Citation
Using academic courses to generate data for use in evidence based library planning

Material Information

Title:
Using academic courses to generate data for use in evidence based library planning
Series Title:
The Journal of Academic Librarianship, VOL 39, ISSUE 3, 2013
Creator:
Brown-Sica, Margaret S.
Publisher:
The Journal of Academic Librarianship
Publication Date:
Physical Description:
Journal Article

Notes

Abstract:
The Auraria Library, which serves the University of Colorado Denver, Metropolitan State College of Denver and the Community College of Denver, collaborated with several academic courses on its campus to investigate some aspects of Participatory Action Research and Service Learning. The goal was to have students (the largest library user group) formulate questions, analyze data and provide suggestions that would help the library make evidence based decisions. The projects would provide student produced information that would be used to renovate the library. Unexpected benefits included the valuable relationships that developed between the Auraria Library, students and teaching faculty.
Acquisition:
Collected for University of Florida's Institutional Repository by the UFIR Self-Submittal tool. Submitted by Matthew Mariner.
Publication Status:
Published

Record Information

Source Institution:
Auraria Library
Holding Location:
Auraria Library
Rights Management:
All applicable rights reserved by the source institution and holding location.

Auraria Membership

Aggregations:
Auraria Library
Auraria Library Faculty Publications

Downloads

This item is only available as the following downloads:


Full Text

PAGE 1

! "NOTICE: this is the author's version of a work that was accepted for publication in The Journal of Academic Librarianship. Changes resulting from the publishing process, such as peer review, editing, corrections, structural formatting, and other quality control mechanisms may not be reflected in this document. Changes may have been made to this work since it was submitted for publication. A definitive version was subse quently published in The Journal of Academic Librarianship, [VOL 39, ISSUE 3, (2013)] D OI 10.1016/j.acalib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

PAGE 2

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
PAGE 3

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

PAGE 4

! ! X)>&'$!QB!%'/#) 2$/2&'$!=,88(+&0!751$'B

PAGE 5

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

PAGE 6

02(G$#589$'0!)40)9$!(49!5&20)9$!2#$!&4)1$'0)2,B!"#$!$I<$')$4/$!56!.5'G)4>!.)2#! 02&9$420!/(4!)40<)'$!/5??&4)2,!<'56$00)54(80!25!+$/5?$!?5'$!)41581$9!.)2#!2#$! &4)1$'0)2,!5'!8)+'(',!(0!9545'0-!158&42$$ '0!5'!<'5?52$'0B!7588(+5'(2)540!?(,!(805 #$8'(9&(2)54 SS 05?$2#)4>! &4)1$'0)2)$0!('$!)4/'$(0 )4>8,!/54/$'4$9!(+5&2!)4!'$>('9 25!4$.!6$9$'(8!)42$'$02!)4! <502 S >'(9&(2$!$?<85,?$42!'(2$0B! "#)0!('2)/8$!5&28)4$0 0$1$'(8!2,<$0!56!0$'1)/$ S +(0$9!8$('4)4>!<'5H$/20!(49!'$8(2$9!+$02!<'(/2)/$0B J *(,$'$9!*$('4)4>P!=2&9$42!7540&82(420!: $$< $4)4>!78(00'55?!(49!*)6$!* $00540 K! C755G S =(2#$'( -!MNQQD )4! 2#$! 57=$,<2&1,')4$<2&1)F0"0,-$% -! 9$0/')+$0!(!<'5H$/2!)4! .#)/# 02&9$420! .$'$!&0$9! (0!<$9(>5>)/(8!/540&82(420!25!6(/&82, B!"#)0!.(0!954$ (6 2$'!2#$!8(/G!56!02&9$42!)4<&2!)4 6(/&82,!9$1$85!$41)'54?$42D!(2!2#$!)402)2&2)54 B!"#$!('2)/8$!65885.0!(! <'5>'(?!/(88$9!2#$!%49'$.!`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b.)88! <'5+(+8,!+$! ?5'$!(<<8)/(+ 8$!25!?,!8)6$!(62$'![!>'(9&(2$BK C
PAGE 7

