#;A>D>MJ6!E;F!)?B;6!<;!%BD/!+J>!%?>>LNA<=>!"J>AB?&!")'$#S#:+;%'$#9! f GHId!8B@AB;!.E?EAJB;!8BL5<;P@! w %?>@;A! &5ELE \ @!);@NB;@>9 g &;D<;>!=B!MD:! I`!,N?59!I!.E6!GHIQ9 J AAN@/ccXXX96BKAK5>9MBLcXEAMJo=vD=Kk;x<54%! $AKMT>6:!.E?6!#9!f">AJ<;T<;P!AJ>!"J>AB ?@;M6!E;F!%?>@;AAB??@AE;F<;P!+?EKLE!m!AJ>!"J>AB?MB=>?6/!,!(<@MBK?@>!,;ED6@<@!BC! SED<;P!]BK?;ED@!BC!3JYKED!,5K@>!$K?=<=B?@9! T"+).*%#"B#;:!49]9:!.9]9,9!$MJBKA?BN:!,9!2E;P>:!39.9!2BK<@:!E;F!]9#9.9!$D>P>?@9!f#CC>MA<=>!E;F! );>CC>MA<=>!1E6@!BC!1??<>;M>@/!,!xKED!$AKF69g! :89$>"!>&)*29#E& 8&*)$> # U9d!VIUUUW/!d`d ^ db H9!%(49 ! S><;P!1JEA!1>!7;BX/!(<@E5B?<>@!BC!.>AENJB?9u T"+).*%#"B# Q'!&)*)9#S#@+%!+)*%#D'8*;'%'!9#=!+/'&8 Q9I!VGHIHW/!dd ^ _Q9!% (49 ! 1<;FA:!+J>BFB?>!&AAB!]?9!f%?>@;AAB?C<;DF!BC!$AKF69g! @&.!)*%# =!*!&8#= 2&&$>#T"+).*%# d_!VIUbQW/!GQ ^ dQ9!%(49 ! 1<;@DBX:!"B@>LE?6!V*EA>@W 9!u+?BN<;P!+?EKLE/!3B;M><=<;P!VBCW!#YN>?<>;M>@!BC!$N>>MJD>@@! +>??B?9u T "+).*%#"B#!% BD?<;P!ELB;P! $BLEDAK?;>>@!<;!#AJ'*!)9 Gb9G!VGHHQW/!IbG ^ GHU9!%(49 !

PAGE 113

IH` kE?>C@T6:!(E=@;AAB?!%BX>?!BC!(>C<;