=$'1)/$!*$('4)4>!(49! @%A #(1$ /5??54!(22')+&2$0!(49!/5?<8$?$42!$(/#!52#$'! .$88B!"#)0!)9$(!)0!0&<<5' 2$9 )4!c[42'59&/2)54P!;5'$!2#(4!;$2#590 SS A$68$/2)540!54! @('2)/)<(25',!%/2)54!A$0$('/#!)4!Y $5>'(<#)/! "$(/#)4>-!*$('4)4>!(49!A$0$('/# c! C U)4954!(49!T8.559-!MNNO D B J`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d0!`$+!@'$0$4/$!(49!=$'1)/$0P! %!=2&9$42 S *)+'(',!7588(+5'(2)54!25!7'$(2$ 2#$!*)+'(',d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

PAGE 8

548,!+$4$6)2!&0$'0!.#5!#(9!?5+)8$!9$1)/$0B!30)4>!02&9$420!.(0!(!>559!(82$'4(2)1$! 25!&0)4>!<'56$00)54(8!2)?$!54!(!<'5H$/2!2#(2!?)>#2!452!#(1$!?(9$!)2!25!2#$!25! 2#$!02&9$42!<'5H$/2!8$(9$'!25!?()42()4!2#$!(<<8)/(2)54B C!@('24$'P!%!`)4 S `)4!7588(+5'(2)54!.)2#! =2&9$420!(49!X(/&82,c! C ;$,$'!(49 ;)88$'-!MNNR D-! 2#$!8)+'(',!02(66!(2!T(02$'4! `(0#)4>254!34)1$'0)2,!/588(+5'(2$9!.)2#!02&9$420!)4!(!2$/#4)/(8!/5??&4)/(2)54! /5&'0$!25!<'5?52$!(49!2$(/#!2#$!/)2(2)54!2558!A$6`5'G0B!"#$!02&9$420!.$42! 2#'5&>#!0$1$'(8!/,/8$0!56!<'5+8$?!0581)4>!+$65'$!2#$,!)9$42 )6)$9!2#$!?502! $66$/2)1$!/5??&4)/(2)54!02'(2$>,B!%62$'!2',)4>!0$1$'(8!5<2)540!2#$!02&9$420!65&49! 2#(2!2#$!?502!0&//$006&8! 02'(2$>,!65'!2$(/#)4>!(+5&2!A$6`5'G0!.(0!+,!2('>$2)4> <('2)/&8(' /5&'0$ 0 -!0<$/)6)/(88,! /5?<50)2)54!/5&'0 $0B!"#$!'$0&820 56! 2#$!<'5H$/2 .$'$!<50)2)1$B J"#$!A$6`5'G0!0$'1)/$ S 8$('4)4>!<'5H$/2!#(0!9'(?(2)/(88,!)4/'$(0$9! (.('$4$00!56!A$6`5'G0!(?54>!02&9$420B![4!]51$?+$'!MNNe-!.$!#(9!2.$42, S 6)1$! 4$.!A$6`5'G0!&0$'0!(49!2.$42,!'$2&'4)4>!&0$'0B!L4$!,$('!8(2$'-!)4!]51$?+$'! MNNV-!.$!#(9!M__!4$.!(49 Q_R!'$<$(2!&0$'0B!Z,!2#$!$49!56!6(88!MNNV! MV^!02&9$420! <('2)/)<(2$9!)4!2#$!02&9$42 S '&4!.5'G0#5<0B!"#&0-!)4/8&9)4>!2#$!6)62, S $)>#2! 2$/#4)/(8!/5??&4)/(2)54!02&9$420-!___!02&9$420!8$('4$9!#5.! 25!&0$!A$6`5'G0 K C ;$,$'!(49!;)88$'-!MNNR -!
PAGE 9

"#$'$!('$4W2!?(4,!('2)/8$0!54!2#$ 25<)/!56 2#$!1(8&$!56 $1)9$4/$ S +(0$9!9$/)0)54! ?(G)4>!(49!<8(44)4>!)4 8)+'(')$0B!"#$!54$!2#(2!)0!?502 '$8$1( 42 25!2#$!%&'(')(! <'5H$/2 )0!(!02&9, /#'54)/8$9!)4!2#$!H5&'4(8! 5>2701$0 C G,"07)/2?-,-#),17) H1*&-.,<2&1)!-,$<2$0) (+5&2!(4!$1)9$4/$!+(0$9!<8(44)4>! <'5/$00!65'!(!'$ S 9$0)>4!56! 8)+'(',!0<(/$0!/('')$9!5&2!+,!2#$!8)+'(')$0!(2!"$I(0!%f;!34)1$'0)2,!(49!"$I(0!%f;! \$(82#!=/)$4/$0!7$42$' !"" *)+'(',!$?<85,$$0!>(2#$'$9!$1)9$4/$!)4!2#$!65'?!56! (4! 548)4$!0&>>$02)54!+5I-!(!8)+'(',!/$40&0!C(0G)4>!8)+'(',!&0$'0!25!(40 .$'!0$1$'(8! E&$02)540!&<54!$42$')4>!2#$!8)+'(',!9&')4>!54$!9(,D" 2 #$ *)+g3%*hi!0&'1$, C(! 02(49('9)F$9! 8)+'(',!0$'1)/$0!0&'1$,!9$1$85<$9!+,!2#$!%/(9$?)/!(49!A$0$('/#! *)+'(',!9)1)0)54!56!2#$!%?$')/(4!*)+'(',!%005/)(2)54D-!.#)2$+5('9!6$$9+(/G -!+(8852! 152)4>-! (49!152)4>!+,!2$I2!?$00(>$ B "#$!02'$4>2#!56!2#)0!(<<'5(/#!.(0! )20!1(')$2,! 56!6$$9 +(/G!02'$(?0B!"#$!(&2#5'0!02(2$ J[ 6!548,!2#$!& 0$' S )4)2)(2$9!6$$9+(/G! /#(44$80!#(9!+$$4!&0$9-!2#$!<')5')2)$0!(99'$00$9!.5&89!#(1$!+$$4!0$(2)4>-! /5?<&2$'0-!<5.$'-!8)>#2)4>-!(4 9!6559j9')4G!<58)/,B!=$1$'(8!56!2#$!25'5&-!"B-!7('')(>(4!TB-!MNQM -!!#(9!+$$4!+&)82!)4!2#$! ?)9 S QOVNW0!65'!(!02&9$42!<5<&8(2)54!56!Q^-NNNB! "#$!/(?<&0!45.!0$'1$0!?5'$!2#(4! _^-NNN!02&9$420! C7585'(95!:$<('2?$42!56!T 9&/(2)54-!MNQM -! #22#$'$9B/585'(95B>51j)_j9$6(&82B(0!.(0!452!<500)+8$! 6)4(4/)(88,B![4!5'9$'!25!0$'1$!2#$!e-NNN!9()8,!1)0)25'0!)2!.(0!4$/$00(',!25 &<9(2$!2#$!

PAGE 10

0<(/$B "#$!<8(44)4>-!9(2(!>(2#$ ')4>j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

PAGE 11

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k(#4!5')>)4(88,!9$0)>4$9!2#$! 8)+'(',!+&) 89)4> B!=2&9$420!.$'$!05!$I/)2$9!+,!2#$!<'5H$/2!2#$,!'()0$9!?54$,! 2#$?0$81$0!25!2(G$!(!2')5!25!0$$!?5'$!56!k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a!0#5.0!(!2'(66)/!?(&'$0!e S R!0#5.!0&>>$02$9!)42$')5'!6855'!<8(40B! ;(4,! 02&9$420!0&>>$02$9!(!/#(4>$!)4!2#$!$42'(4/$!25!2#$!8)+'(',B! =5?$!2#5&>#2!2#(2! 2#$! $42'(4/$! 4$$9$9!25!+$!?5'$!0)>4)6)/(42-!25!/5??&4)/(2$!25!&0 $'0!.#$'$!25!$42$'!

PAGE 12

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

PAGE 13

! ! ! X)>&'$!MB!J@'5>'(?K!(4(8,0)0!56!2#$!%&'(')(!*)+'(',B

PAGE 14

! X)>&'$! _B!7(?<&0! 6552 S 2'(66)/!(4(8,0)0B

PAGE 15

! X)>&'$!aB!*5>)/(8!?(&'$!^B!J*5>)/(8K!?(
PAGE 16

! X)>&'$!eB!*)+'(',!6)'02!6855'!6855' S <8(4B

PAGE 17

! ! ! X)>&'$!VB!*)+'(',!6855' S <8(4B

PAGE 18

!

PAGE 19

!

PAGE 20

X)>&'$!RB!*)+'(',!6855' S <8(4B X)>&'$!OB J75F,K!0<(/$B

PAGE 21

X)>&'$!QNB!J75F,K!0<(/$B X)>&'$!QQB!J75F,K!0<(/$B !

PAGE 22

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

PAGE 23

9%2")$&=-"0)"=->0#")<%0)*20'7)&*)%=.,1)*,$<&-")01(2100-21()*&$="21()&1) 2701<2*#21()<%0)"<-01(<%"),17)'2.2<,<2&1")&*)%=.,1"@)21)&-70-)<& ) ,66'#) %=.,1)*,$<&-")70"2(1)6-21$26'0")21)&6<2.2I21()%=.,1)21<0-,$<2&1"):2<%)?&<%) .0$%,12$,'),17)01>2-&1.01<,')"#"<0."@),"):0''),"):&-;6',$0@)%&.0@),17) &<%0-)01>2-&1.01<"D)5.6%,"2")2")&1)<%0)217="<-2,'),66'2$,<2&1")&*)%=.,1) *,$<&-")70"2(1)6-21$26'0"),17)6" #$%&'&(2$,')-0"0,-$%)7,<,D ) ) C ;$2'5<58)2(4 =2(2$!7588$>$!56!:$41$'-!MNQM -! #22B?0/9B$9&j<'$1)$.l/5&'0$l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a /#50$!2#$)'!5.4!0&+H$/20 (62$'!0<$49)4>!2)?$!5+0$'1)4> &0$'!+$#(1)5' )4!2#$!8)+'(', B! =5?$!56!2#$!)00&$0!(99'$00$9!)4!2#$0$!<'5H$/20!('$P! 8)>#2)4>!)4!2#$! 8)+'(', CX)>&'$!Q_D -!4(1)>(2)54 CX)>&'$!QaD -!45)0$ CX)>&'$!Q^D -! 0$86 S /#$/G!5&2 CX)>&'$!QeD!(49!(!8)+'(', ?5+)8$!(<<8)/(2)54 CX) >&'$!QVD B! "#$!6(/2!2#(2! 02&9$420!<)/G$ 9!2#$0$!0&+H$/20!9$?5402'(2$0!2#(2!2#$0$!('$!<'5+8$?0!2#(2!8)+'(',! &0$'0!$4/5&4 2$'B!=5?$!56!2#$0$ -!0&/#!(0!8)>#2)4>-! 0&'<')0$9! 8)+'(',! $?<85,$$0 B "#$!

PAGE 24

02&9$420!)42'59&/$9!8)+'(')(40!25!L=\%!02(49('90!'$>('9)4>!8)>#2)4>B "#$,!(805! /546)'?$9!2#(2!45)0$!)0!(4!)00&$!(49!<&2!(!65'?!56!?$(0&'$?$42!54!)2B!"#$!65/&0! 54!0$86 S /#$/G!5&2!)49)/(2$9!2#(2!5&'!0,02$?!.(0!45 2!.5'G)4>!(49!2#(2!02&9$420! #(9!)9$(0!25! )?<'51$!)2B!%0!(!'$0&82 45)0$!(49!8)>#2)4>!#(1$!+$$4!?(G$!#)>#$'! <')5')2) $0!)4!'$451(2)54!<8(40!(49!2#$!8)+'(',!#(0!?(9$!0)>4)6)/(42!/#(4>$0!)4! 0$86 S /#$/G!5<2)540B !! X)>&'$!Q_B!*)+'(',!*)>#2)4>B !

PAGE 25

! X)>&'$!QaB!*)+'(',!](1)>(2)54 ! !

PAGE 26

! X)>&'$!Q^B!*)+'(',!]5)0$B ! ! !

PAGE 27

! X)>&'$!QeB!=$86 S /#$/G!)42$'6(/$!)?<'51$?$420B ! ! !

PAGE 28

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

PAGE 29

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a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j7588$>$!56!%'/#)2$/2&'$!(49!@8(44)4>!/588(+5'(2)54!)0 /&''$428,! 2(G)4>!<8(/$!25!'$451(2$!2#$!(2')&?0!(0!(!'$0&82!56!$('8)$'!<'5H$/20B!"#$'$!('$!<8(40! 65'!)?<'51)4>!2#$!9'()4(>$-!8(490 /(<)4>!(49!6&'4)2&'$!25!)4/'$(0$!&0(>$!56!2#$! 0<(/$B! !

PAGE 30

! X)>&'$!QOB!TI2$')5'!A$451(2)540B

PAGE 31

X)>&'$!QOB!:$0)>4!Y5(80B ! ! !

PAGE 32

X)>&'$!MNB!7&''$42!:$6)/)$4/)$0!56!2#$!*)+'(',!T42'(4/$B ! ! !

PAGE 33

X)>&'$!MQP!%2')&?!TI<(40)54B ! ! !

PAGE 34

X)>&'$! MMB!L4$!56!2#$!/&''$42!%2')&?0B ! ! !

PAGE 35

X)>&'$!M_B!Y'(49!T42'(4/$B ! ! !

PAGE 36

X)>&'$!Ma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

PAGE 37

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

PAGE 38

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j(/'8j)49$IB<#l:$0)>4PlA$05&'/ $0l65'l@8(44)4> D! .)G)! C %7A*j*%;%!:$0)>4)4>!=<(/$0!65'!\)>#$'!T 9&/(2)54!"(0G X5'/$ -!(//$00$9!QMjajMNQM D! ?()42()4$9!+,!2#$! %005/)(2)54!56! A$0$('/#!(49! 7588$>$!*)+'(')$0-!(!9)1)0)54!56!2#$!%?$')/(4!*)+'(',!%005/)(2)54-! 5&2 8)4$0!2#$! 65885.)4>!)00&$0!(0!/&''$42!/#(88$4>$0!)4!8)+'(',!9$0)>4P @'51)9)4>!(49!025')4>!)465'?(2)54!)4!(!?&82) 2&9$ 56!65'?(20!(49!1$4&$0 =25')4>!)465'?(2)54!)4!(!1(')$2,!56!.(,0 L<$4!1$'0&0!/850$9!02(/G0 A$?52$!025'(>$ %&25?(2)/!'$2')$1(8!0,02$?0 T41)'54?$42(8!/54/$'40 75?<8$I!+&)89)4>!&0$!<(22$'40! o 05?$2)?$0!MajV!(//$00 @'51)0)54!56!2'(9)2)54(8!0$'1)/$0!(49! $I<(49$9!0$'1)/$0!0&/#!(0!?$9)(! <'59&/2)54!(49!<'$0$42(2)54!6(/)8)2)$0 =2&9$420!(49!6(/&82,!.5'G)4>!)4!9)1$'0$!/588(+5'(2)1$!.(,0 @('24$'0#)<0!.)2#!52#$'!/(?<&0!0$'1)/$0!0&/#!(0!)465'?(2)54!2$/#4585>,!5'! /$42$'0!65'!2$(/#)4>!$I/$88$4/$ =2&9$42!(49!6(/&82,! $I<$/2(2)540!65'!'$8)(+8$-!<$'1(0)1$!2$/#4585>,

PAGE 39

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a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

PAGE 40

! @&7&4&*-&)' QB %7A*j*%;%!:$0)>4)4>!=<(/$0!X5'!\)>#$'!T9&/(2)54!"(0G!X5'/$B!CMNQM-! :$/$?+$'!aDB!A$2')$1$9!6'5?!%/(9$?)/!*)+'(',!Z&)89)4>!:$0)>4P!A$05&'/$0!65'! @8(44)4>!.$+0)2$P! #22j(/'8j)49$IB<#l:$0)>4PlA$05 &'/$0l65'l@8(44)4> MB %49$'?(4! T')/!;B!(49!*,48$,!\B!%49$'?(4 B CMNNODB! !"#$%&'&(#)&*) +',""-&&.)/0,121(3)41)51$#$'&6072,3)J&'=.0)K @ ) :$2'5 )2P!;(/?)88(4! A$6$'$4/$!3=%-! QQV S QQOB _B Z'5.4 S =)/( ;('>('$2 B CMNQMD! *)+'(',!=<(/$0!65'!3'+(4-!:)1$'0$-!75??&2$'! =2&9$420P!%!<('2)/) <(25',!%/2)54!A$0$('/#!@'5H$/2B +&''0(0),17)F0"0,-$%) /2?-,-20" @ ) LM ) NMO)NP,#O@ MQV S M_QB aB Z'5.4 S =)/(-!;('>('$ 2-!U('$4!=5+$8!(49!T')G(!A5>$'0B CMNQND! @('2)/)<(25',! %/2)54!A$0$('/#!)4!*$('4)4>!75??540!:$0)> 4!@8(44)4> D ) Q0:)/2?-,-#)R&-'7) KKK)NLSTO @ _NM S _QOB ^B 7585'(95!:$<('2?$42!56!\)>#$'!T9&/(2)54B!CMNQMD!7585'(95! :$<('2?$42!56 \)>#$'!T9&/(2)54!`$+0)2$! #22#$'$9B/585'(95B>51j)_j9$6(&82B(0'(1$-!(49!Z(0$$?(!ZB!U'G50G(B! CMNQND ;5+)8)F)4>!2#$! *)+'(',W0!`$+!@'$0$4/$!(49!=$'1)/$0P!%!=2&9$42 S *)+'(',! 7588(+5'(2)54!25!7'$(2$!2#$!*)+'(',d0!;5+) 8$!=)2$!(49!)@#54$!%<<8)/(2)54B 9%0) F0*0-01$0)/2?-,-2,1 @ ) UV)NK C VO)NW0$0.?0-)MXO@ MV S _^B!

PAGE 41

VB 755G S =(2#$'-!%8)054B!CMNQQD! *(,$'$9!8$('4)4>P!02&9$42!/540&82(420! 9$$< $4 )4>!/8(00'55?!(49!8)6$!8$00540B 57=$,<2&1,')4$<2&1)F0"0,-$%@ ) KYNKO) NP,-$%O@ ) aQ S ^VB! RB :(88)?5'$-!TB-!A5/#$65'2! :B!%B!(49!=)?54$88)-!UB!CMNQND 75??&4)2, S +(0$9! 8$('4)4>!(49!'$0$('/#B! Q0:)W2-0$<2&1")*&-)90,$%21(),17)/0,-121(@)VXKXNKVZO@ Q^ o MMB! OB \(88)4>-!"B-! 7('')(>(4!TB CMNQMD! ](1)>(2)4>!30$'!X$$9+(/G!7#(44$80!25!7#('2! (4!T1)9$4/$!Z(0$9!75&'0$!65'!*)+'(',!A$9$0)>4B! 5>2701$0)G,"07)/2?-,-#),17) H1*&-.,<2&1)!-,$<2$0@)Q&-<%)4.0-2$,@)NLO@ VN S RQB QNB X502 $'-!]B!XB-!f!Y)++540-!=B!CMNNVD [<=7#21( ) "<=701<"3)9%0)\170-(-,7=,<0) F0"0,-$%)!-&A0$<),<)<%0)\12>0-"2<#)&*)F&$%0"<0B!7#)/(>5P!%005/)(2)54!56! 7588$>$!(49!A$0$('/#!*)+'(')$0B QQB U)4954-!=('(-!(49!=('(#!T8.559B!CM NNOD! [42'59&/2)54P!;5'$!2#(4! ;$2#590 p A$68$/2)540!54!@('2)/)<(25',!%/2)54!A$0$('/#!)4!Y$5 >'(<#)/! $(/#)4>-!*$('4)4>!(49!A$0$('/#B ]&=-1,')&*)^0&(-,6%#)21)_2(%0-)57=$,<2&1@ ) MM)NKO)N],1=,-#O@ ) QO S _MB! QMB *(?G)4-!;B-!f!=(8$#-!%B!CMNQND %/2)54!'$0$('/#B![4!7B!U')9$8!CT9BD-! 51$#$'&6072,)&*)$=--2$='=.)"<=720"D C<< B!V S QNDB!"#5&0(49!L(G0P!=%YT! @&+8)/(2)540-![4/B! Q_B ;(085.-!%B!\B!CQOa_D!%!2#$5',!56!\&?(4!;52)1(2)54B! !"#$%&'&(2$,')F0>20: -! UXNZO@ _VN S OeB QaB ;$2'5<58)2(4!=2(2$! 7588$>$!56!:$41$'! C(//$00$9!L/25+$'!Q-! MNQM D #22B?0/9B$9&j<'$1)$.l/5&'0$l45<5
PAGE 42

Q^B ;$,$'-!](9$(4!kB-!(49![$88$$4!AB!;)88$'B! C MNNR D "#$!*)+'(',!(0!=$'1)/$ S *$('4)4>! @('24$'P!%!`)4 o `)4!7588(+5'( 2)54!.)2#!=2&9$420!(49!X(/&82,B +&''0(0)`) \170-(-,7=,<0)/2?-,-20" @ KU)NZO)NW0$0.?0-O@ _OO S aQ_B! QeB =5?$'1)88$-!;(',-!(49!;('>('$2! Z'5.4 S =)/( B CMNQQD *)+'(',!=<(/$!@8(44)4>P!%! @('2)/)< (25',!%/2)54!A$0$('/#!%<<'5(/# D ) 9%0)5'0$<-&12$)/2?-,-#)VY)NUO @ eeO S eRQB! QVB =2$'8)4>-!;(',B!CMNNVD! =$'1)/$ S *$('4)4>!(49 [42$')5'!:$0)>4P!%!7(0$!=2&9,B ]&=-1,')&*)5a60-201<2,') 57=$,<2&1@ ) VY __Q S _a_B!